StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Effectiveness of HRM Should Be Assessed Only by Financial Measures - Article Example

Cite this document
Summary
"The Effectiveness of HRM Should Be Assessed Only by Financial Measures" paper presents the affirmative and negative sides of this statement and concludes that it should be done but by means of improving the overall worth of its people resources as they perform their respective roles in society. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.1% of users find it useful
The Effectiveness of HRM Should Be Assessed Only by Financial Measures
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Effectiveness of HRM Should Be Assessed Only by Financial Measures"

The effectiveness of HRM should be assessed only by financial measures Introduction Organizational excellence begins with the performance of people. It is what people do or do not do that ultimately determines what the organization can or cannot become. It is their dedication and commitment to organizational purposes that make the difference. Whether organizational goals can be achieved will depend on the willingness of people to make the necessary contributions. It is the performance of people that is the true benchmark of organizational performance. People constitute an organization’s most important and vital factor in its success or failure. In order to function efficiently and effectively, people must be managed well. Human resources management (HRM) is the art and science of dealing with people at work for the optimum achievement of individual, organization and society’s goals. While general management is the orchestration of all the resources, human resource management is limited to people management – their motivation, acquisition, maintenance and development. There are those who aver that the effectiveness of HRM should be assessed only by financial measures – meaning, its effect on the organization’s bottom-line or net income. It is the objective of this essay to present both the affirmative and negative sides of the statement. The Effectiveness of HRM should be Assessed Only by Financial Measures According to an study conducted by the U.S. Office of Personnel Management (OPM), “defining practical, meaningful measures that assess the effectiveness of …human resources management and its support of mission accomplishment is a topic that agencies have been struggling with. It is easy to measure a process -- how long does it take to complete an action? It is easy to measure productivity -- how many actions were completed in any given time frame? But how do you measure the outcome of human resources management? How does an agency know if it has the right people, with the right skills, in the right positions to carry out the agency mission? Have any agencies found a way to do this?” (1999, 8) First of all, maximization of use and value of benefit choices to employees mean that the company should determine the mix of options and alternatives which would give them more income and least cost that would make their employees motivated to do the tasks required of them. Benefits represent substantial annual expenditures for a company. The design for the appropriate benefits program in the short and long term should account for the following factors: the long-term plans of a business, its stage of development, its projected rate of growth or downsizing, characteristics of its workforce, legal requirements, the competitiveness of its overall benefits "package," and its total compensation strategy. Organizations normally assess the effectiveness of an action in terms of its effect to the financial performance of the firm – how much it increased the firm’s net income in a specified period of time. According to Crawford (2005, 1), “typical financial measures may include revenue growth and cost improvements.” In this regard, HRM is effective only insofar as its activities contribute to the increase in net income of the organization since it is the bottom line that the stockholders of the organization are mostly concerned of. The net income is the determinating factor for pay increases and bonuses and therefore, should be the only criterion for HRM’s effectiveness. The Effectiveness of HRM should be Assessed by Other Measures In a study conducted by Crawford (2005, 3), he averred that “the multiple constituency approach to HRM effectiveness adopts the multiple constituency model of organizational effectiveness, which is the most appropriate for evaluating HRM. This approach considers the influences of key stakeholders in the organization.” Literatures presenting various approaches to measure the effectiveness of HR performance indicated the Balanced Scorecard approach as translating “strategy into operational terms by measuring a full range of perspectives: financial, customer, internal, and learning and growth.” (OPM, 1999, 19). In a paper written by Cabrera & Cabrera (2003, 1), the authors expounded that “the balanced scorecard also attempts to link all measures through a cause-and-effect chain; thus, it acts as a management, rather than measurement, system by helping managers to better understand how different measures are related and how they ultimately contribute to financial results (Bontis, et al., 1999)”. The research of OPM discussed other measures of HRM effectiveness including benchmarking (“a systematic process of measuring an organization’s products, services, and practices against those of a like organization that is a recognized leader in the studied area” (OPM, 1999, 18); activity based costing, a method aimed to determine the true cost for a product or service; and the “Malcolm Baldrige and the President’s Quality Award Criteria, based on a set of core values and concepts that integrate key business requirements into a results-oriented framework (OPM, 1999, 20)”. More importantly, as the roles and functions of HRM become more diverse adapting to the demands of the times, the means to assess its effectiveness evolves into encompassing areas of employee development (employee behavior, attitudes and skills), competencies, performance, as these attributes all contribute to the achievement of organizational goals. As aptly concluded by Cabrera & Cabrera, “no longer are operational measures of internal efficiency sufficient. HR departments must be able to demonstrate the value of their strategic contributions” (2003, 3). According to Crawford, “from a HRM perspective, the multiple constituency approach can be operationalized by measuring HRM effectiveness from the perspective of HRMs internal and external stakeholders (such as top management, line management, employees, customers, and trade unions). This particular approach demonstrates the responsiveness of HRM to the