StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

International Control in Private and Public Companies - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This paper gives a brief overview of the primary differences between internal control in private and public companies, the five components of internal control, why the frequency in which private companies test their internal control is much lower than for public companies and so on. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.7% of users find it useful
International Control in Private and Public Companies
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "International Control in Private and Public Companies"

One of the primary differences between internal control in private and public companies is that public companies are obligated by the SEC to comply with the mandates of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act (SOX) of 2002. Section 404 deals with management report on internal control over financial reporting. Based on section 404 public companies are required to provide a managerial assessment of internal control within its annual report. Section 404 also includes guidelines for design of internal control and operating effectiveness of controls. Private companies are exempt from compliance with the Sarbanes-Oxley Act. The internal controls of private companies vary depending on the size of the companies, the industry, and the expectations of the stakeholder groups. 2. The five components of internal control are control environment, risk assessment, control activities, information and communication, and monitoring. These five components are based on the COSO internal control framework. An effective control environment is required for the other four components to work effectively. For a control environment to be effective the executive managerial team must be committed to it. Identifying and evaluating risk is a critical component of any auditing work including internal control assessment. A good control environment makes it easier for the audit to detect and assess business risks. Based on SAS 94 most control activities related to policies and procedures are associated with segregation of duties, information processing, physical controls, and performance reviews. Information and communication between the auditors and the managers is required for an audit to be performed efficiently. Monitoring assesses the quality of an internal audit. The component that I selected for evaluation is information and communication. An audit problem associated with this component of internal control can be very problematic. As an auditor if I had problems with this component due to a lack of cooperation from the managerial staff I would resolve the problem by seeking the intervention of the board of directors of the company. 3. I agree with you that the frequency in which private companies test their internal control is much lower than for public companies. The two reasons for this occurrence is due to the legal requirements of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act and because private companies do not have as many stakeholder groups to satisfy. Public companies have to respond to lenders, suppliers, government, regulatory agencies, employees, investors, business partners, the community, and the environment. I think that private companies often disregard the importance of internal controls. This makes private companies more susceptible to fraud and illicit financial behavior. 4. I agree with you that the size of a company influences the need for internal controls. There are some private companies that move billions of dollars in revenues every year. Such companies should by their own initiative implement internal control standards similar to those used by public companies. When companies do not institute tough internal control mechanisms they are susceptible to financial fraud. Collusion among the managerial staff is more likely to occur in companies that do not perform proper internal audit and internal control mechanisms. In terms of small businesses sometimes internal audits are too costly. If costs of information exceed its benefits companies should not invest in acquiring that information. 5. As you mentioned in your response only public companies are required to comply with the Sarbanes-Oxley Act. One of the reasons that private companies cannot comply with SOX is because it is extremely costly to comply with the Act. I think that public companies have benefited a lot from the implementation of SOX. The accounting profession is now able to provide information that is more reliable that ever. Auditors must adequately control risks because risks that are not identified can hurt a company because the firm cannot implement remedial actions to manage the risk factor. 6. I agree with you that issues in the control environment should be dealt with by focusing on the top. The executive management team has a lot of influence over the control environment of a company. During the Enron case the control environment was non-existent since the top managerial team colluded to commit financial fraud. As you mentioned in your response often managers can change the tone of its control environment by altering its mission statement, value statements, and overall objectives. The internal control mechanism of a company should enable the company the ability to detect any wrongdoing. 7. In the case that a company was using security guards as a control mechanism to watch over the employees’ behavior a firm could ensure the quality of its laborers by running tight background checks on its security personnel. I think companies can benefit from incorporating technological tools to monitor employees. For instance the online surfing behavior of the employees can be monitored by incorporating encrypted passwords for each employee to access the information system of the company. There are software applications that can block certain websites which minimizes the unauthorized use of the internet for personal reasons. 8. I tend to agree with you that control activities are often a weakness or shortfall of many corporations. Many companies are exposed to a lot of unnecessary risks due to a lack of proper implementation of control mechanisms. Often the greatest threat to the financial assets of a company comes from within. A lack of documentation is a bad practice because it leaves the company without supporting evidence to track all the economic activity of a company. Corrupt managers utilize any weakness in a system to collude with other unethical employees in order to enrich their pockets. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“International Control in Private and Public Companies Essay”, n.d.)
International Control in Private and Public Companies Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/business/1442595-week
(International Control in Private and Public Companies Essay)
International Control in Private and Public Companies Essay. https://studentshare.org/business/1442595-week.
“International Control in Private and Public Companies Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/business/1442595-week.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF International Control in Private and Public Companies

