StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Rene Descartes Philosophy - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The present essay "Rene Descartes Philosophy" deals with the ideas depicted by Descartes in his works. According to the text, Rene Descartes introduces a philosophy of consciousness and self-realization. He applies the art of doubt to solve problems and bring forth the existence of a self. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.6% of users find it useful
Rene Descartes Philosophy
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Rene Descartes Philosophy"

In the Fifth Replies, Descartes writes, “I am surprised that you should say here ... that I distinctly know that I exist, but not that I know what I am or what my nature is” (71–2). Descartes seems to be insisting, contrary to his objectors, that the cogito conclusion, “I exist,” is inseparable from an understanding of the nature of self or mind as a thinking substance. Explain Descartes’ arguments in moving from the initial realization of the cogito conclusion to his claims about thinking substance, and then explain how good these arguments are in light of the criticism in the Objections or your own criticisms. Rene Descartes introduces a philosophy of consciousness and self-realization. He applies the art of doubt to solve problems and bring forth the existence of self. In the cogito, he reflects the possibilities and facts about consciousness. The initial statement of cogito reaffirms his belief in self-existence he says, “So after considering everything very thoughtfully, I must finally conclude that this preposition, I am, I exist, is necessarily true whenever it is put forward by me or conceived by my mind” (17). In fuller conclusion the issues of doubt are brought up, he says, “under thought I embrace all that which is in us so that we are immediately aware of it, a thing which exists thinks is a thing which doubts, understands….” (21). These arguments by Descartes illustrate the need for self-assessment before making conclusions. A person (thinking being) is subject to doubt, hence must first be skeptic about everything in order to end up making informed judgment. Thus, anything that exists has properties, but must be subject to some skeptic before making an informed judgment and acknowledging its existence. For example, a person sees a bottle of water, and his eyes tell him that it is there. Since this person has the premise that what his eyes sees is in fact real (or existing) it means that he knows that the bottle exists. In a similar way, Descartes explains that man (I) exists because of some attributes like body, soul, and thoughts. He goes ahead to explain that ‘I’ denies, understands, doubts, affirms, is willing, is unwilling, has sensory perception and imagines (19). This shows that an existence comes hand in hand with knowledge of properties that something possesses. Existencewithout the knowledge of its properties is even more illogical than deriving a conclusion that the existence of self also encompasses the nature of self. When René Descartes says that he thinks, therefore, he exists, it means that he is aware of what he is and what his nature is. Otherwise, there is no existence. Every existence has its properties; be it divine authority like God or as trivial as a plastic water bottle. The objection of Descartes’s claimrests with the understanding of the proposition.If criticsaccept the premise when hesays that something exists, he also bases this by understanding someproperties. The philosopher has some understanding of the nature and properties of theobject. This existence theory can also be related to the existence of God. For instance, René has confirmed many times that he doesn't understand God. But he knows that He exists, it means he is aware of certain godlike properties. These properties include all good, all powerful, and all knowing. However, the fact that he acknowledges a lack of understanding about God reveals that God is more intellect than humans and has not made it possible to have such knowledge. No one has to know the chemical composition of plastic or water to know what the properties of water and plastic are. What Descartes puts across is that one needs not to have distinct perception of an object in order to prove its existence. Knowing particular properties is enough to comprehend the existence of something, which is contrary to the critics who propose clear and distinct perception of an object to be able to assess knowledge about it. However, the big question is what is the proof that they know everything about something? Be it Renée Plato Aristotle or Kant, every philosopher or any individual has to have some understanding of any existence to be able to function properly. They do acknowledge some parts of their lives in order to establish the others. It is not a matter of absolute proof that existence describes the nature of an object, it is a matter of having sufficient proof to establish what is unknown. Therefore, point of argument between Descartes and his objectors lies in the clear and distinct perception that gives knowledge about the properties of an object, and hence, make a decision on its existence. In order to come to a point of agreement, the two sides need to acknowledge certain grey areas, which incorporate both sides of the argument. Nevertheless, what holds is that, through some knowledge about the properties of something, it can be established that it exists, and, therefore, through the existence that a person exists there is also an acknowledgment of his properties and nature. The properties may present themselves in different forms under different circumstances, but these forms give evidence to the existence of an object. For example, Descartes explains the properties of wax when it has just been picked from honeycomb, and one that has been placed by fire (20). The two show a distinct difference in terms of properties, but what holds is that they are still wax, it does not change to another object. This perhaps explains why it is not possible to have distinct perception of something because one may perceive to understand something distinctively only to realize that the perceived properties are subject to change under given conditions. The mind is a reflective organ, which questions and reacts to everything, but not everything about it is supposed to be experienced to acknowledge its existence. The example of a triangle, which he explains that if a triangle is imagined in the head, it also raises questions as to why the person is thinking about the triangle, is just the tip of the iceberg. Renée says that through imagining the triangle he can explain other shapes that can be created out of the triangle. At least it gives some insight into other shapes. Does that mean that René has seen or experienced every other shape or simply he had sufficient information to establish other disciplines of shapes? It is simply having sufficient information to establish the knowledge about the shape, and thus, its existence. Descartes’s arguments play a very important role in the general realm of criticism. They depict a realistic formula of criticizing something and making good conclusion out of it. The logic of these arguments is irrefutable by any scholar. Hence, making a decision as to existence of something does not require absolute knowledge about its properties. Work cited Descartes, René. Meditations on First Philosophy. Ed. John Cottingham. Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 1986. Print. "Full text of "The method, meditations and philosophy of Descartes. Translated from the original texts, with a new introductory essay, historical and critical by John Vietch and a special introd. by Frank Sewall"." Full text of "The method, meditations and philosophy of Descartes. Translated from the original texts, with a new introductory essay, historical and critical by John Vietch and a special introd. by Frank Sewall". N.p., n.d. Web. 6 Mar. 2014. . Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Rene Descartes Philosophy Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Rene Descartes Philosophy Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1637005-i-am-requesting-you-a-revised-essayplease-read-my-instructions-below-and-dont-be-write-highest-level-read-my-essay-that-i-have-attached-first-and-use-the-writing-style-and-level-similar-to-mine-the-essay-should-include-same-reference
(Rene Descartes Philosophy Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
Rene Descartes Philosophy Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1637005-i-am-requesting-you-a-revised-essayplease-read-my-instructions-below-and-dont-be-write-highest-level-read-my-essay-that-i-have-attached-first-and-use-the-writing-style-and-level-similar-to-mine-the-essay-should-include-same-reference.
“Rene Descartes Philosophy Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1637005-i-am-requesting-you-a-revised-essayplease-read-my-instructions-below-and-dont-be-write-highest-level-read-my-essay-that-i-have-attached-first-and-use-the-writing-style-and-level-similar-to-mine-the-essay-should-include-same-reference.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Rene Descartes Philosophy

