StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Jury Trial Analysis - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Jury trial analysis Introduction A jury trial seems to be an absolutely easy process consisting only of five simple steps: selection of a jury, the trial, judge’s charge to the jury, jury deliberation and verdict. However, it is also important to critically consider the assessment of the constitutional trial rights that are enacted during a jury trial, as well as to examine and discuss the selection of a fair and unbiased jury…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.7% of users find it useful
Jury Trial Analysis
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Jury Trial Analysis"

Jury trial analysis Introduction A jury trial seems to be an absolutely easy process consisting only of five simple steps: selection of a jury, thetrial, judge’s charge to the jury, jury deliberation and verdict. However, it is also important to critically consider the assessment of the constitutional trial rights that are enacted during a jury trial, as well as to examine and discuss the selection of a fair and unbiased jury. These are some of the most important critical points that need to be considered in a jury trial analysis, which are particularly integrated in this essay.

Selection of a jury In the actual jury trial the first step is selection of jury. Selection of fair and unbiased jury should be primarily implemented in here. This is to ensure that the entire case would be handled accordingly and both parties would be given fair trial that each one deserve s to have. However, there are some experts lawyers that could be employed at this stage for the effective selection of jurors. As stated in sixth amendment to the US Constitution, all accused have the right for speedy and public trial by an impartial jury of the State and district where crime is committed (Hornberger, 2005; The Constitution of the United States, 2012).

However, for some, the selection of jury is the most crucial step because the case can either be won or lost in this stage. After all, the prosecution and defense lawyers can either reject a juror for a cause or illogically. Furthermore, according to Hornberger, there exists a judicial corruption in court where the judge has the power to influence the jury to ensure conviction. The existence of Hornberger’s point is just a reminder that the employment of constitutional trial rights especially in the selection of a jury can still be manipulated through the strong powerful force of bureaucracy.

The trial Each party would be given a chance to share an opening statement. The prosecutor is privileged to tell the court what the trial is all about. The prosecutor would present their specific accusations to the defendant and a summary how they would prove that the accused is culpable. On the other hand, the defendant’s attorney would also present an opening statement in order to tell the court in summary how to prove his or her client is innocent. After this, just as how the prosecutor started to take the floor in actual trial, it is also the privilege of the said party to call on first their witnesses to present physical evidences in which the main point is for them to tell some actual stories in order to prove beyond reasonable doubt that indeed the accused is guilty.

After this, the defense would be given the chance to cross-examine the prosecutor’s witnesses. The defense would then get its turn after the prosecutor would be done with its case. Just like the prosecutor, the defense would also present its witnesses and evidences and after this the other party would be given the chance to cross-examine defense witnesses. The next part of the trial would then be the time for closing statements. In here, the defense would be the first to stand and show how the prosecutor was not able to prove its case.

After this, the prosecution has to say something regarding on how it achieves its main objective which particularly would result to summing up its entire case. Specifically, the above process is still very in line with the general view of the sixth amendment to the US Constitution. However, it is always the point of the defense to critically consider if the case could stand on its own after the prosecutor presented it. If it is not, then the defense lawyer can ask the judge to dismiss the case.

The dismissal of this case would be upon the judge’s decision of the defendant’s lawyer’s request. Thus, if the judge would agree, no defense is necessary and the case would simply be dismissed. Based on the argument of Hornberger, the judges can reasonably create a significant twist in here as they are quiet unable to distinguish the law from justice. In a sense, Hornberger points out that bias is still remarkable in a trial by jury. This can still happen even though the right for fair trial and freedom of speech are remarkable.

Judge’s charge to the jury Generally, there are three main important things that the judge would do at this point. The judge would explain the jury’s jobs, the things they are supposed to do, and finally, the evidences that have to be considered or disregarded by the jury. These are still specifically in line with the right of the accused for speedy and public trial by an impartial jury. However, knowing the fact that the judge may have the power to influence the jury, the charge may not actually give a real significant value but just merely a part of the ceremony.

Jury deliberation The next step of the jury trial would then be to bring them into a little room to deliberate. In here a presiding officer from the juror should be elected in order for them to discuss freely and open-mindedly in line with the judge’s instructions. This specifically presents the right to freedom of speech (Independence Hall Association, 2012). However, this freedom may not be substantially practiced if bias already conspired from the first step down to the deliberation process.

Verdict After the jurors come up with a verdict, they would be out in the courtroom once again and take their seat and their decision is read. The verdict for both civil and criminal cases must be unanimous. In civil cases, the verdict should be written while it should be verbal in criminal cases. It is the jury foreman or the jury elected as presiding officer in the deliberation should present to the court. However, based on the previous discussion, the result may either be based on justice or just merely justification of the law.

