StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Whether Food Mart Stores Should Close - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The essay "Whether Food Mart Stores Should Close" focuses on the critical analysis of the dilemma of whether or not Food Mart Stores should close. A corporation is recognized as a distinct entity under the law. This means the operations of such an organization are delineated from individuals…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.4% of users find it useful
Whether Food Mart Stores Should Close
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Whether Food Mart Stores Should Close"

? Whether or not Food Mart Stores should close Number Whether or not Food Mart Stores should close A corporation is recognized as a distinct entity under the law. This means the operations of such an organization are delineated from individual(s) who established them. A corporation can be treated as a natural person in terms of rights and existence. The main features of a corporation are perpetual existence, limited liability and smooth transferability of assets and or interests. Any party that is willing to establish a corporation in the US is required by law to deposit a Certificate of Incorporation or Articles of Incorporation with the Secretary of State under whose jurisdiction the corporation will be established. The certificate must bear the signature of a sole incorporator, whose main objective is to establish the corporation. The Articles generally specify the name of the business, the chosen capital stock structure, the objective of the corporation, and the formal location of the headquarters and agent(s) of the corporation. After all that, the sole incorporator should formalize the appointment of the initial company directors by signing a consent document. Corporations such as Food Mart Stores are normally established to advance the business interests of the shareholders and cushion them against any liability. As such Smith owes a duty to the company’s stakeholders: the investors, directors, employees, and Stone Hill customers. Nonetheless, he is confronted with a delicate situation that could see the company make more profits by opening a bigger store farther away for the neighborhood at the expense of the locals. Different ethical theories manifest in this case study with regard to the impending decision on whether or not to close the store. Firstly, utilitarian ethical principle focuses on implementing ethical decisions that would maximize the good or value within the society while ensuring that the end result harms as few individuals as possible (Shaw, 2010). In this case, two issues prop up in the analysis of the best utilitarian action that Smith should take: on the one hand, the geriatrics who cannot carry heavy loads over long distances on foot make up about 10 percent of the population. Moreover, the average income of the lower-end segment in the neighborhood population depending on the Food Mart Store is $15,000, a figure that is lower than that of the city residents. On the other hand, Food Mart Stores and Smith face a gloom future if no action is taken to expand the store for stocking of a wide range of goods. With a gross income of a paltry 2%, the corporation’s operations could grind to a halt if it heeded the cry of the local population advocating for the retaining of the status quo, or worse still, engage in a costly renovation exercise whose returns on investment would be too little to imagine. Moreover, the future of Smith at the helm of the company hangs on the balance as the level of profits generated by the corporation continues to decline. Having done adequate research on the positive prospects of opening a larger store stocked with a variety of goods, it is ethical of Smith to press for the closure of the two smaller stores in order to pave way for the establishment of a bigger one that would guarantee all the stakeholders better outcomes. In essence, the new store will provide low prices on goods for patrons; and ensure higher profitability and continued existence to the benefit of all the stakeholders. A utilitarian-driven action by Smith would definitely cause suffering to the old residents of Stone Hill, however their suffering would be insignificant because they are a paltry10 percent of the population. The poorer residents have reasonable incomes (of $15,000) which would enable them to adjust if a new store was established a few miles away from the neighborhood. Secondly, a rights ethical principle comes to fore in this dilemma. It is premised upon the notion that all stakeholders in a company have rights which should be respected across board. This implies that all stakeholders should be accorded due respect and dignity in the handling of business operations including restructuring. Whereas the closure of the Food Stores in Stone Hill area will practically deny the locals the right to access foodstuff more easily because other outlets had closed shop under stiff competition from the company, Food Mart Stores was not solely responsible for the monopoly. The corporation did not impose their missions, commodities, or systems on the local consumers. Similarly, the corporation’s activities have no bearing on investors who might want to open doors in the area. As things stand now, it is evident that the shareholders will feel the pinch of shrinking profits which have decreased to a low of 2%. The company’s entire leadership owes a significant obligation to the shareholders, a role which is the manifested in the consolidation of profits or the running of a viable corporation. Failure to observe the shareholder value, the customers and prospects as well as the interests of Smith whose continued engagement with the company is in jeopardy results in the contravention of the third ethical principle – justice or fairness. As Shaw (2010) indicates, fairness is an ethical theory that requires the treatment of all parties equally. In this case, customer’s age, income earnings, class and proximity to the store do not count. After all, the current location of the Food Store is far away from some customers and prospects. Besides, at any given time, not all stores can be closer to all the members of a society. In light of fairness, it would be fair for all stakeholders to continue enjoying the existence of the company. Lastly, common good is as ethical principle that supports the closure of Food Mart Stores in Stone Hill neighborhood. This theory attempts to foster the common values that all the stakeholders are set to enjoy should the corporation carry out the planned restructuring of its operations. The shareholders would be guaranteed a steady income from the company occasioned by a diverse stock. Customers would enjoy a wider variety of goods and services in a larger store at low prices. Mr. Smith’s performance would be felt and; the employees would also stand to gain from the expansion program by gaining better workplace conditions. These are clear indications that the standard, rational decision which embraces the common good rests in the closure and transfer of the Food Mart Stores from its current location to a bigger premise rather than on meeting the interests of the few senior citizens and poorer members living in the neighborhood (Shaw, 2010). According to Immanuel Kant, a standard of rationality dictates the moral requirements in society. Like in most corporate organizations whose continued existence are threatened by dwindling sales, restructuring is not only moral but standard. In this case, Kantian philosophy supports the closure of the smaller stores in favour of a larger one because the current ones have proved unviable. Besides, any form of renovation has been proven to be of little if any positive impact on profits. Despite the need to close the two stores, the action will leave the locals with no other option. This might result in the store losing some of its loyal customers. Moreover, new investors or those that had been in the market but had been forced out under stiff competition might establish new stores or make a comeback in to the area respectively. On the contrary, if the store were to remain open, the society would develop more trust in the corporation and earn it more customer loyalty. A continued existence of the store hangs on the balance by virtue of the low profits. In light of this, it would close at some point leaving the customers with no option. In my view, there cannot be a compromise because the corporate mission of making profit contradicts the interests of the residents of Stone Hill neighbourhood who want easily accessible foodstuff at low prices. Perhaps, the only compromise would be the locals agreeing to sell a piece of land to the store owners to facilitate the construction of a larger store in the area. Reference Shaw, W.H. (2010). Business Ethics: A Textbook With Cases: A Textbook with Cases. New York: Cengage Learning. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Debate Paper Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Debate Paper Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/business/1487579-debate-paper
(Debate Paper Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
Debate Paper Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words. https://studentshare.org/business/1487579-debate-paper.
“Debate Paper Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/business/1487579-debate-paper.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Whether Food Mart Stores Should Close

