StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Towards the Understanding of the Strategic Intent by Hamel and Prahalad - Assignment Example

Cite this document
Summary
This paper "Towards the Understanding of the Strategic Intent by Hamel and Prahalad" focuses on the article, which will be analysed in light of a perspective of strategic management and in the rest of the parts, its weakness, strength, convincing and unconvincing factors will be exhibited. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.7% of users find it useful
Towards the Understanding of the Strategic Intent by Hamel and Prahalad
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Towards the Understanding of the Strategic Intent by Hamel and Prahalad"

Critical Review of the Article “Hamel, G. and Prahalad, C. K. (1989) Strategic Intent in Harvard Business Review, May-June” Table of Contents Table of Contents 2 Overview 3 Whittington’s 4 Schools of Strategy 3 Theoretical Underpinnings 5 Strengths of the Article 5 Weakness of the Article 7 Convincing Content of the Article 7 Unconvincing Content of the Article 8 References 9 Bibliography 10 Overview In this paper, an article written by Gary Hamel and C. K. Prahalad will be reviewed. Basically the article has been written on strategic intent but it has covered many of the related topics. At the very first stage, article will be analysed in light of a perspective of strategic management and in the rest of the parts, its weakness, strength, convincing and unconvincing factors will be exhibited. Whittington’s 4 Schools of Strategy Before linking the approaches to the Whittington’s 4 schools of strategy with the particular article, it needs to be understood that what the Whittington’s strategies imply. The four schools of thoughts can be discussed one by one. Classical Approach to Strategy: As per the view of the Whittington, the prime objective of the business according to the classists is the profitability. Following this strategy it can be said that the strategic aim of a business should be earning more profits and in case of unsatisfactory results, a corrective measure need to be taken. Even the activity which is responsible for that result can be abandoned. Evolutionary Approach on Strategy: It refers that there is no need to rely upon the top management’s ability to develop a strategy and act accordingly. As per this approach, profit maximisation is determined by the market not managers. It further denotes that only the best performer can survive in the market and the weaker ones are turned out of the market. Processual Approach to Strategy: This approach neither follows the classical approach nor agrees with evolutionary approach. It denotes that instead of striving for the ideal, it needs to handle the reality offers. This theory further implies that rational economic cannot be expected as it is not able to consider all the factors simultaneously. Systemic Approach on Strategy: According to the systemic theorists, organisation is capable enough to plan and act effectively and economic activity can not be estranged from the social relations. It implies that organisation is not only a combination of individuals but also of social factors (Cuizon, 2009). Basically classical and evolutionary approach has been considered under the prescriptive approach where the other two can be taken as the emergent approach. Again both the classical and evolutionary approach can be functional in the economic field where processual and systematic approach can be applied in psychology and sociology respectively (Macmillan & Tamppoe, 2000). From the understanding of the above mentioned theory and the article, it can be accomplished that the approaches which have been implemented in this article can be considered under the processual approach since the authors emphasise more on the strategy development as per the present condition of the organisation and not on the basis of profit motive or management concern. Theoretical Underpinnings In this article, the authors have considered certain assumptions. They have demonstrated the entire article in perspective of few specific instances. In the initial stage of this article, it has been found that the authors have adopted a comparative analysis among the companies between United States of America and Japan. They further describe the strategy of those companies to boost up their internal and external policies in order to gain the competitive advantages. Mostly they stick to the explanations of the growth study of Japanese companies in comparison to the American companies in the worldwide perspective, as they stated the expansion strategies in Asia and Europe market. From the overall understanding of the article, it has been observed that the analysis of all the theories and the assessment of the strategies have been made in respect of few organisations instead of the business environment. It can be argued that though the authors has brought into light entry strategies of the organisations of Japan and America, but they does not consider any companies that originated from different countries. Therefore, it can be considered that to some extent the authors have measured a restrictive world view. Regarding the presence of logic, this article can be rated as a rational piece as each and every strategy and policy have been justified with respect to the theoretical and practical perspectives. Strengths of the Article The main focus of the article is on the strategic intent and the authors have represented it in a very systematic way. Now the merits of this article can be described. First of all it has been found that the authors have undertaken a global perspective to analyse the topic. It is not only helpful to conceptualise ‘strategic intent’ in a broad perspective but also to build up a comparative analysis and develop a well built concept out of that. Secondly, they had started their discussion with a comparative analysis of mainly two countries and those are America and Japan. They make it clear that how the Japanese companies modify their strategies and become capable enough to provide a tough competition to their American competitors. This is a part of the article but somehow denotes that how a feeble company can boost up and can gain competitive advantages. The article has been ornamented with certain assumptions which have been supported by few theories. Similarly, it has also been found that certain theories have been linked with the core topic and