StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Case Study: Johnson v. Fresh Mark, Inc - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Born male, she represented herself as a woman and was hired as such by defendant Fresh Mark, Inc. After complaints were received that Johnson was seen using both the mens and womens restrooms, Fresh Mark brought this to her…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.6% of users find it useful
Case Study: Johnson v. Fresh Mark, Inc
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Case Study: Johnson v. Fresh Mark, Inc"

SELENA JOHNSON v. FRESH MARK, INC., and BRIAN WESS 337 F.Supp.2d 996, 999 (N.D. Ohio 2003), aff’d, 98 Fed. Appx. 461, 2004 WL 1166553 (6th Cir. May 18, 2004)Issue: The issue to be decided here is whether or not Respondents violated Title VII of the 1964 Civil Rights Act when they terminated Plaintiff, a transsexual employee.Facts:Selena Johnson was a pre-surgical transsexual woman. Born male, she represented herself as a woman and was hired as such by defendant Fresh Mark, Inc. After complaints were received that Johnson was seen using both the mens and womens restrooms, Fresh Mark brought this to her attention.

Johnson responded, through counsel, that she was "not entirely male nor entirely female" and preferred for her to use a female or unisex restroom. However, because the gender stated on her drivers license that she was male, her employer decided she was in fact male and would have to use the mens restrooms. Johnson refused to return to work under that condition. When she failed to appear for work on three consecutive days, she was terminated under the employers absenteeism policy.Decision:The district court did not err in concluding that Title VII and Price-Waterhouse was inapplicable to the instant case.

Judgment of the district court affirmed on appeal. Case dismissed.Analysis: How HR function may be affected by the decision Title VII of the 1964 Civil Rights Act states that “It shall be an unlawful employment practice for an employer … to hire or to discharge any individual, or otherwise to discriminate against any individual with respect to his compensation, terms, conditions, or privileges of employment, because of such individual’s race, color, religion, sex, or national origin…” In that statute, the denotations of the word “sex” has come under controversy in the present-day context that allows social recognition of homosexuality, lesbianism, transgender modification and/or transsexuality, as distinct social orientations.

The question is thus raised: Is transsexuality a “sex” that is accorded the protection of Title VII of the Civil Rights Act? Price Waterhouse v. Hopkins, [490 U.S. 228, 104 L. Ed. 2d 268, 109 S.Ct. 1775 (1989)], a case that preceded Johnson, ruled that Title VII prohibited employer discrimination against employees because they failed to conform to sex stereotypes (including stereotypical norms about dress and appearance). Johnson argued that on the basis of this decision, transsexuals should be accorded the protection of the Civil Rights Act.

Together with Johnson, however, several cases have ruled that the case of the use of comfort rooms is not a matter of “sex stereotyping”; were it so, then allowing transsexuals to use both comfort rooms should mean that men or women should be allowed the same entitlement, to use both comfort rooms as well (i.e., for men to use the women’s restrooms and vice-versa). Clearly, the proposition becomes then absurd, and argues against the classification of restroom use as sex stereotyping. (Etsitty vs.

Utah Transit Authority, et al., 2005 U.S. Dist. Lexis 12634. 2005). Johnson, Etsitty, Ulane v. Eastern Airlines, Inc. 742 F.2d 1081 (7th Cir. 1984), and Sommers v. Budget Mktg., Inc., 667 F.2d 748 (8th Cir. 1982), as well as every federal court that has dealt directly with this issue have all held that “Title VII does not prohibit discrimination based on an individual’s transsexualism,” (Johnson v. Fresh Mark, Inc.) clearly indicating its position that Title VII does not afford the same protection to transsexuals.

Furthermore, the court stated in Nichols v. Azteca Rest. Ent., Inc., 256 F.3d 864 (9th Cir. 2001): “We do not imply that all gender-based distinctions are actionable under Title VII. For example, our decision does not imply that there is any violation of Title VII occasioned by reasonable regulations that require male and female employees to conform to different dress and grooming standards.” This has implications for HRD managers and human resources policy-makers. An employer is allowed to distinguish between males and females, and prescribe appropriate behaviour, dress codes, and to require them to use particular restrooms.

This is but proper and reasonable practice. It is important to afford other employees the privacy and convenience of using a restroom used by a individuals of a single sex. HRD personnel should therefore take the added precaution of securing a positive statement from the applicant seeking employment of his/her gender, whether male or female, and to confirm this upon interview. During such interview it should also be made clear to the applicant that he pursuant to HRD policy, he/she shall be required to comply with certain gender-distinctive behaviour, and to secure his/her acknowledgement and agreement to this.