Company analysis on Dollar General Stores expanding into Britian

This paper intends to analyze the scope of Dollar General stores' expansion to Britain.... The corporation operated over 9,300 stores in 35 US states as per the data of January 2011.... Generally, the Dollar General stores are located in small shopping plazas and it typically deals with communities that are too small for Wal-Mart.... Within two years of it business commencement, the organization earned an annual sales of $5 million from its 29 stores....
14 Pages (3500 words) Research Paper

How Distance Impacts Products Price

The research "How Distance Impacts Products Price" focuses on gathering primary information including the food prices taken from three US food stores.... Specifically, the researcher gathers the food price data from the three food stores' online shelves.... The three competing food stores are Wal-Mart food store, Netgrocer food store, and Netfoodex.... The institute explains that the food stores must generate profits in order to stay in business....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

Wallmart (Global Economy, Global Competition)

t started from a single Wal-Mart discount store but today, there are 629 stores The size of an average store is 108,000 square feet.... The company has continued to grow rapidly after his death in 1992 and now operates four retail divisions; Wal-Mart Supercenters, Wal-Mart discount stores, Neighborhood Market stores and Sams Club warehouses (New York Times, 2012).... Wal-mart Supercenters were developed in 1988 to meet the growing demand for convenient, one-stop family shopping....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Wall Mart Mission

This paper ''Wall mart Mission'' tells us that the company's mission and vision provide a tool for communicating the company's purpose and its entire values to the major shareholders (Bonaich, 2004).... Customers of Wall-mart are, therefore, the most influential stakeholders of the company.... Employees of Wall-mart are highly treasured since they are the ones selling and marketing the products to consumers (Bonaich, 2004).... al-mart has a unique, competitive environment....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Organization details

Organizational structure no doubt is contributory to an efficient operation of a company, much more when it needs to operate several chain stores in different.... om/companies/wal-mart-stores/) Wal-Mart is a global company selling goods in 15 countries and has 8,500 stores of 55 different names.... Study found out that Divisional Structure works well in this kind of set-up and Wal-mart has been effectively using this for many years in its operations....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Walmart. Final project

As such, Wal-Mart is required to develop new stores to accommodate fully its strengths concentrated in urban areas.... The paper will also examine the current strategic issues facing Wal-mart and their construction solutions.... al-mart is an international company that provides home-based products at affordable prices.... al-mart is a large wholesale distributor in the world that can afford modern construction technologies.... Owing to its large influence on the market, Wal-mart has the potential to replicate its best architectural techniques in all its stalls across the world (Roberts & Berg, 40)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Lab Report

Is Walmart Good for the Economy and Bad for Workers

Walmart stores are popular in the US through their provision of low prices and variety in products that they sell.... The author takes into account whether Walmart is good for the economy and bad for workers or bad for both, it depends on an individual's view on what the varied impacts of Walmart are relevant to one.... The paper will go further to evaluate and provide a conclusion on whether Walmart is beneficial for the economy and bad for workers or if it is bad for both....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Sam Walton Management

Sam was a unique individual and one of the successful entrepreneurs in history since his enterprise continues to grow with almost 7000 stores.... Sam was a unique individual and one of the successful entrepreneurs in history since his enterprise continues to grow with almost 7000 stores across the globe employing about 2 million employees.... Sam was a unique individual and one of the successful entrepreneurs in history since his enterprise continues to grow with almost 7000 stores across the globe employing about 2 million employees making Wal-Mart a global force....
12 Pages (3000 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us