StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Crime Seriousness and Prior Criminal Record - Dissertation Example

Cite this document
Summary
This paper talks that the production of witnesses to testify on the character of an accused is an important part of all court proceedings, and has an impact on the proceedings. Crime Seriousness and Prior Criminal Records are of definite legal relevance…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97% of users find it useful
Crime Seriousness and Prior Criminal Record
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Crime Seriousness and Prior Criminal Record"

CRIME SERIOUSNESS AND PRIOR CRIMINAL RECORD: LEGAL RELEVANCE ‘Character is much easier kept than recovered’. This most oft repeated quote emphasizes the importance of one’s reputation, whether spoken or otherwise. In fact, the production of witnesses to testify on the character of an accused is an important part of all court proceedings, and has an impact on the proceedings. Thus the presence (or absence) of a prior criminal record is definitely relevant as far as criminal justice is concerned, with the criminal history including not only the numbers of prior arrests, but also the seriousness of previous offenses. The gravity of previous offences and whether or not they resulted in prison sentences is an important ingredient of sentencing procedures. Thus, Crime Seriousness and Prior Criminal Records are of definite legal relevance. Prior Criminal Record There is a positive correlation between a person’s prior criminal record and the chances that firstly, such a person is more likely to commit an offence in the future, and secondly, that there is a greater probability of such offences resulting in imprisonment. Moreover, as a result of mandatory sentencing policies, repeat offenders are now far more likely to face imprisonment (Mauer, M 1999 p 9). A prior record sets into motion totally different responses amongst law enforces, with the suspect considered ‘guilty until proved innocent’, rather than the other way around which is the basis of modern jurisprudence. However, this ground reality has resulted in two developments that go contrary to conventional logic. Firstly, though crime rates have declined, prison populations have actually increased, which questions the very basic premise that the threat of getting caught and imprisoned actually deters crime. In fact, the prison population is likely to grow in coming years. A study by the Bureau of Justice Statistics revealed that the 1994 prison population would rise by 51% by the year 2000 (Ditton, P and Wilson, D as cited in Mauer p 13). This is a direct result of taking into account a person’s prior criminal record, however minor and irrespective of the relevance of previous offences to the new charge. The second aspect is the increasing numbers of African Americans in particular (apart from other minorities) that constitute the prison population. This is in spite of the fact that several positive changes in society such as the civil rights movement and enhanced educational and employment opportunities. As a result of this, the number of African American in prison should have decreased, but the same is not the case. 49% of prison inmates in the US are African Americans, although they constitute only 13 % of the population, up from about 30% in the 1950’s for a comparable percentage of the population (Mauer p 3). The reasons for this are not conclusive, though a racial bias in the criminal justice system could be one possible reason. ‘Blacks’ and other minorities are more likely to be stopped for routine checks than ‘whites’ and booked for petty offences that come to light as a result of this enhanced screening. Thus, these ‘discretionary law enforcement practices result in minorities acquiring a criminal history more rapidly’ (Mauer, p 5). This aspect has become more acute post 9/11 with minorities especially Asians, now at the receiving end of spot checks. As a result, even if the first offence is of a minor nature, it greatly enhances the chances of a prison sentences for subsequent offences irrespective of the gravity or seriousness of the new offence. The point to note, however, is that prior criminal history, no matter how minor, is always taken into account. Crime Seriousness There is no doubt that the gravity of the offense has a great bearing on prison sentences. As a general rule, the “more serious a prior criminal record, the greater the likelihood of receiving a prison term for a new offense” (Mauer, p 5). Thus not only prior criminal activity but also the severity of the offence is definitely taken into account by the judicial system, with impact on conviction rates as well as the severity of the sentence imposed. There is also a general feeling that ‘once an offender, always an offender’ which goes against the law of natural justice. However, this is often the case, especially if an accused has committed a similarly serious offence in the past. This is then seen as fitting the pattern or profile as reflected in the criminal history of the offender. Even in this, the race of the offender seems to have an effect on the outcome of the judicial proceedings. In murder cases, the races of both the victim as well as the offender affect the outcome. Defendants charged with killing ‘whites’ faced a 4.3 times greater chance of receiving a death sentences (Baldus, D et al, cited in Mauer, p 7). Similarly, the race of the offender is also a factor in sentencing with minorities more likely to receive stiffer punishments. For property offenses and misdemeanors, minorities are more likely to receive jail terms as compared to ‘whites’ who are more likely to left of with a warning, concluded a US statewide study (Nelson, J cited in Mauer, p 8). However, violent offenders are more likely to be sentenced to prison irrespective of their origins, especially once a threshold of violence has been crossed which engenders a feeling of revulsion, thus proving conclusively that crime seriousness in also a legally relevant variable. The criminal justice system is supposed to be fair and impartial. However factors such as race and ethnicity, as well as the social background of the offender also do play a role in the final outcome, both in terms of conviction rates, as well as the nature and severity of sentences imposed. Not withstanding these limitations, however, what clearly stands out is that the prior criminal history of an offender as well as the seriousness of the crime is always taken into account. If the purpose of punitive measures such as imprisonment is to control crime then imprisonment seems to have served its purpose as evidenced by a 17% decline in crime since 1992 (Mauer, p 11). However, this is at odds with the increasing numbers of people who are either currently in prison or who have been imprisoned at one time or the other. To really create a free and civil society, reductions in crime rates must be matched by corresponding decreases in the prison population and of persons having criminal records. Unfortunately, that is not the case. What is required is a change in current legislation that will make the law less discriminatory, while at the same time ensuring that proclaimed offenders who constitute a threat to society are not allowed to roam at large. To this end the twin factors of previous criminal history and seriousness of previous offenses will have to be taken into account. Reference Mauer, Marc, The Crisis of the Young African American Male and the Criminal Justice System, prepared for the U.S. Commission on Civil Rights, Apr 1999. htpp://www.cjtoday.com/pdf/nijapr99.pdf . Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Crime Seriousness and Prior Criminal Record Dissertation”, n.d.)
Crime Seriousness and Prior Criminal Record Dissertation. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1535261-crime-seriousness-and-prior-criminal-record
(Crime Seriousness and Prior Criminal Record Dissertation)
Crime Seriousness and Prior Criminal Record Dissertation. https://studentshare.org/law/1535261-crime-seriousness-and-prior-criminal-record.
“Crime Seriousness and Prior Criminal Record Dissertation”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1535261-crime-seriousness-and-prior-criminal-record.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Crime Seriousness and Prior Criminal Record

