StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

What is Akrasia (incontinence) according to Aristotle in Book 7 of Nicomachean Ethics - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The psychological explanation of akrasia (incontinence) according to Aristotle is based on the perception that the actions of people are not usually uncontrolled and unrestrained. When incontinent people feel the guilt of their actions, they are usually willing and ready to…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.8% of users find it useful
What is Akrasia (incontinence) according to Aristotle in Book 7 of Nicomachean Ethics
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "What is Akrasia (incontinence) according to Aristotle in Book 7 of Nicomachean Ethics"

of Lecturer August Akrasia The psychological explanation of akrasia (incontinence) according to Aristotle is based on the perception that the actions of people are not usually uncontrolled and unrestrained. When incontinent people feel the guilt of their actions, they are usually willing and ready to abandon them. Aristotle believes that it is not the emotions and passions of people that really make them to behave or act in a particular way. It is also not the absence of reason that makes people to behave in a particular manner and Aristotle believes that akrasia poses an extraordinary challenge for moral education.

According to Aristotle, the feelings of an incontinent person are not usually more powerful than their reason as people have been made to believe (Aristotle 106).The incontinent man, knowing that what he does is bad, does it as a result of passion, while the continent man, knowing that his appetites are bad, refuses on account of rational principle to follow them. Aristotle (106) Thus, an incontinent person could also be driven by reason as well as by their feelings and emotions. Other philosophers like Socrates believed that incontinence presents a scenario where individuals have let their emotions control their lives and they have found it difficult to control their emotions.

“It would be strange. if knowledge was in a man, something else could master it and drag it about like a slave” (Aristotle 107). This was an anomaly that Aristotle sought to correct. Aristotle believes that it is on the basis of akrasia that people are influenced or propelled to act irrationally and this is not to say that these people are not logical in nature. Aristotle also opined that the incontinent people have not totally lost their sense of reasoning and even in cases that there seems to be no appreciable amount of reasoning in them, these people could still decide to behave logically, but they prefer to use the pleasures of their emotions (Aristotle 108).

Since we use the word “know” in two senses (for both the man who has knowledge but is not using it and he who is using it are said to know),it will make a difference when a man does what he should not, he hasknowledge but is not exercising it… Aristotle (109)Aristotle uses these arguments to explain the uncontrolled and unrestrained nature of the incontinent people that it is not due to the fact that they are incapable of keeping their emotions at bay and this is really not the reason that they behave in an irrational manner.

Aristotle believed that the fact that incontinent people have knowledge of their actions goes a long way to show that they also make logical calculations and people should not see them as irrational human beings that are only driven by their feelings. Aristotle believed that akrasia does not imply irrationality or ignorance as he was of the opinion that akrasia is not a total neglect of reason and that people should not assume that incontinence results only from pleasurable feelings. Aristotle agrees that the incontinent person is quite aware that his actions could lack some form of social principles and moral values, but still goes ahead to act in that way and he then went on to say that it is really not the thoughts or feelings of the incontinent people that influence their actions as believed by other philosophers that made arguments on the same subject matter (109).

This represents a great psychological dimension to the issue of akrasia and on this note, I disagree with Aristotle. I do not endorse Aristotle’s account of akrasia as incontinent people usually act based on their emotions. Let us consider the issue of sexual urges. In spite of the alarming increase in the rate of unwanted pregnancy and the issue of sexually transmitted diseases, people still allow their emotions and feelings to rule their lives not minding the consequences. These people are incontinent in nature as they have let their emotions to overpower their sense of reasoning.

The same reasons anyone would give to indulging in sexual frivolities against all odds may be applicable to kleptomaniacs. From the foregoing, it would not be far from the truth to assume that many of us, as humans, are naturally weak. I therefore do not believe that Aristotle’s psychological explanation of akrasia is valid as these incontinent people have shown that, they are weak in nature and that, they cannot control their emotions in anyway and have also shown that, they cannot give any room to reasoning in their lives.

