StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Regulation of International Capital Movement - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The essay "Regulation of International Capital Movement" focuses on the critical analysis of the current capital movement landscape, identifies the regulatory mechanisms that govern it (i.e. statutes, treaties, etc.), and assesses their strengths, failures, points of opportunities, and challenges…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.4% of users find it useful
Regulation of International Capital Movement
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Regulation of International Capital Movement"

?METHODOLOGY PAPER Proposed Topic: The Regulation of International Capital movement under Bilateral Investment Treaties: A Critical Analysis INTRODUCTION Starting in the 1990s, there has been a steady increase in the bilateral investment treaties (BITs). (Sauvant and Sachs, 2009, p935) During this period, the World Bank has identified around 700 such treaties. (Sornarajah 2010, p172) This is mainly attributed to the globalization phenomenon and the permeation of liberal trade. In the Gulf region, for instance, there was a proliferation capital exchange that ushered in a type of sophistication and daring among local capital investment players. As the Gulf countries traded with the world, they have gained both capital and expertise to go beyond the passive investments that have dominated the flow of capital in the region in the past. Legrenzi and Momani have pointed this out, arguing that the profits accumulated from the years of stable and high oil prices have enabled the GCC states to have a wider range of investment choices. (p20) A parallel development is the perception that BITs have or will create a special limb of international customary law. (Dolzer and Schreuer, 2008, p2) It has been argued for the most part that BITs have evolved to such an extent that they have their own unique regulatory laws within the wider scope of international commercial laws. (Dolzer and Schreuer, p2) This expectation led to the favorable attitude on BITs. Sornarajah, however, raised an interesting point warranting further exploration and research. According to him, the fact that there has been an increase in BITs for some time and no legal standards has been established as yet should already demonstrate how these treaties have not been able to create the “customary principles of international law” for protecting the movement of foreign capital. (p232) This is critical because, as with the case of all states and regional blocs all over the world, the GCC states are prone to the vulnerabilities and risks that are brought about by the deficiencies of the global economic system. For instance, the 2009 economic crisis that was triggered by the US mortgage crisis sent shocks all over the world, illustrating the argument that there is no safe place for investors. Oil prices, for its part, has now become relatively impervious of late as the highly integrated international system become more and more strict in addition to how the world is scrambling to tap alternative energy sources. Therefore, the need for BIT regulation is underscored. Aside from intelligent investment decisions, the GCC member-states have used regulatory mechanisms to control international capital movement especially concerning the BITs in a bid to prevent and mitigate risks and threats. This paper will explore this theme. The aim is to outline the current capital movement landscape, identify the regulatory mechanisms that govern it (i.e. statutes, treaties, etc.) and assess their strengths, failures, points of opportunities and challenges. 2. SOURCES AND DATA ANALYSIS This research uses several approaches within the qualitative method of inquiry. The sources of the information, hence, are composed of both primary and secondary data, which will often be referenced in order to outline specific cases and important statutes that govern BITs. These sources can include academic journals as well as other texts published on the subject (i.e. published dissertations and news reports), Internet sources in addition to data available from corporate websites among other documents released and published by organizations, individuals and documents from the GCC governments and their agencies. Relevant information from international organizations will also be used. In addition, this study will also conduct interviews on selected resource persons, which could be composed of legal luminaries, specializing in the GCC jurisprudence, investors, policymakers and other stakeholders that are authoritative in discussing the GCC BIT subject. The number of these resources would be from 5-7, which is expected to provide enough primary data to support, corroborate and update the secondary sources. 3. LITERATURE REVIEW As a qualitative research, the literature will play a crucial part in the study. The examination of the extant work on the topic will include the legal, economic and policy perspectives. It will also cover the theoretical and real-world cases as provided by academics, economists and even the media. Finally, the literature review will also focus on the prevailing themes in the academic perspectives on future trends, patterns, opportunities and challenges. 4. RESEARCH METHODOLOGIES Since this is a descriptive and analytical research, this study will not use models for empirical inquiries. Instead, this researcher will use a combination of methods to address the multi-dimensional character of the research subject. For example, the data collected through the secondary sources will be augmented by ‘black-letter' doctrinal analyses and ‘law in context' approach. The idea is to capture the complexity of having to discuss the general subject of bilateral investment treaties and the specific experiences of GCC states for a comprehensive critical outline of the topic. The ‘black-letter’ model aims to systematize, correct and clarify specific statutes on any particular topic through a distict analytical framework to authoritative texts that are composed of both primary and secondary research. (McConville and Chui, 2007, p4) It is, hence, the most appropriate model to explain the BIT system and the related statutes and legal decisions such on matters concerning arbitration. Moreover, it can provide the representation of some universal standards and rules that are acceptable in the international community by clearly and authoritatively establishing the framework in which BITs are contracted and implemented as well as their resolution in the events of disputes. In this respect, the strategy is clearly understood as crucial in identifying legitimate solutions to problems, say, of contractual enforcement. Furthermore, the ‘black-letter’ model can also enable this study to gain deeper insight on the Sharia law, which is a fundamental source for policy and regulation. Meanwhile, ‘law in context' approaches will be utilized in order to understand BITs in the context of the GCC experience. According to Slapper and Kelly, this contextualist model examines and analyzes the law as a social phenomenon and, hence, operates within a social context. (Slapper and Kelly, 2009, p11) This researcher believes that this model can provide invaluable insights on the GCC experience and accurately explain and depict the reasons behind the issue of BIT, its initiation and enforcement. For example, the problems of enforcement compliance can be better understood as the issue is explained in the Islamic context, with its own unique variables. Say, the refusal to comply based on Shari’a law can be better understood and explained. In an effort to be scientific in the method of research, this study would follow the linear progression of the academic research model. As has been outlined and demonstrated in this proposal, a problem or an issue is identified, research is initiated, and then, a thesis is formulated. Afterwards, the research would finally commence, which would be followed by the analysis and the requisite recommendations/conclusion. 5. EXAMINATION OF RELEVANT CASE LAWS An important variable in the examination of case laws for the purposes of this study is theoretical analysis espoused in the literature by virtue of the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development relative to the doctrine of fair and equitable treatment. (UNCTAD, 2009, p11) Case law will be analyzed to demonstrate the practical difficulty of establishing a clear and cohesive body of customary international law relative to the doctrine of fair and equitable treatment. Related cases include but are not limited to: United Mexican States v Metalclad Corporation 2001 BCSC 664, The Loewen Group, Inc and Raymond L. Loewen v United States of America Case No. ARB(AF)/98/3 Washington, (2003), S.D. Myers Inc. v Canada 2000-2002 NAFTA, Pope and Talbot Inc and The Government of Canada Award on the Merits of Phase 2, Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Methodology paper for PHD research, the proposal is ready but the Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1437540-methodology-paper-for-phd-research-the-proposal-is
(Methodology Paper for PHD Research, the Proposal Is Ready But the Essay)
https://studentshare.org/law/1437540-methodology-paper-for-phd-research-the-proposal-is.
“Methodology Paper for PHD Research, the Proposal Is Ready But the Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1437540-methodology-paper-for-phd-research-the-proposal-is.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Regulation of International Capital Movement

