StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Business Ethics: Hewlett Packard - Case Study Example

Summary
This case study "Business Ethics: Hewlett Packard" presents a corporation that is engaged in the business of information technology all across the world. The company is dexterous in manufacturing, assembling, and selling personal computers, computer accessories, and software…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93% of users find it useful
Business Ethics: Hewlett Packard
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Business Ethics: Hewlett Packard"

ASSIGNMENT Introduction to Hewlett Packard: Hewlett Packard is a United s based corporation that is engaged in the business of information technology all across the world. The company is dexterous in manufacturing, assembling and selling of personal computers, computer accessories and softwares, scanners, storage devices, various types of printers including desktop, laser, ink jet, plotters etc, home servers, monitors, calculators and handhelds, laptops, mini notebooks and computer services. The corporation has established a global sales and business network, has sound market reputation, goodwill and consumer acceptance. It is the first IT corporation that achieved a landmark of over 100$ billion sales in a year that showcase its financial, managerial and marketing strength in comparison to its major global competitors including Dell, Apple, IBM etc. The company merged with Compaq in 2002 that further intensified its strength and business position among the rivals. Business Case: This paper aims to throw light over a scandal that involved the corporation’s board chairperson Ms. Patricia Dunn and an outside investigative firm in an attempt to determine who among the company’s directors leaked the company’s secret information discussed in a board meeting to the media personnel. The board meeting was originally held to discuss the sensitive issues faced by HP at that time, however, an online technology site CNET published an online article about ‘the long-term strategic plans of HP’ that contained sensitive information that could only be revealed or disclosed by a director or any other well-informed top executive. This further endorsed the fact that someone at the top was deliberately engaged in publicizing the information about Hewlett Packard’s would-be strategies. This act of irresponsibility would have sabotaged the corporation’s long-term objectives and interests by making the rivals aware of company’s policies well-before time. The CEO Carly Fiorina scolded the board of directors but failed to figure out the person behind the game. She was later ousted from HP and was replaced by Mark Hurd and the chairperson Patricia had initiated the move to find the culprit hiring private investigators to determine the source of those leaks. (Krazit, 2006) More specifically, the investigative firm employed the controversial in fact an illicit technique of Pretexting (which means to sham one’s original identity in order to gain access to someone else’s private information such as phone numbers, social security numbers, credit card and bank account details etc. It is, more precisely, viewed as an attempt to fraud or cheat another person through misleading) to determine who was responsible for that information leak to Wall Street Journal and others. The detectives namely Ronald DeLia, Matthew Depante and Bryan Wagner not only indulged in spying on the phone records of directors but also disguised themselves as directors to track down their own records. They also spied the records of nine journalists who were working at The New York Times and Wall Street Journal during 2005. In addition, when Mr. Hunkaser (HP senior council responsible) inquired Mr. Gentilucci (HP global security officer) about the legitimacy of Pretexting, Ronald DeLia confidently replied that the activity had not called illegal by any ‘Federal laws’ which was absolutely false since Pretexting is illegitimate exercise. (Jennings, 2008) However, the investigative firm successfully identified Mr. Keyworth as the leaker of information who was then forced to resign. The case finally led to criminal charges against the board’s chairperson Ms. Petricia Dunn, Mr. Hunkaser, Ronald DeLia and Matthew Depante. Ms. Dunn at last survived from those accusations but forced to resign to completely settle down the dispute that ‘threatened to derail the Silicon Valley icons momentum’ after the ouster of high-profile CEO Carly Fiorina. (Krazit, 2006) Ethical Considerations: This case is very rich when we talk about ethical concepts and considerations. Basically, the ethical issue as concluded from the above summary of this case is the fact that directors, employees and journalists were misguided by the people within and outside of HP. In simple words, the privacy rights of an individual were violated besides the state law. But the question that I would be focusing on is should Patricia Dunn be forced to resign and was that ethically correct or not? First of all, it was Mr. Hunkaser who confirmed about the legitimacy of the investigative technique after receiving the reply from Ronald. Ms. Petricia Dunn endorsed the idea to discover the director who revealed the confidential information through private investigators, mainly because she believed it was destructive for HP and ‘it destroyed the trust between people and if they don’t trust each other, they can’t function as a board.’ (Schorn, 2006) Actually, Petricia Dunn was of the view that confidential information about the company’s long-term strategies related to products, changes in management and organizational structure and culture, budgeting and forecasting, market potential, internal disputes, monetary and volumetric sales targets, expected mergers and acquisitions could make the major rivals of the HP such as Dell, Apple, IBM and others aware of the ongoing policies who would then replicate, alter, adjust, innovate and improve their policies, strategies, internal organizational strengths and weaknesses to get a competitive advantage over Hewlett Packard. Obviously, this would be destructive for the accomplishment of both short-term and long-term goals and would compel HP to revise all the policies and strategies since they would no longer be useful and effective than they were before the leak. This shows that Petricia was loyal to her company since she took that initiative in better interest of the corporation and its employees because they would have been the direct affectees if HP had failed to come up with new effective decisions that could facilitate the company in competing with its competitors. Petricia’s initiative to nail the leaker was in greater corporation’s interest despite the fact the leaker was discovered through the employment of some inappropriate techniques and tactics. According to Utilitarian theory, the alternative that yields the greatest benefit to the majority is the alternative that is ethically correct and that must be used. One benefit of this ethical theory is that the utilitarian can compare similar predicted solutions and use a point system to determine which choice is more beneficial for more people. This point system provides a logical and rational argument for each decision and allows a person to use it depending on the context and situation. Based on the above explanation of theory, we could say that Petricia Dunn’s decision was in favor of her corporation and its employees so she was interested in her company’s survival and growth which would result in more jobs opportunities and economic well-being of her country. As far as the employment of Pretexting is concerned, it was quite truly unethical and a violation of privacy rights. Yet, it must not be forgotten that the detectives had no option other than Pretexting in that organizational settings for reasons such as reluctance of the director to accept his blunder, chances of retaliation by employees who might not support the investigation process and would lose trust over its top management. Therefore, the detectives had to use that technique to determine the culprit behind the scenario. Similarly, Ms. Petricia should have not been forced to resign from her position of being a chairperson because she did everything in favor of HP and her sin for allowing detectives to use Pretexting as a technique could have been forgiven by the board after comparing the fact that benefits from her decision to secure HP were greater than the costs of employing Pretexting as a technique to achieve the results. References Schorn, Daniel. (2006). “Patricia Dunn: I Am Innocent”. Cbsnews.com Available at http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2006/10/05/60minutes/main2069430.shtml Gonsalves, Antone. (2008) “HP Settles Spying Case With N.Y. Times, BusinessWeek Reporters.” InformationWeek Available at http://www.informationweek.com/news/globalcio/showArticle.jhtml?articleID=206504249   Wong, Grace (2006). “Now, HP is a criminal case” Money.cnn. Available at http://money.cnn.com/2006/10/05/news/companies/hp_california/index.htm Krazit, Tom (2006). “FAQ: The HP pretexting scandal” News.cnet Available at http://news.cnet.com/FAQ-The-HP-pretexting-scandal/2100-1014_3-6113011.html Jennings, Marianne Moody (2008). “Business Ethics: Case Studies and Selected Readings”. Pp. 184-187 Available at http://books.google.com.pk/books?id=nWZSKxfVVYIC&pg=PA184&dq=Peter+Dunn+case+of+Pretexting+at+HP&cd=1#v=onepage&q=Peter%20Dunn%20case%20of%20Pretexting%20at%20HP&f=false Read More