It is not against the law to require such conforme as condition for employment. Furthermore, should existing employees wish to undertake such transgender modification, they should be required to inform HRD and to come to an agreement as to which restroom he/she is required to use during and after the transition. Furthermore, HRD managers and human resources policy makers should keep in mind that whatever behaviour they allow their employees who are “transsexuals” should be within the proper behaviour they would allow normally allow males and females, otherwise the unjust discrimination will work against the latter group, putting transsexuals at an unjustified advantage.

REFERENCESEtsitty vs. Utah Transit Authority, et al., 2005 U.S. Dist. Lex 12634. (2005)Nichols v. Azteca Rest. Ent., Inc., 256 F.3d 864 (9th Cir. 2001)Sommers v. Budget Mktg., Inc., 667 F.2d 748 (8th Cir. 1982)Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, The U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, as seen in http://www.eeoc.gov/policy/vii.html, Retrieved March 15, 2009Ulane v. Eastern Airlines, Inc. 742 F.2d 1081 (7th Cir. 1984)

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Case Study: Johnson v. Fresh Mark, Inc Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Case Study: Johnson v. Fresh Mark, Inc Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1552641-case-study-johnson-v-fresh-mark-inc
(Case Study: Johnson V. Fresh Mark, Inc Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
Case Study: Johnson V. Fresh Mark, Inc Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1552641-case-study-johnson-v-fresh-mark-inc.
“Case Study: Johnson V. Fresh Mark, Inc Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1552641-case-study-johnson-v-fresh-mark-inc.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Case Study: Johnson v. Fresh Mark, Inc

The Supreme Court of the State of Ireland

James Naughton lost a significant amount of money at the racetrack seeking solace he went to powers pub were he consumed pints of larger and five double vodkas and redbull.... The pub landlord knew him and offered him a lift home he refused (no attempt was made to dissuade him) he then walked the mile to were his car was located....
10 Pages (2500 words) Case Study

Case Study 6-2 Johnson & Johnson's Enterprise Infrastructure

johnson & johnson Company is an international American company that deals in offering consumer packaged goods, pharmaceuticals, and medical devices to its customers.... This paper discusses this approach by johnson & johnson of providing an information technology infrastructure to Case Study 6-2: johnson & johnson's Enterprise Infrastructure johnson & johnson Company is an international American company that deals in offering consumer packaged goods, pharmaceuticals, and medical devices to its customers....
2 Pages (500 words) Case Study

FreshDirect Is an Online Grocery Store Company

YourGrocer has been launched with strategy focusing on bulk buying as customers prefer to order in large quantities of goods and get instant deliveries which is being offered by this online grocery store According to johnson et al.... This paper presents the company which name is FreshDirect, it is operating in food and grocery industry and its website name is FreshDirect....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

Automobile Workers v. Johnson Controls Inc

Johnson Controls inc" describes Is the company in line with professional work ethics and fair gender opportunities act by passing the policy discriminating fertile and fertile women from working in the lead related departments.... Johnson Controls inc 1991).... Johnson Controls inc 1991).... Johnson Controls inc 1991).... Johnson Controls inc, 1991).... Johnson Controls inc 1991).... Johnson Controls inc 1991)....
4 Pages (1000 words) Case Study

Jhonsan&jhonsan case

Referencing Chapter 6: Corporate –Level Strategy: Creating Value through DiversificationJohnson & Johnson face a stiff competition from its competitors; the Pfizer inc and Novartis AG.... The aim is to expand its operations by getting into new businesses, in the area of health care, and… johnson & johnson have gained and sustained competitive advantages through acquisitions such as Pfizer's consumer health division and a $1.... These acquisitions have assisted the company to increase its market power in johnson & johnson johnson & johnson Discussion Questions and Responses What corporate strategy does johnson & johnson pursue?...
1 Pages (250 words) Case Study

Johnson & Johnson Tylenol Controversies

The case "johnson & johnson Tylenol Controversies" shows the way in which the crisis was managed by J&J and the steps taken in restoring the good reputation of the company.... hellip; The author of this paper states that johnson & johnson used to enjoy great sales of its over the counter medication....
5 Pages (1250 words) Case Study

Johnson & Johnson Corporation as a Global American Medical Device

This work "johnson & johnson Corporation as a Global American Medical Device" describes the work of this company that serves the consumer, pharmaceutical, and Medical Devices and Diagnostics markets with a focus on research-based technology-driven products.... nbsp;johnson & johnson (J&J) came into existence in response to the needs of society.... Robert Wood johnson was convinced of the discovery of Sir Lister and along with his brothers, James Wood and Edward Mead johnson formed the company johnson & johnson in 1987....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study

Launching Energy-R

This paper, Launching Energy-R, declares that marketing is one of the most prominent constituents of business dynamics.... It is integral to the operations of the firms and is regarded as one of the chief functions of the organization, amongst other departments.... hellip; The purpose of this paper is to research the market potential for an energy drink in London, UK, and to go through the aforementioned process of launching a product....
20 Pages (5000 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us