Economic Regulation

This process of privatization is now an international affair.... This research paper "Economic regulation" shows that in this paper I will discuss economic regulations or competition analysis.... The relationship between Competition policy and Economic regulation will also be discussed.... We also discuss some other concepts which include AJ effect and rate of return regulation.... Economic Regulations George Stigler was the pioneer of the theory of economic regulation....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

Regulations in the Transport Industry

modern look on regulation in the transport industryRegulation is developed in order to 'balance concerns for the public interest within a competitive framework driven by private enterprise' (Coyle, 20011).... This essay "Regulations in the Transport Industry" focuses on the importance of regulations in the transport industry....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

The Regulation of International Capital Doctrine

A parallel development is the perception that BITs have or will create a special limb of international customary law.... The writer of this research study proposes to rebut the argument that the doctrine of fair and equitable treatment standard has the potential to create a cohesive body of customary international law relative to the movement of foreign investment via BITs.... This research study proposes to rebut the argument that the doctrine of fair and equitable treatment standard has the potential to create a cohesive body of customary international law relative to the movement of foreign investment via BITs....
5 Pages (1250 words) Dissertation

The Extent of and Reasons for the Uneven Impact of Global Crisis on Global Capital Movements

The global capital movement has significantly contributed to the business cycles.... It has been stated that the increase in the global capital movement is primarily due to the augmented integration of the global financial markets.... This essay "The Extent of and Reasons for the Uneven Impact of Global Crisis on Global capital Movements" is about to examine the extent of and the reasons for the uneven impact of the global crisis.... The increasingly global and financial liberalization and innovation along with other developments globally have resulted in increasing cross-border capital flows prior to the global crisis....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Financial Regulation in the United Kingdom

The regulation of financial markets and its implications have been a topic of considerable interest among researchers and policy makers for a long time.... On the one hand, it is argued that the regulation of financial markets has welfare benefits due to the existence of market.... On the other hand, it is argued that financial market regulation imposes significant costs to an economy that outweighs the benefits (Benston, 1998).... In this essay, the failure of financial regulation in UK in the light This essay is organized as follows....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

The Regulation of International Capital Movement under Bilateral Investment Treaties

Generally speaking, the paper "The Regulation of International Capital Movement under Bilateral Investment Treaties" investigates and analyses the customary international law regulating the movement of capital via bilateral investment treaties (BITs).... This thesis seeks to determine whether or not the doctrine of fair and equitable treatment represents a separate and cohesive standard for regulating the movement of international capital under BITs or is merely incidental to the minimum standard treatment at customary international law....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

The Relationship between Competition Policy and Economic Regulation

This process of privatization is now an international affair.... The paper "The Relationship between Competition Policy and Economic regulation" discusses that the regulatory scene which we witness today is significantly different from what it was in the 1980's.... We discuss some concepts which include AJ effect and rate of return regulation.... eorge Stigler was the pioneer of the theory of economic regulation.... (Vane) He integrated the economics of regulation and the economics of politics....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

The Internationalism of Labour Movement

The main focus of the current paper "The Internationalism of Labour movement" is to highlight special concern areas for the labor movement's growth and how it is now able to communicate to organizations around the world on issues that are global.... The ideas presented in this article are to formulate the opinion as to how much the recent globalization has impacted the internationalism of the labor movement.... Beginning with an overview of how and when the Labour movement initiated and what were the issues they faced in the early 19th century....
9 Pages (2250 words) Article
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us