demands of a variety of stakeholders who may hold different opinions regarding the effectiveness of the function. (2005, 3)” In human resources management, people are considered investment, assets and a real resource. Following this philosophy, relatively more funds are earmarked for their proper screening and evaluation, for their growth, training and development, which in turn, increases the rate of retention and organizational productivity. These studies confirm that the effectiveness of HRM should not be assessed solely on financial means. There are more relevant concerns, specifically the strategic development of the organization’s human resources that should be taken into account for an organization to be considered as highly successful in attaining organizational goals. Further, as organizations become more specialized in their respective core competencies, the mission and vision that each explicitly stipulates does not necessarily focus on the bottom-line. More contemporary organizations include goals of social responsibility, service to the community, enhancement and encouragement of cultural diversity, among others. In this regard, the effectiveness of HRM should be measured in terms of their success in achieving their well defined goals. Conclusion All resources – man, money, methods, market, materials, minutes (representing time) and machines are the domain of general management. Human resources management solely involves man. Through and by men, the other m’s are acquired and utilized. The quality and utilization of the rest of the resources are almost always affected by decisions about and by human resources. Indeed, the accomplishment of the goals of an organization depends upon the availability and utilization of all these ingredients, the interaction of which, are people-caused. An organization may start with zero funding, but with creative, resourceful, hardworking and honest people, it becomes financially viable. On the other hand, a plethora of financial and material resources in an organization may go down the drain if handled by an incompetent and dishonest staff. The challenge of management is not so much in its money, machines, methods, markets but in its people. (Guia, 2007) Human resources management purports to accomplish not only organizational goals but also individual goals. It posits that an individual worker whose personal goals are realized is willing to cooperate in the accomplishment of organizational goals. The congruence of both goals is directly proportional to the harmony between management and labor. This approach subscribes to the idea stipulated by Carell & Kuzmitz (1986: 5), to wit: “organizational goals and employee needs are mutual and compatible. One set need not be gained at the expense of the other”. In human resources management, people are considered investment, assets and a real resource. Following this philosophy, relatively more funds are earmarked for their proper screening and evaluation, for their growth, training and development, which in turn, increases the rate of retention and organizational productivity. Trends in human resources management indicate the possible direction that his particular phenomenon takes with the past as its backdrop and the present as its center stage. The main area of concern will be the shift in the environment from a monolithic view to the many-sided interests, particularly quality of working life and the impact of technological development. Integrating human and organizational values will be a principal objective. This will be achieved by developing basic methods of reconciling clashes of values through viable primary work groups that will reduce feelings of normlessness. The role of human resource managers will be expanded in helping the organization meet its ever increasing needs. The pay and benefits a worker receives are a yardstick of how adequately his needs are met. Compensation is a denominator of productivity and job worth. However, just like pay and benefits, these financial measures are not the sole yardstick to assess the effectiveness that HRM accords. The strategic value of human resources are measured in diverse ways including determining the growth and development planned for the employees; the ways by which stakeholders’ interests are achieved; and the role that HRM played in improving organization’s worth in terms of contributing service to the community. Therefore, the effectiveness of HRM should not be measured only by financial measures but by means of improving the overall worth of its people resources as they perform their respective roles in one’s society. Reference List Bontis, N., Dragonetti. N.C., Jacobsen, K., & Roos, G., 1999, "The Knowledge Toolbox: A Review of the Tools Available to Measure and Manage Intangible Resources." European Management Journal, Vol. 17(4): 391.402. Cabrera, E.F. & Cabrera, A., 2003, Strategic Human Resource evaluation. Viewed 16 March 2010, from < http://www.entrepreneur.com/tradejournals/article/99146560_1.html> Carell, M.R. & Kuzmits, F. 1986, Personnel: Human Resource Management, 2nd edition, Columbus: Merill Publishing Company. Crawford, J., 2005, Indicators of strategic HRM effectiveness: a case study of an Australian public sector agency during commercialization, Viewed 16 March 2010, from < http://www.allbusiness.com/human-resources/847224-1.html> Guia, F. 2007, “The Role of Human Resources in an Organization”, Lecture, MBA Class on Seminar in Personnel Management and Industrial Relations, College of Business Administration, University of the Philippines, Diliman, Quezon City. U.S. Office of Personnel Management, 1999, Strategic Human Resources Management: Aligning with the Mission, Viewed 16 March 2010, < http://www.opm.gov/studies/alignnet.pdf> Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(The Effectiveness of HRM Should Be Assessed Only by Financial Measures Article, n.d.)
The Effectiveness of HRM Should Be Assessed Only by Financial Measures Article. https://studentshare.org/human-resources/1734584-the-effectiveness-of-hrm-should-be-assessed-only-by-financial-measures-negative-and-affirmative
(The Effectiveness of HRM Should Be Assessed Only by Financial Measures Article)
The Effectiveness of HRM Should Be Assessed Only by Financial Measures Article. https://studentshare.org/human-resources/1734584-the-effectiveness-of-hrm-should-be-assessed-only-by-financial-measures-negative-and-affirmative.
“The Effectiveness of HRM Should Be Assessed Only by Financial Measures Article”. https://studentshare.org/human-resources/1734584-the-effectiveness-of-hrm-should-be-assessed-only-by-financial-measures-negative-and-affirmative.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Effectiveness of HRM Should Be Assessed Only by Financial Measures