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Business Ethics: Hewlett Packard

Hewlett-Packard (HP)

The services of Hewlett-Packard comprise of imaging along with printing services, computing systems as well as information technology services required for personal use and business (Lynn, “Trading Idea - Momentum Building in hewlett packard”).... Hewlett-packard (HP) Table of Contents 1.... Product and/or Service Hewlett-packard develops such products that may be easily accessible globally....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

How Positive Leadership Can Be Reinforced: Helwet-Packard Company

The paper 'How Positive Leadership Can Be Reinforced: Helwet-packard Company' focuses on the case involving the merger of Hewlett-packard Company (NYSE: HWP) and Compaq Computer Corporation (NYSE: CPQ) which was intended to build an $87 billion global technology leader (Palo & Houston, 2001).... As such, this study focuses on the case involving the merger of Hewlett-packard Company (NYSE: HWP) and Compaq Computer Corporation (NYSE: CPQ) which was intended to build an $87 billion global technology leader (Palo & Houston, 2001)....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Proposal

The Gradual Development of Hewett Packard

ackground Analysis of Hewett Packard & Carly Fiorina hewlett packard (HP) is an American multinational company, which is headquartered in California, United States (Hewett Packard, 2013a).... This essay "The Gradual Development of Hewett packard" is about details regarding the background and as a company and Carly Fiorina as the Chief Executive Officer.... The author of the study will highlight the present scenario of Hewett packard under the managerial control of Carly Fiorina and its impact on business activities....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

The Supply Change Management Practices at Hewlett-Packard

The paper "The Supply Change Management Practices at Hewlett-packard" states that according to the HP website, it sells two types of contracts: HP Direct Contracts and HP Partner contracts.... Hewlett-packard encourages its supplier or contractor to contact its support in case they require any information regarding the legalities and other issues.... History and Background of the Organization Hewlett-packard Company (HP) were founded in 1939 by Stanford University students Bill Hewlett and Dave packard (Hewlett-packard 2013)....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Corporate Code of Conduct

hewlett packard Sales for 2004 was $79.... hewlett packard is now facing off and accelerating its business weapons to topple the higher ranked competitor called with IBM in order to be acknowledged as one of the best in the realm of world's largest technology vendor in terms of sales.... hewlett packard has finally, after many years of painstaking hard work, has been recognized as the No.... hewlett packard has been implementing the best practices in its environment....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Normative Ethics In Hewlett Packard

Patricia Dunn the former chairman of hewlett packard has been known for bringing about a strong improvement in the working of hewlett packard.... But the paper "Normative Ethics In hewlett packard" discusses the case of a breach of the code of conduct of the company by Patricia Dunn....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Case Analysis on Human Resources at Hewlett Packard

Such high quality products have to come from an equally high standard in HRM practices adopted and led by managers HP Way in conducting its business is based on a set of ethical principles.... Human resources at HP are evaluated on the basis of innovation, independent thinking, mutual trust and uninhibited contribution. ...
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

HP Settles Spying Case with N.Y. Times

The researcher of this essay will make an earnest attempt to discuss the famous business scandal that took place 4 years back in 2005 - 2006 when famous board chairperson of hewlett packard named board Ms.... This research will begin with the statement that hewlett packard (HP), which is an American multinational corporation, has been involved in the global business of computer products, accessories, instruments and information technology equipment that facilitate in communication, networking, office work and record keeping of business operations....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us