StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Leibniz's Mental Mill - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Leibniz's Mental Mill" states that it is crucial to continue studying various theories advanced by both the old and modern philosophers to make the understanding of humanity clear. There should be a clear distinction between the elements of philosophy and their applicability in life. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.7% of users find it useful
Leibnizs Mental Mill
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Leibniz's Mental Mill"

Instruction: Task: Leibnizs Mental Mill Philosophy is an important discipline especially in the comprehension of life and the nature of things. Therefore, this calls for various philosophers to make explanations to phenomena such as religion, life, politics and even psychology. Similarly, it is imperative to understand the principles and ideologies that form the body of philosophy and those that explain the mental processes of human being. In other words, there is the need to assess the relation between the thinking of a human being to his/her immediate actions (Umphrey 56). This is what led famous philosophers such as Leibniz, Moore and Hume among other notable researchers to formulate theories of analyzing the functioning of the human brain. For example, Leibniz came with the Mental Mill analogy that says that all actions are controlled by the mind. On the other hand, Moore refuted the claims by stating that the use of common sense was both inherent and logical in helping humanity to make decisions. According to Gottfried Leibniz’s Mental Mill, physical processes do not give assessment of the thinking process of human beings. Instead, there is an existence of mystery of the workings of the brain that led him to equate it to a person entering a machine. Therefore, in terms of personal identity and freedom versus determinism, there are interesting issues to note. For example, all human beings have the right to control their thought processes through the way parts of machine operate. Similarly, it is an innate ability of the mind to function like a mental mill in terms of pushing and moving one another to operation (Umphrey 59). The mental mill analogy by Leibniz also helps individuals in dissociating the materialistic thinking. In other words, there is no physicality of thinking with personal identity hence making the understanding of the human mind complex. This influences the individual perception of situations in the development of personal identity. However, it is essential to note that the perception theory also manipulates freedom and determinism of a person. For example, in the Mental Mill scenario, it is upon a person to extract freedom of perception for an element of determinism (Umphrey 35). This is through realization that determinism occurs because of some past event. In the same prospect, the Mental Mill theory asserts that the freedom of personal identity arises from a pre-determined reality of existence. It also affirms the belief of personal conscience that the mind works according to a pre-existent process in the same way as a machine. Therefore, because of Leibniz Mental Mill theory, several philosophers emerged with varying reactions in the formulation of their thoughts. For example, G. E. Moore in his book Defense of Common Sense emphasize that the human being must have the control of some external influence in order to function efficiently “…empiricism represents a giant leap forward in human thought (Umphrey 44).” He also refutes the notions proposed by Leibniz by stating that there is absolute certainty in all our beliefs. Alternatively, Moore proposed the theory of truism where he states that everything is guided by common sense instead of a Mental Mill being in control. Another philosopher who had interesting views on Leibniz’s proposition was Bertrand Russell. The British born scholar argued that there was freedom of thought for every individual and things such as attachment to physicality or mentality of thought did not exist. However, his impression of Gottfried Leibniz led to his discovery of analytic philosophy. Therefore, unlike his mentor and role model, Russell majored in the field of metaphysics to explain the functions and operations of human being. Analytic philosophy also explained its concepts using both in language analysis and formal logic. In that case, there are similar elements that also influenced another philosopher who reacted to the works and research of Leibniz. For example, Gottlob Frege used logical positivism in understanding the rational clarification of truths to establish a common stand. On that note, he also incorporated fundamental investigation of reasoning where there is an evaluation of principles based on tested constructs. This meant there was a continuity of inquiries in terms of freedoms and determinism explained by Leibniz in the Mental Mill analogy. In contrast, there was also Ludwig Wittgenstein who subscribed to the philosophy of foundationalism. Ludwig argued that there are underlying reasons and principles behind most things in the world “…concept of time is inconsistent and therefore cannot be exemplified in reality (Umphrey 46).” This could happen either consciously or unconsciously especially in the formulation of thought to understand external forces. Additionally, there is an element of understanding the logical system of the social constructs of humanity in relation to the use of language during clarification. However, this philosophy is in contrast to the proposition held be Gottfried Leibniz that the mental processes are influenced by deterministic forces. Therefore, there are several merits of the above philosophies advanced by Leibniz, Moore, Gottlob and Ludwig. For example, they help people in the clarification of their deep-seated beliefs especially in answering the questions of life. This has the benefit of enhancing their thinking concerning controversial questions about life. Therefore, these issues raised by the authors’ philosophical study assist in the formulation of critical assessments. Furthermore, the issues help institutions of society such as in law and government whereby the mental arguments of the offender are paramount during the trials. The issues raised by the philosophers’ aid in the comprehension of religion especially in these days of doubts in God. For example, the Mental Mill analogy by Leibniz is fundamental in identifying the personal identity of an individual in the context of selecting his/her beliefs. This is in the form of recognizing the enshrined freedoms of thought and choice including the theory of determinism (Umphrey 67). On the other hand, it assists in the establishment of stronger democracies and economic systems when using the philosophies of Gottlob and Ludwig. This is in terms of the ideas of logical clarification of truths that may have a background on past injustices. In other words, there is a chance to distinguish between actions and things in forming the framework of a philosophical inquiry. In the same breadth, the ideas of metaphysics helps in understand how theories such as idealism, mechanism, materialism and teleology affect humanity. Therefore, materialism theory that insists that real existence is only found in matter and phenomena such as thoughts and feelings are generated by the activity of an occurrence. This suggests that while people apply thoughts and feelings in understanding different scenarios of life, there is the attachment to existence that influences human beings. Additionally, there is idealism that holds that ideas bind every material thing hence the most critical phenomena is the mental part (Umphrey 71). This is what Leibniz espoused in his Mental Mill theory by noting that the working the brain through various mental processes help in decision-making skills. In contrast, there is also the mechanism theory that has its origin in foundationalism by Ludwig Wittgenstein and it attests that mechanical forces influence things. This is different from elements of purpose or a sense of universal background as noted by the theory of teleology. On that perspective, it is crucial to continue studying various theories advanced by both the old and modern philosophers to make the understanding of humanity clear. Additionally, there should be a clear distinction between the elements of philosophy and their applicability in life. This is in the form of conducting logical and rational comparisons between various theories for synthesis and evaluation (Umphrey 52). It would help in solving modern day problems that are mostly caused because of wrong decisions. Work Cited Umphrey, Stewart. Complexity and Analysis. Belmont, MA: Lexington Books. 2002. Print. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Philosophy Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words - 27, n.d.)
Philosophy Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words - 27. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1783699-philosophy
(Philosophy Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words - 27)
Philosophy Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words - 27. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1783699-philosophy.
“Philosophy Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words - 27”. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1783699-philosophy.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Leibniz's Mental Mill

