StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Love and Aggressiveness in Freuds Civilization and Its Discontents - Book Report/Review Example

Cite this document
Summary
The aim of the current book report is to discuss the relationship between love and aggressiveness as depicted in the work "Civilization and its Discontents" written by Sigmund Freud. The writer of the report will specifically reference the chapters 5 and 7…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93% of users find it useful
Love and Aggressiveness in Freuds Civilization and Its Discontents
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Love and Aggressiveness in Freuds Civilization and Its Discontents"

Discuss the relationship between love and aggressiveness in Freud’s Civilization and its Discontents1, making especial reference to chapters 5 and 7.Love and aggressiveness are very closely related in Freud’s conception of a person’s social interactions. Both allow the individual to satisfy the desires of his ego: love-relationships provide satisfaction of desires either through sexual satisfaction, or (in friendships) through aid to achieve the individual’s aims; aggressiveness towards other people allows the individual to satisfy the desires of his ego undisturbed by competition from others. Freud discusses the origins of our sentiments of aggression (especially as involved in feelings of guilt) in chapter seven of Civilization and its Discontents, and finds them to be intimately involved with feelings of love; equally, sentiments of love often originate from feelings of aggression. Finally, Freud deploys his concepts of love and aggression to show that civilized societies are bound to fail: they place restrictions on our natural sentiments of love and aggressiveness which are in many cases insupportable – in particular, he criticises societies founded on the Christian principle of love, and those founded on communist ideas. Freud’s discussion of the origins of our aggressiveness show how strongly it is related to love, as he conceives it. The initial aggressive sentiment is directed inwards, at the child’s own ego, Freud claims, due to a frustration of the desires of the child’s ego. This ‘introjected’ aggressive impulse results in the formation of the super-ego, and so the initiation of feelings of guilt. For example, when a child is forbade by a parent to do something which is desired by his ego, he initially feels aggressiveness towards that parent as a result of the frustration of his desires. However, since aggressiveness cannot be directed towards the parent, it is directed at the ego, the source of the frustrated desire. Why can aggressiveness not be directed at a parent (or another figure of authority)? Here, Freud shows how essential he believes the concept of love to be to the formation of aggressive impulses: the child directs aggressiveness towards his own ego rather than towards the figure of authority because of a “fear of loss of love” (p. 757). Thus, the need for love is instrumental in the formation of the super-ego, which results in aggressive impulses directed at the ego: self-hating feelings of guilt. In situations where aggressiveness is in fact directed towards the figure of authority, and not introjected, love is still essential to the changes in the individual’s psychological make-up. Freud claims that this would only happen in situations involving the Oedipus complex: that is, when sons kill their fathers. This supposedly was a more common occurrence in earlier societies which were less bound by ‘civilizing’ restrictions. Here, the actual aggression involved in killing the father results in a feeling of remorse at the action: this is because of the love that the son naturally has for his father. Hence, for Freud, the origins of feelings of aggression are always bound up with feelings of love. However, it is not obvious that non-repressed aggression need always be followed by feelings of remorse. As stated above, Freud believes that the only cases of actual aggression by a child will be from a son to his father, and, since this relationship necessarily involves some love, remorse is a necessary consequence. However, it is not clear that son-to-father aggression would be the only case of actual aggression from a child to a figure of authority – a child may show aggression towards a teacher or minder, for example – and if aggression is directed at others, there may not be a necessary bond of love from the child to these people, so remorse may not be a necessary consequence. Freud’s assumption is that a child’s initial authoritative influence will be from his father, so it is towards the father that initial aggression (suppressed or not) will be directed. Whilst this assumption will usually hold, it is clearly not true in all cases – consider, for example, orphans. Regardless of this objection, it seems fair to allow that it is the conflict between feelings of love and the original sentiments of aggression that result in guilt and remorse in nearly all possible cases, and perhaps in all actual cases. This said, Freud also claims that, “aggressiveness […] forms the basis of every relation of affection and love among people” (p. 751). This is due to the fact that he sees love as essentially a self-serving phenomenon: through love-relationships, individuals are able to temper the aggressiveness of others towards them, enlist the aid of others in achieving their own desires and defending themselves from the aggressiveness of their enemies, and fulfil their sexual desires (in explicitly sexual love-relationships). Evidence for this reading of Freud’s conception of love-relationships can be found in chapter five of Civilization and its Discontents: Freud writes, “if I love someone, he must deserve it in some way […] he deserves it if he is so like me in important ways that I can love myself in him; and he deserves