The Principles of Operations Management

However, non-financial measures are also important.... This paper seeks to analyze the structure of the business and establish key performance measures for introducing changes to achieve the corporate objectives.... Performance Key measures Wangoway et al (2010) state, “Performance of an organization has traditionally been measured by looking at the revenues or the profit made at the end of the year, or using key financial ratios” (p.... The centres need to send weekly performance report covering all the key performance measures to HQ....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Internal: One Tiuch Direct

For every product the company takes on to market, an r and d team should be setup to over see the right target market.... The primary objective of Human resource management should be to develop an HRM management system for the organization that will enhance the organization's effectiveness, efficiency, quality, innovation and responsiveness to customers.... It is an important and a rigorous process and each of the following six components are just as important: Recruitment and selection Training and development Performance appraisals and feedback Pay and benefits Labor relations The first and most major component of hrm is recruitment and selection....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

Financial Performance Assessment of William Hills

“Operating profit margin measures the percentage of each sales dollar remaining after all costs and expenses other than interest, taxes, and preferred stock dividend are deducted.... The first issue is financial performance assessment of William over a period of four years since 2006 with the help of ratio analysis with particular emphasis on profitability performance and… In the second part the issue of management accountancy has been taken up as to how techniques and tools of management accountancy can help in reporting, assessing and analyzing the activities and performance of William Hills Ltd. The matrix used o assess the financial performance of William Hills is its profitability assessment over the last four years and the satisfaction of investors in terms of returns on their investments....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Performance-Related-Pay

The following paper “Performance-Related-Pay” will discuss the effectiveness of PRP from an organization's viewpoint.... Money linked to performance targets has varied opinions – some feel it is the sole motivator while others feel that motivation is purely intrinsic and money should never be linked to it (Hendry et al....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

Financial Statement and Ratio

The researcher of this essay aims to analyze Google Inc.... s Cost of Goods Sold to Net Sales Ratios for 2005, 2006 and 2007.... The percentage of the cost of revenues to net sales decreased from almost 42% in 2005 to about 40% in 2006.... The decrease was due to lower traffic acquisition costs.... hellip; This essay discusses that the increases in the percentages are primarily due to an additional headcount of R&D, sales, marketing etc....
10 Pages (2500 words) Coursework

Safe and Secure: Security Management

All of these aspects may be seen to impact upon the cost-effectiveness of the process of information acquisition that would be an aid in carrying out a project and provide an idea of whether they would be considered useful in enhancing the project value.... Since the protection measures have become increasingly stringent, such as for example, passwords that may be hard to crack, these hackers are resorting instead to trickery to persuade insiders to reveal the passwords....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

What Is the HR Scorecard Approach

These steps are designed and developed with a view to improving the effectiveness of hrm policies and practices in order to add values (Paauwe, 2004, p.... he HR scorecard provides a strategic framework that assesses the effectiveness of an organization and organizational performance, basically from four perspectives.... 8- Choosing HR Scorecard measures 9: Summarize scorecard measures on digital dashboard and 10: Monitor, Predict, and Evaluate the measures and changes thereon....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

Risk Management as an Essential Part of Project Planning

hellip; Management of information systems can never be successful if risks that come with these systems are not properly assessed and managed.... Most importantly, risk managers have to be keen on cost-effectiveness.... The paper "Risk Management as an Essential Part of Project Planning" argues in a well-organized manner that risk management is a very important function in today's corporate world that is heavily reliant on information systems....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us