again those have been justified through practical instances. A separate part has been attached with article which deals with the strategy development and its implication on organisations. That portion of the article does not interrupt the flow of the discussion but has bestowed a well structured causal effect of different strategies which has further supported all the assumptions considered for the article. Apart from all these, the authors had exhibited the process and history of building up the competitive advantages of Komatsu through different passages of time. The most important aspect is that Hamel and Prahalad have explained all the supporting aspects of the core topic i.e. the strategic intent. These are leadership position, strategic planning, and developing strategic decisions such as joint venture, mergers and others, effect of technological resources, strategic business unit and strategic hierarchies. Critical analysis of these topics further enable the reader to enhance their understanding with regard to what extent strategic extent is useful and what affects it has on the organisational level. Throughout the entire discussion in the article, the authors have cited few examples of various companies across the world which has built up an in-depth understanding with the topic. Moreover the surrender process has also been described which is relative to the core topic. All these efforts and explanations have added value to the article and makes it more effective for the readers. Weakness of the Article First of all, the thorough discussion prevalent in this article can make it monotonous. It should have encompassed or it can be said that it could have ornamented with more headings and subheadings which can make the topics more prominent to the reader. Focusing more on two particular nations, America and Japan; somehow make certain portion of the article profligately specific. That has restricted the discussion flow. It could have been better if the authors considered five or six companies from different origins and continue the discussion in respect of different aspects. Thus, the effect of each strategy can be precise and clear to the reader. Convincing Content of the Article Basically in an article, the convincing factors are those assumptions which can satisfy the demand of the reader or in simple words it can be stated as those assumptions or statement whose outcomes are expected to the reader. Even it differs from reader to reader. According to me, the most convincing content is the recommendation of developing a competitor’s focus at each and every level and across the organisation. As per my opinion, human resource plays a significant role not only in the production but also in every department. It is also evident that at the era of artificial intelligence, significance of the human resource prevails. Therefore, they should be trained properly as stated in the article. To motivate them a well built reward system should also be there. Eventually after all these effort performance level of the employees need to be measured, which can be better achieved through the policy stated in the article. This refers to set the benchmark as per the best-in-class competitors. Unconvincing Content of the Article Unconvincing statement or assumptions are those which can not satisfy the expectations of the reader or rather, which differs from the reader’s perceptions. In this article, one assumption has differed from mine set of perception. According to the article, an organisation should be given time to assimilate a challenge before launching other. Disagreeing with the statement, I would like to state that a new product line or newly launched product or services can share the burden of a challenge or loss. Even it can be set off with the profit or success of newly launched product. As per the real scenario, the employees of an organisation can get panicked during the crisis of the organisation and this can be discarded through reducing the possibilities of fatal scenarios. I agree that launching of new product is another hectic process as it needs to set a specific objective, check proper execution of the launching process, disseminates best practice and others. But again it set off the load of challenges (Sachs, 2009). References Cuizon, G., 2009. Theories of Action in Business Strategy. Content. [Online] Available at: http://www.suite101.com/content/theories-of-action-in-business-strategy-a94410 [Accessed November 08, 2010]. Macmillan & Tampoe, 2000. Whittington’s 4 Generic Approaches to Strategy. Strategic Management. [Online] Available at: http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:-KXqfbkHe2kJ:www.oup.com/uk/orc/bin/9780198782292/freelecturer/ppts/ch03.ppt+Whittington%E2%80%99s+4+schools+of+strategy&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=in [Accessed November 08, 2010]. Sachs, R. M., 2009. How to Effectively Launch New Products. RMR. [Online] Available at: http://www.rmr.com/marketingtips.asp?nid=357&lid=1 [Accessed November 08, 2010]. Bibliography Hamel, G. & Prahalad, C. K., 1989. Strategic Intent. Harvard Business Review. Nelson, R. R. & Winter, S. G., 1982. An Evolutionary Theory of Economic Change. Harvard University Press. Rivani, D., No Date. An Overview of Strategy Development Models and the Ward-Rivani Model. Papers. [Online] Available at: http://129.3.20.41/eps/get/papers/0506/0506002.pdf [Accessed November 08, 2010]. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Towards the Understanding of the Strategic Intent by Hamel and Prahala Assignment, n.d.)
Towards the Understanding of the Strategic Intent by Hamel and Prahala Assignment. https://studentshare.org/business/1744349-critical-review-of-the-article-hamel-g-and-prahalad-c-k-1989-strategic-intent-in-harvard-business-review-may-june
(Towards the Understanding of the Strategic Intent by Hamel and Prahala Assignment)
Towards the Understanding of the Strategic Intent by Hamel and Prahala Assignment. https://studentshare.org/business/1744349-critical-review-of-the-article-hamel-g-and-prahalad-c-k-1989-strategic-intent-in-harvard-business-review-may-june.
“Towards the Understanding of the Strategic Intent by Hamel and Prahala Assignment”. https://studentshare.org/business/1744349-critical-review-of-the-article-hamel-g-and-prahalad-c-k-1989-strategic-intent-in-harvard-business-review-may-june.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Towards the Understanding of the Strategic Intent by Hamel and Prahalad