it if he is so much more perfect than myself that I can love my ideal of my own self in him” (p. 748) – therefore, for Freud, love is an egotistical construct. Thus, it is our own aggressiveness towards other people, and their potential aggressiveness towards us, that causes us to form love-relationships. In turn, this aggressiveness stems from our very nature – Freud writes of the “primary mutual hostility of human beings” (p. 750) – and is designed to allow the fulfilment of the desires of our ego. Thus, our feelings of love and aggression, the formation of each being dependent on the other, are constructed egotistically in order to fulfil our desires. It is from these ideas of the nature of the sentiments of love and aggression that Freud derives his critique of civilized society. Social interactions with other human beings and the structuring of these interactions by a society necessarily result in the restriction of these sentiments. Hence, to put it simply, our natural sentiments of love and aggression are restricted by civilization, and so are bound to lead to the frustration of the individual. It is civilization which causes the inhibition of our initial sentiments of aggression, and so leads to the feelings of guilt described above. Equally, civilization necessarily imposes “a restriction upon sexual life” (p. 747), and so restricts the love-relationships that an individual would naturally form. Freud demonstrates that civilization is unviable by criticising two different socio-political ideals: Christian society and communism. Freud’s criticism of Christian societies (which extends to most non-Christian western societies) is based on a criticism of the fundamental tenet of Christianity and other moralities: ‘love thy neighbour as thyself’. This doctrine, Freud says, is based on a misunderstanding of human nature: we cannot truly love someone who is not in some way deserving of our love. In the first place, to do this undermines our relationships with those who are deserving of our love: “it is an injustice to them [the people I love] if I put a stranger on a par with them” (p. 748). Secondly, it runs against the egotism of our nature to love oneself so little as this doctrine implies: if I am to love everyone equally, then I must love each person only a very little; if I am to love each person as myself, then I must love myself only a very little. But this is contradictory to my nature, so it is impossible to love everyone as much as I love myself. It might be objected, though, that Freud here conceives of love as something of which each person only has a defined quantity to give; however, he gives no evidence of this, and indeed it would seem that love does not work like this – we can love new people without diminishing the strength of our love towards those we originally loved (e.g. our parents). Another of Freud’s criticisms of the Christian doctrine is that it requires an individual to love his enemies: this is impossible and absurd, because it requires loving those who are not worthy of love – it is contradictory to the egotistical nature of love-relationships as Freud conceives them. Communism, on the other hand, fails by misinterpreting the nature of human aggression. The essential idea of communism is that removing ownership will remove human aggressiveness; however, Freud counters this by pointing out that aggressiveness is the result of any restrictions on the fulfilment of our desires, not just restriction on the fulfilment of those desires involving property ownership. He writes: “in abolishing private property we deprive the human love of aggression of one of its instruments […] but we have in no way altered the differences in power and influence which are misused by aggressiveness, nor have we altered anything in its nature” (p. 751). Thus, sentiments of aggressiveness are not abolished in communist systems, since there is still power, and there are still restrictions on some of our desires – e.g. sexual desires. In conclusion, I hope to have shown here that love and aggressiveness are very closely linked in Freud’s conception of our psychology. Initial sentiments of aggressiveness are based on frustration of a child’s egotistical desires; sentiments of love are initially directed at parents. Since parents tend to be figures of authority, these sentiments combine to create the super-ego, and feelings of guilt and remorse. Each of love and aggressiveness often stems from the other (according to Freud’s definition of them), and both are ultimately involved in serving the desires of the ego. Thus, according to Freud, “civilized society is perpetually threatened with disintegration.” (p. 750) because it restricts the natural scope of our sentiments of love and aggression, and so frustrates our egotistical desires. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Love and Aggressiveness in Freuds Civilization and Its Discontents Book Report/Review - 1, n.d.)
Love and Aggressiveness in Freuds Civilization and Its Discontents Book Report/Review - 1. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1703515-discuss-the-relationship-between-love-and-aggressivity-in-freuds-civilization-and-its-discontents
(Love and Aggressiveness in Freuds Civilization and Its Discontents Book Report/Review - 1)
Love and Aggressiveness in Freuds Civilization and Its Discontents Book Report/Review - 1. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1703515-discuss-the-relationship-between-love-and-aggressivity-in-freuds-civilization-and-its-discontents.
“Love and Aggressiveness in Freuds Civilization and Its Discontents Book Report/Review - 1”. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1703515-discuss-the-relationship-between-love-and-aggressivity-in-freuds-civilization-and-its-discontents.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Love and Aggressiveness in Freuds Civilization and Its Discontents