The Importance of Legal Structures and Changes in Legal Systems

private and public companies tend to depend on economic forms of centralizing, organizing and operating capital and with the availability of the registration process from the acts of 1852 and 1882, and these companies could gain limited liability from the process.... The historical development of such companies is tied to several legal changes such as introduction of Company law and the Companies Act, Limited Liability Act, the Bubble phenomenon, the conceptual foundations of Company law and the importance of the share market, the private and public company differences, governmental support for such companies and the emergence of joint stock companies....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

The Department of the US Homeland Security

As the homeland security director in the United States, a list of recommended ways that will enable private and public stakeholders be prepared for, respond to, and recover from a possible terrorist attack on technological infrastructure facility will be tackled in details.... Aiming to protect public and private infrastructure from being attacked by terrorists, the concept of National Infrastructure Protection Plan (NIPP) together with its 18 supporting Sector-Specific Plans (SSPs) were publicly introduced in In general, a country with a publicly or privately owned critical infrastructure and key resources (CIKR) can be a possible target for a terrorist attack....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

PetroChina: International Corporate Governance with Chinese Characteristics

Despite an incredibly close relationship between the private and public sectors, shareholders seem to have an appropriate amount of control of PetroChina, and the publicly held CNPC seems to avoid exerting too much control.... Small Scale privatization, however, has and will continue to occur in a number of contexts, as private companies can usually be a cost-saving alternative for cash strapped local governments, especially in this time of economic recovery....
2 Pages (500 words) Case Study

Will Private Equity Overtake Public Equity

The author has pointed out to the difficulties in private and public equity markets.... However despite this sudden tax problem, which may have to be resolved by the BVCA, it is important to analyze why private equity firms have recently been more attractive than public equity firms and why has there been an exodus of top executives who moved from public companies to privately financed companies within the UK and indeed in many other emerging markets of the world....
44 Pages (11000 words) Term Paper

Public Policing Versus Private Security

This essay "Public Policing Versus Private Security" compares private security and public police that basically carry out different errands but the essential policing performed by them are mutually supportive, making law enforcement easier and effective.... nbsp;… Regardless of the common goals and duties of both private security and public policing, the latter has a much wider mandate than the former.... These personnel is not recruited by the government; instead, they are directly employed by security companies and public administration industries....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The Advantages of Private Sector and Low Carbon Projects

In the research paper “The Advantages of Private Sector and Low Carbon Projects” the author defines the private and public sector, which is an essential stage in understanding current practices and their role they are given in development policies.... public Sector consists of governments and all publicly controlled or publicly funded agencies, enterprises and other entities.... There is growing public revenue in low carbon projects, especially in developing countries....
13 Pages (3250 words) Research Proposal

Contracting Private Garbage Removal for Public Services

hellip; The National Environment Maintenance has different policies that ensure the works the private companies carry out are up to par to ensure residents of Maywood are living in environment-friendly conditions.... "Contracting Private Garbage Removal for public Services" paper argues that Solid Waste Management is still a major concern in different parts of the country.... There have been studies that give an indication of the cost of private service being lower as compared to the public service in the collection of household garbage and waste....
10 Pages (2500 words) Coursework

Public to Private Partnerships

hellip; Public-private partnership refers to a government service or private ventures financed and operated through a partnership of the central or federal government and one or more private sector companies.... Therefore, the public-private partnership is an official contract between the public and private companies.... The paper "public to Private Partnerships" examines the structure of this set of forms of interaction.... n other cases, the cost of the investment is borne exclusively by the private investor during the contract with the government on the provision of the specified services of public interest while the total cost of the project is borne by the government....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us