Business Operations and Systems

According to authors hamel and prahalad, resource leverage is defined as doing more (or adding more value) with what you have (hamel and prahalad, 1966 cited in Morden, 2007, p.... Authors hamel and Prahlad conceptualized the enterprise as a portfolio of knowledge, assets and resources and competencies.... Business Operations and Systems Table of Contents Table of Contents 2 Managerial qualities and Resource utilization 3 Balanced Scorecard (BSC) 4 Conclusion 6 References 6 Managerial qualities and Resource utilization The successful implementation of an effective business model depends upon the strategic analysis conducted by the manager....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Critical review from an Business Strategy Article

hellip; The core competencies strategy, amongst all the other strategies that the management of different organisations may apply, emerges as superior, according to Hamel & prahalad (1990 p80).... The core competencies strategy makes the exploitation of opportunities more viable, and thus sets an organisation on the path of growth, in terms of size, sales and revenues/ Therefore, the concept of core competencies as an application strategy for businesses, require advanced focus and learning the trends and change within an industry, and then identifying one or a few areas of the changing trends that are likely to merge, then working towards producing a product that serves that exact merging point of need (prahalad & Hamel, 80)....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Real Strategies for Virtual Organizing by N. Venkatraman and John C. Henderson

The paper centers on harmony among three vectors: Customer interaction, asset sourcing, and knowledge leverage and a strong Information Technology (IT) platform laying their arguments on the premise that, the current model of strategy and structure are woefully inadequate to… The researchers rejected the virtual organization as a distinct structure and instead treat virtualness as a strategic characteristics common to every organization....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Self-organization in complex systems

In order for a company to create value, it has to provide unique experiences with its consumers by the way it transacts with it.... Personalization is key to creating this unique experience.... With the advancement of technology, personalization is made more possible to companies without incurring high costs....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

U04d1 Critique Case

The main topic of focus here for this paper is the importance that… The main trend that firms follow is to work with the management and work towards reaching the strategic position and work towards better and improved governance within the company (Mill, 1995).... The main trend that firms follow is to work with the management and work towards reaching the strategic position and work towards better and improved governance within the company (Mill, 1995)....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Communication strategy using technology

They have got a role in the inter-organizational networks like the industrial districts and knowledge networks (hamel and prahalad, 1990).... & prahalad, G.... Technology has played a great role in the advancement of communication everywhere.... During the past decade, organizations had to face dynamic markets and had to be specified by… So it was important for them to use the new and upcoming technology to keep them up graded and up dated....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment

Analysis of Strategy as Revolution Article by Hamel

Not only does the company make the employees a part of the strategic direction it is taking, but it also shifts its own strategy to match the ideas of the employees.... In this manner, the projects the employees work on become a part of the strategic path taken by the company as recommended by Gardiner (2005).... The "Analysis of Strategy as Revolution Article by hamel" paper analyzes the article which contains the ten principles outlined by hamel touch quite a few different topics and theoretical issues that deal with the ideas of strategy and making the right plans for businesses....
7 Pages (1750 words) Coursework

Analysis of Strategic Intent Article by Hamel and Prahalad

The author of the “Analysis of Strategic Intent Article by hamel and prahalad " paper analyzes the position of the article in the wider debates about the processes of strategy, the theoretical underpinnings of the article as wells its strengths and weaknesses.... The idea of strategic intent is competitive innovations so it must be something that addressing the changing or evolving opportunities of the future that using the past to look and plan for the future (hamel and prahalad, 1989)....
7 Pages (1750 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us