Love and Aggressiveness Are Very Closely Related in Freuds Conception

hellip; Freud discusses the origins of our sentiments of aggression (especially as involved in feelings of guilt) in chapter seven of civilization and its discontents, and finds them to be intimately involved with feelings of love; equally, sentiments of love often originate from feelings of aggression.... love and aggressiveness are very closely related in Freud's conception of a person's social interactions.... Finally, Freud deploys his concepts of love and aggression to show that civilized societies are bound to fail: they place restrictions on our natural sentiments of love and aggressiveness which are in many cases insupportable - in particular, he criticises societies founded on the Christian principle of love, and those founded on communist ideas....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Beauty and Order in Civilization

n civilization and its discontents Freud asks the question, why is humanity not happy?... n civilization and its discontents Freud asks the question , why is humanity not happy Freud reasons that the suffering of humanity has three main causes-"The superior powers of nature, the feebleness of our own bodies and the inadequacy of regulations which adjust the mutual relationships of the human beings in family, state and society"(Freud,274) According to Freud , man needs civilization for his security against the superior powers of nature....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The Gypsies And Their Journey

Sigmund Freud, founder of psychoanalysis, offers as a locus of analysis in his civilization and its discontents this notion of aggression towards an out-group as a major obstacle to civilization, "the inclination to aggression is an original, self-sustaining instinctual disposition.... civilization and its discontents.... It constitutes the greatest impediment to civilization [sic]" (81).... The treatment of the Gypsies in Europe is paradigmatic of the deleterious effects on civilization as a result of this instinctual disposition toward violence and aggression....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Understanding Modern Conflict

On the one hand, it is aggression of an individual against others, a classic case of the the individual's death drive unleashing its negative energy.... Let us consider the books, love My Rifle More than You by Kayla Williams and Bury me Standing by Isabel Fonseca....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Pressures Applied by Civilization: a Choice to Happiness

Regardless of the pressures applied by civilization it is the individual that ultimately… Kayla Williams on the other hand has seen a staggering degree of cruelty.... According to Freud, civilization is what "describes the whole sum of achievements and the regulations which distinguish our lives from those of our animal ancestors and which serve two purposes namely to protect men against nature and to adjust their mutual...
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Frankenstein by James Whale and Freud

civilization and its discontents (Freud) largely dwells on the superego, ego, and the id nature of humankind that mainly aims at benefiting one's desires but fails to protect the surrounding environment (Heffner).... The id does not care about anything else but only cares about satisfying its own will.... The rules set by the society have severe punishment if broken hence human beings become discontented by the simple act of civilization.... The third section of Sigmund's book addresses the aspect of civilization that has been both advantageous and disadvantageous for humankind....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Civilization in Human Mind

Freud in his book civilization and its discontents explain this phenomenon by using psychological terms to define the human state of mind regarding the rules of civilization and his duty to follow them.... Controlled by his own values Jobs was least concerned about society and its expectations from him.... rdquo; Steve Jobs's personality was in many conflicts with society and its values.... The paper "civilization in Human Mind" states that civilization is not a path to be followed, it's the history in an individual's life which hampers the growth in an individual....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The Progress of Civilization in the Modern World

As the paper "The Progress of civilization in the Modern World" outlines, there are very many aspects that must come together before a community develops to high levels of sophistication which is commonly referred to as civilization.... hellip; In-depth psychoanalysis can offer detailed information regarding the formation of civilization.... This is important in the understanding of the major factors that were involved and the main aspects that need to be taken into consideration when determining the progress of civilization in the modern world....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us