Provide an argument for the claim that (some) mental states are not identical to any brain state

Argumentative Essay Introduction There have been different philosophical theories about brain state and mental state.... Brain state refers to the physiological condition of the brain or the nervous system, while the mental state refers to the pains, desires, thoughts, and beliefs.... Some mental states (beliefs) are not identical to any brain state The first argument being focused in this paper is the difference between mental and brain states....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Music alone by Peter Kivy

On pg 40-41, the stimulation model is not embraced by Kivy as it doesn't account for the mental aspect of listening to music or relating to it.... Kivy verifies his stance yet again by extracting the intellectual aspect of ‘counting' from leibniz's account p.... To understand Kivy's work, one has to understand the roots of his representational theory....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Doctrine of Determinism

This paper ''Doctrine of Determinism'' tells that There is perception and there is reality.... Some thoughts pervade and some thoughts provoke.... Questions and uncertainty abound.... Is the perception of reality real?... The first step on the journey of revelation begins with doubting all that we have been taught to believe....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

From Leibniz: Letters to Arnauld

Student nameInstructor nameCourse nameDateLeibniz's Letter to Arnauld The primary argument of leibniz's letters to Arnauld is to determine the true nature of material objects.... As he makes his case for his way of reasoning, leibniz's argument is seen to be based upon the Scholastic concept of the substantial form as something existential from the material element.... This, in itself, suggests there is some weight to leibniz's argument as individual understanding plays such an important role in assigning designations to elements....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

MENTAL HEALTH AND THE LAW (GUILTY BUT MENTALLY ILL)

This… There was a loss of his mental faculties which connotes he is not aware of the consequences of the crime.... There are several high-profile cases in which the accused got off from penalties and mental HEALTH AND THE LAW (Guilty but Mentally Sick) ID Number: of of School (University)Estimated Word Count: 614Date of Submission: January 31, 2012MENTAL HEALTH AND THE LAWIntroductionThe administration of justice is based on the principles of retribution, equity and use of just punishment (in relation to the gravity of the crime committed)....
2 Pages (500 words) Research Paper

Who were the two people who discovered Calculus

The priority issues involved philosophical beliefs shared by both scholars, especially those that Newton held, contrary to leibniz's values.... There exists controversy over the origin of calculus as a field of mathematics or applied science based on the question of the people who founded it....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Malebranche and Leibniz Solution to Evil

The paper "Malebranche and Leibniz Solution to Evil" examines two theories, provided by philosophists Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz and Nicolas Malebranche, which explain and discuss the concepts of the problem of evil in the world and possible solution to these problems.... hellip; The problem of evil has been categorized variously, but the major categorizations of evil entail physical evil on the one hand, and moral evil, on the other hand....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Voltaires Satire on Optimism

hellip; In the novella, “Candide” Voltaire deals with a series of themes such as the 'folly of Optimism', 'bitterness of stern reality, 'futility of philosophical speculation', 'the corrupting effect of money, 'hypocrisy of the religious system', etc that are stitched together with the common thread that leibniz's optimistic philosophy simply failed to perceive the reality.... Pangloss's optimism can be defended on the ground that the best possible world does not necessarily mean that there is no evil in this world like 'the Garden' that Voltaire takes for the embodiment of leibniz's optimistic world....
1 Pages (250 words) Book Report/Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us