Conclusion Clearly, an effective jury trial depends on the genuine inclusion of constitutional trial rights that are enacted during a trial by jury, as well as on the selection of fair and unbiased jurors. References ‘ Hornberger, J. G. (2005). The Bill of Rights: Trial by Jury. Retrieved from http://www.fff.org/freedom/fd0501a.asp Independence Hall Association. (2012). Bill of Rights and Later Amendments. Retrieved from http://www.ushistory.org/documents/amendments.htm The Constitution of the United States. (2012). A brief guide.

Retrieved from http://depts.alverno.edu/dgp/GEC/Overview%20of%20Constitution.html

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Jury Trial Analysis Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1446893-jury-trial-analysis
(Jury Trial Analysis Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/law/1446893-jury-trial-analysis.
“Jury Trial Analysis Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1446893-jury-trial-analysis.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Jury Trial Analysis

Runaway Jury Movie Critique

This movie was based on a book by John Grisham and the plot revolves around the jury trial of a major gun manufacturer.... Included in that analysis is an evaluation as to which jurors the other party might reject.... From there the trial is "engineered" still more.... Simpson trial, when a consultant named Jo-Ellan Dimitrius picked the jury that found him not guilty.... She has worked with hundreds of other witnesses - including actors, lawyers, CEO's and people from almost every walk of life - - to help prepare them for trial....
10 Pages (2500 words) Movie Review

Psychology to Understanding of the Judge and Jury Decisions

This has become so common to the point that it is replacing evidence from religious witnesses.... However, there are instances where psychology may not be appropriate.... This is because the… psychology and the criminal justice system are quite different.... The criminal justice system aims at giving punishment to wrong doers while the field of psychology mostly focuses on the reasons behind the offender's actions....
18 Pages (4500 words) Essay

The Concept of a Trial by a Jury

In the final analysis, the perpetuation of such a jury is inconsistent with an element of fairness to both the accused and the victim which is an extension of the community at large.... This paper "The Concept of a trial by a Jury" focuses on the notion which takes its roots from the British Magna Carta 1215.... (Knight, 1881, 211)Penn and Mead's trial reflected some of the limitations and constraints on the fundamental concept of a fair and impartial jury as envisaged by the Magna Carta's mandate for a trial by a jury of one's peers....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Place of a Jury Trial in Modern

The essay “The Place of a jury trial in Modern” will look at the provision for settlement of disputes.... There are 2 major different types of trials; these are a bench trial and a jury trial.... In a jury trial, the court proceedings are held in front of both the judge and the jury.... In any modern society, disputes are settled by virtue of a trial.... A trial can, therefore, be described as the coming together of two parties to a dispute....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Criminal Law - Casey Anthony Trial

This paper "Criminal Law - Casey Anthony trial" focuses on Casey's trial - one of the cases that have drawn a lot of attention and marred by many controversies regarding how the case was handled and the defence provided by both lawyers and witnesses of both parties.... The trial continued for six from May to July 5, 2011, when the jury acquitted her of murder charges but convicted of a misdemeanour for lying to the police officers during investigations (Shahani, 2011)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Essential of forensic investigation

If yes, how was the evidence used used at trial, and, if not, why?... In the selected case the decision made once was reversed in the second trial of the case and the second trial of the case was accepted by the court on the basis of new forensic investigation and it proved how important the evidence collected by the forensic scientists and their investigation are for the legal purposes....
20 Pages (5000 words) Case Study

Jury System in England and Wales

The assignment "Jury System in England and Wales " points out that The jury trial paradigm is an entrenched part of the criminal justice system, posited as a fundamental tool against oppression.... rdquo; However, whilst the jury trial remains theoretically symbolic of the preservation of justice within the criminal trial system, the role of the jury has been plagued by controversy, with some critics attacking the competence of the jurors and expense of the system in reality5....
8 Pages (2000 words) Assignment

Why the Jury Is an Outmoded Institution and Ought to Be Discarded

rdquo; However, whilst the jury trial remains theoretically symbolic of the preservation of justice within the criminal trial system, the role of the jury has been plagued by controversy, with some critics attacking the competence of the jurors and expense of the system in reality5.... The increasing concerns regarding the practical limitations of the jury trial paradigm have fuelled contentious debate further in the English legal system since the Royal Commission on Criminal Justice made its report in 19936....
8 Pages (2000 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us