Work CitedAristotle. Nicomachean Ethics. Ross W. D. (Ed.). Kitchener: Batoche Books. 1999.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“What is Akrasia (incontinence) according to Aristotle in Book 7 of Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1578586-what-is-akrasia-incontinence-according-to-aristotle-in-book-7-of-nicomachean-ethics
(What Is Akrasia (incontinence) According to Aristotle in Book 7 of Essay)
https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1578586-what-is-akrasia-incontinence-according-to-aristotle-in-book-7-of-nicomachean-ethics.
“What Is Akrasia (incontinence) According to Aristotle in Book 7 of Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1578586-what-is-akrasia-incontinence-according-to-aristotle-in-book-7-of-nicomachean-ethics.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF What is Akrasia (incontinence) according to Aristotle in Book 7 of Nicomachean Ethics

Nicomachean Ethics by Aristotel

The author of this essay under the title "nicomachean ethics by Aristotel" gives detailed information about the ethical considerations in the Aristotel work.... "What are the ethical considerations in Aristotle's "nicomachean ethics" R.... Kilcullen, in the article, "Aristotle's Ethics: Essay, " d 1996, accessed on 9th Jun 2008, explains Aristotle's nicomachean ethics.... Apart from this, the author tries to explain the idea of this writing and justify the central notion in the ethics of Aristotle....
1 Pages (250 words) Book Report/Review

Is Consciousness the Same as a Soul

according to him, consciousness possesses a subjective character.... Both Nagel and aristotle have the same perspective view on mind and body problems.... what Nagel is trying to put forward is that consciousness is not an aspect that can be proven by any scientific method....   For Nagel, consciousness is what makes a life form different from one another.... It occurs at many levels of animal life, though we cannot be sure of its presence in the simpler organisms, and it is very difficult to say in general what provides evidence of it”He says that the mind needs to be studied with subjectivity and objectivity attached to it....
5 Pages (1250 words) Book Report/Review

The Human and Animal Interaction According to the Book Born Free

The paper gives detailed information about the book entitled Born Free: A Lioness of Two Worlds, perhaps the most pervasive theme that is represented throughout the text.... hellip; as the author of the book attempts to describe and explain the way in which an ongoing relationship is formed between humans and an otherwise wild animal, the story itself takes shape.... The texts in the book Born Free not only offers a representation of understanding in terms of human and animal interrelationships with regard to the dependency that is created between the lioness and humans; but also in terms of the independence that should be established as a means of reintroducing this wild animal back to its natural habitat....
6 Pages (1500 words) Book Report/Review

The concept of business ethics

In the paper “The concept of business ethics” the author focuses on the concept of business ethics within the business environment.... Business ethics is concerned with the relationship that exists between the organization and its stakeholders.... hellip; The author analyzes the book Business ethics Manual, which presents a rich coverage of various issues that arise within the modern business market.... The book explores the obligations that companies have to their stakeholders, corporate social responsibility plans and issues such as bluffing that are rampant in the employment sector....
10 Pages (2500 words) Book Report/Review

Beautiful and the Damned: Portrait of New India by Siddhartha Deb

The findings that will be obtained in this phase will be used to study his philosophy in its entirely, and judge it according to the principles of ethics and social order.... hus, we support Deb in his thesis that any economic and social development, when divorced from the basic principles of morality and ethics, or when it fails to uphold the dignity of the human person, may bring the course of human development into its unnerving downfall.... This book report "Beautiful and the Damned: Portrait of New India by Siddhartha Deb" discusses at the novel and its author, and evaluate whether his thesis rings some hardcore truths not only about Indian society but modern global society in general....
6 Pages (1500 words) Book Report/Review

Business Planing and Ethics

The author of the paper discusses his philosophy surrounding the topics ethics (general concept of ethics, instinct as a driving force, my own understanding of ethics), explains the differences between a strategic plan and business plan and identifies the approach for each type of planning process… Conscience is a distinct moral-psychological mechanism, which operates from within our own souls, meticulously checking whether or not we are doing right for the society....
8 Pages (2000 words) Book Report/Review

Analysis of Peter Singers Practical Ethics Book (Chapter 10)

The author of the paper examines Peter Singer's "Practical ethics" Chapter 10 which focused on the environment.... This ethical perspective avoids waste because it discourages the hoarding of resources as a measure of success that strains the environment and instead prescribes for us to become full and contented as persons Teacher Peter Singer's Practical ethics Chapter 10 Peter Singer's Practical ethics Chapter 10 focused on the environment....
2 Pages (500 words) Book Report/Review

The Doctrine of Mean by Aristotle

He is very concerned with morals and ethics, believing that conduct has its value in reaching happiness, the ultimate end of life.... With this, he can be regarded as very passionate about the concept of the self and ethics.... The development of Aristotle's theories and concepts shows us his intelligence and his value for knowledge, life, and ethics.... … The paper "The Doctrine of Mean by Aristotle" is a worthy example of a philosophy book review....
1 Pages (250 words) Book Report/Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us