Life of Rene Descartes

Your Name Due Date rene descartes: Life and Times Joachim Descartes, and, his wife, Jeanne Brochard, welcomed their son, Rene, on March 31, 1596.... rene descartes continued his work but would eventually retire in the Netherlands.... rene descartes died in February of 1650, at the age of 54 from complications related to pneumonia; no doubt contributed to by the cold Scandinavian weather (Skirry).... He studied many subjects, including, mathematics, science, rhetoric, verbal arts, philosophy, and astronomy....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Descartes Account of What Is Necessary for Knowledge

Often called the father of modern philosophy, Descartes introduced a shift in thinking from the empiricist school of thought in which people believed all knowledge ultimately… Through this development in thought, he was also the founder of modern day mathematics and provided the framework for study of In developing these ideas, Descartes wrote several books regarding the nature of existence and knowledge, providing us with plenty of material to study and has had tremendous influence on those who have come after him....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Meditation on First Philosophy, by Rene Descartes http://classicallibrary.org/descartes/meditations/

In continuing his thoughts Meditation on First Philosophy by rene descartes I agree with Descartes' reasoning behind the existence of God.... To help prove his argument, descartes tries to understand where the idea of God originally came from.... In his third meditation, descartes states that ideas come from three different sources: innate ideas,… Innate ideas are naturally within us; adventitious ideas are derived from our own personal experiences; and invented ideas are linked directly to our imaginations....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Supreme Being and Created Things: Rene Descartes, Principles of Philosophy

Eminent fourteenth century philosopher rene descartes has elaborated the attributes of the Creator in the light of His creation and their characteristics.... Since creatures, Module Module ID: Supreme Being and Created Things Eminent fourteenth century philosopher rene descartes has elaborated the attributes of the Creator in the light of His creation and their characteristics.... Work CitedCottingham, John Western philosophy: an Anthology John Wiley & Sons 1996 78-81...
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Philosophy of David Hume in response to Rene Descartes

Since an a priori knowledge is essential to rationalists, Descartes subjects… To him, the process of building knowledge upon pure cognition enables a rational person to yield to clarity and distinction of ideas as he Show how the philosophy of David Hume was a response to the philosophy of rene descartes, and how the Philosophy of Immanuel Kant was a response to the philosophy of David Hume.... On the contrary, Hume responds by demonstrating his philosophy on empiricism whereby an a posteriori knowledge is required apart from analytical endeavor for such theory posits that matters of fact in the world may only be ascertained by perceiving through the senses....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Meditation on first philosophy, Rene Descartes, 3 pages attached follow the instruction

Citing from some of the best arguments put forth by previous philosophers, Meditation on First Philosophy, rene descartes Meditation on First Philosophy, rene descartes SummaryThis treatise seeks to demonstrate to the reader that through philosophy, the existence of God, and the soul can be proven using ancient philosophical truths.... nalysis rene descartes believes that most people would rather seek out what is wrong than defend the truth which they cannot understand....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

The Fifth Replies of Descartes

… In the Fifth Replies, descartes writes, “I am surprised that you should say here .... descartes seems to be insisting, contrary to his objectors, that the cogito conclusion, “I exist,” is inseparable from an understanding of the nature of self or mind as a thinking substance.... The Fifth Replies of descartes The argument in question is the argument of Discourse.... Renée descartes says that he knows he exists it is inherent that he knows what he is and what his nature is, it is the very definition of establishing his existence....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Descartes and Elisabeth

In her letters, Elisabeth seeks to clarify Descartes idea of dualism by Descartes and Elisabeth The correspondence between Princess Elisabeth of Bohemia and rene descartes yielded a total of fifty eight letters.... The letters provide a chance for any individual interested in understanding Descartes's philosophy.... The letters offer Descartes's philosophy on human being as… The correspondence offers the reader with an insight into the development of ideas through intellectual collaboration and the characters of the authors....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us