The Concept of Sentencing and PostSentence Supervision

Another reason for the employment of stricter sentencing and supervision was the belief that it would carry out some of the aims of the criminal justice system.... 3Dangerous Offenders and the Law Measures for controlling dangerous offenders are outlined under the criminal Justice Act 2003.... In the words of Hungerford - Welch, "Under s 225(2), if the offence is punishable with life imprisonment and the court considers that the seriousness of the offence (or of the offence and one or more offences associated with it) is such as to justify the imposition of a sentence of imprisonment for life, then the court must impose a life sentence"....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Developing a Pre-sentence Investigation

nbsp; … Charging a person with a crime is a serious event- it has legal implications and will also appear on his public records.... nbsp; It details the circumstances of the arrest, the evidence or suspicion that led the officer to book the suspect, the crime of offense he or she is charged with, and the events after the suspect has been booked.... The pre-sentence investigation report is the outcome of an interview between the defendant and the investigating officer and usually includes basic information about the defendant as well as the circumstances of the arrest and the crime of which he is being charged....
8 Pages (2000 words) Term Paper

Pre-sentence Investigations

Someone with no prior criminal record may get a less severe punishment, especially if the crime is relegated to a misdemeanor.... These elements, according to the article “Presentence Investigation” (2012), include: an interview with the defendant; a review of the defendant's criminal record; and a review of the specific facts of the crime (pgh.... Secondly, there is a review of the defendant's criminal record.... On the other hand, if the jails are full—and the person's crime is relatively minor like a misdemeanor—another misdemeanor is not going to look suspicious on the criminal record of a career criminal who has only been committing minor offenses....
2 Pages (500 words) Research Paper

Analysis of Crime Problems and the Justice System

hellip; It is evident that crime and criminal justice is a social issue that involves various social and scientific disciplines.... However, the behavior is not inherently criminal or deviant but rather deviance depends upon one's interpretation and judgment.... The sequence of events involved in criminal justice right from the identification of a crime, reporting the case and prosecution are complex.... f the subject of crime is to be fixed in light of criminal law as discussed in the fields of criminology and law, then the execution of the processes relating to the subject would lie solely on the definitions of criminal law and its procedures....
6 Pages (1500 words) Coursework

Homeland Security and Child Pornography

Holliday reflects that: “Child pornography is prohibited by federal statutes, which provide for civil and criminal penalties for its production, advertising, possession, receipt, distribution, and sale.... Besides, production and other activities related to child pornography will lead to civil and criminal penalties.... Moreover, the law enforcement effort conducted by the Child Exploitation and Obscenity Section of the criminal Division at the Department of Justice and U....
5 Pages (1250 words) Coursework

Felony Defense in the U.S

Thus, in each state, crime and criminal activities are distinguished into specific categories, as influenced by their seriousness, cause-effects, and social implications, amongst others.... Felonies are by far, the most serious of criminal offenses, typically involving the presence of the threat of harm or serious physical harm.... The determination is usually focused on such issues as social impacts (on the affected victims and society in general), and the crime's seriousness....
11 Pages (2750 words) Research Paper

Crime and Intelligence

"Crime and Intelligence" paper reviews the relation that exists between criminal activities and levels of IQ.... nbsp; The paper introduces various existing literature on the relationship between IQ levels and criminal activities.... The paper establishes the link between lower functioning intelligence and offending and identifies the possible factors that enhance the relationship between intellectual levels and crime.... The study states the hypothesis of the research process and with respect to the relationship between IQ levels and crime....
10 Pages (2500 words) Lab Report

Documentary Analysis and Opinion: No End in Sight

he film explores the rapid descent of Iraq into a state of anarchy, lawlessness and guerrilla warfare with the government losing its grip to warlords and other criminal elements.... The paper "Documentary Analysis and Opinion: No End in Sight" states that the seriousness of the matter raised in “No end in sight” is underpinned by the impunity of the US, its allies directly resulted in civilian casualties, and owing to the fact that these nations have influence at the UN....
8 Pages (2000 words) Movie Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us