StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

A Grief Observed by Lewis in Reference to Historical and Contemporary Views of Bereavement and Grief - Term Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
The author of the paper "A Grief Observed by Lewis in Reference to Historical and Contemporary Views of Bereavement and Grief " argues in a well-organized manner that in his darkest moments, the author of the article "A Grief Observed " had to tackle the intensity of his despair…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.4% of users find it useful

Extract of sample "A Grief Observed by Lewis in Reference to Historical and Contemporary Views of Bereavement and Grief"

Analysis of A Grief Observed in reference to Historical and Contemporary Views of Bereavement and Grief (Student Name) (Institutional Affiliation) (Nursing) (Instructor) April 8, 2013 ANALYSIS OF A GRIEF OBSERVED BY LEWIS Very few people would deny the demise of their loved ones, especially of a child or a spouse is one of the greatest heart breaking encounters that we as human beings are supposed to bear, and a number of psychologists have outlined various stages of the process of typical grieving and they are: numbness and shock at the beginning, then great anger and intense mourning becoming the intermediate period, and finally sense of restoration and healing (Bowlby, 1962b). Dr. Elizabeth Kubler Ross is one such person, who was a psychiatrist from Swiss who deployed most of her time studying and comforting people in her hospital. Kubler transformed the manner in which the world viewed the incurably ill people, and promoted care and companion for them. Her five stages of grief are as follows and will be explained in the context of Lewis’ “A Grief Observed”. Denial: The bereaved people will allows deny what has happened. Anger: they must find someone to blame for the cause of the death (blame). Bargaining: they give reasons why they want life to continue Depression: they feel very sad Acceptance: they will come to terms with peace and accept what is ahead (Kubler-Ross, 1969). As illustrated in his extremely personal article, A Grief Observed, besides Lewis C.S underwent similar phases following the demise of his dearly loved wife Joy Davidman as a result of cancer. However, the article is not quite much Lewis’ account of grief but rather a manifestation of grief; a testimony of his instant feelings and thoughts as he seemingly searches in vain at the beginning, for some kind of solace in the demise of his wife as well as the separation it caused. The feelings and thoughts documented in the article tell Lewis’ camaraderie with the rest of humankind. He desperately wanted for his worldly life with his wife to go on and to carry on in the type he had come to realize. Had his wife been magically transported to a phenomenal life to another planet, he could have been grieved no less because of the separation. Hence he wrote: “You tell me, she goes on”. But my body and my heart are weeping out, come back, come back” (Musacchio, 1998). In other words, it not because of her past torment, but his personal need – his personal connection to the life he is been used to, that has absorbed his attention here. Lewis knows that the thing he wants is precisely the thing he cannot get at all; the jokes, the old life, the arguments, the drinks, they tiny, the love-making, and the commonplace heartbreaking. Even in the profundity of his despondency, Lewis appeared not capable to delude himself (Kubler-Ross, 1969). However, in his darkest moments, he still had to tackle the intensity of his despair, and his articles reports a captivating dialect between his profound feelings on one side and on the other side, his theological reckoning. In the last sentences of Chapter II, for instance, a hysterical Lewis in consequently lays blame on God for having obstructed every hope and every prayer with strange remissions and false diagnoses (Grosskurth, 1987). Evidently, Lewis was completely cognizant of internal battle wagging between his feelings and his intellect. At the start of chapter III, he hence calls out: “Feelings, feelings and feelings. Instead let me try to think. From the rational perspective, what new element has the death of [my wife] brought into the quandary of the earth” (Musacchio,1998). He gives more obvious answers, to imply that the death of his wife has not introduced into the early problems, and he is aware that such things or even worse occurs daily… and humanity was assured of sufferings. Bereavement in the Contemporary World Scholars have frequently applied the term modernist to typify the contemporary cultural zeitgeist of Western society, in distinction with that of earlier century, which has often been referred to as romanticist (Miller, Galanter & Pribram, 1960). Some of the major characteristics of cultural modernism comprise emphasis on observation and reason as well as faith in incessant progress. The approach of modernism to life is one that underlines efficiency, goal directedness, and rationality. Modernism, in psychological aspect has enhanced human functionality and when used in the context of grief, this perspective implies that human beings need to heal from the condition of extreme emotionality and get back to their normal effectiveness and functioning as efficiently and as fast as possible (Mains, Arend, & Sroufe, 1978). Modernism premises of grief as well as their associated therapeutic mediations persuade people who have encountered loss to react in just this manner. Grieving, which is an emotional debilitating reaction, is viewed as a wearisome interference with usual routines and hence has to be worked through. In view of both counseling practices and theoretical formulations, researchers time after time highlight relationship with the spouse to be one of the greatest risk elements for poor bereavement outcomes. Robertson & Bowlby (2002) explored two major pathological grief causes, which come as a result of problematic matrimonial bonds. One such problem following Freud, is referred to as the ambivalent grief syndrome, which means a relationship whereby elements of hate and love coexisted, disagreements were rampant, and separation or divorce could have been contemplated( Lindskoog, 2008). The bereaved, after the loss could still be attached to the departed, but in an insecure manner. The other syndrome is known as the chronic grief syndrome, and it follows an end of a relationship that is characterized as clinging or highly dependent. It is worth mentioning that features of a strongly bonded matrimonial relationship have been observed not only as the pathology cause, but also as the main contributor to deplorable adjustment among the bereaved as in the case of Lewis and others in general. Vanauken (2011) observed ineptitude in widowhood to be associated with earlier matrimonial roles. A widow who has deeply engaged in the lives of her husband and who were socially as well as psychologically dependent on him, exhibit major problems to adjust as opposed to the ones who were probably more autonomous. As noted above, the contemporary perceptions of grief among the professionals highlight the significance of the problematic implications and breaking bonds of relationships that are deeply dependent (Bowlby, 1962b). Appropriate bereavement requires that bonds with the departed has to be relinquished, and therapy and counseling plans be established to enhance the breaking of the bonds. In this line, then it follows that an individual who is autonomous and independent in marriage will experience less problems in breaking the ties and hence will encounter less problematic grief experience (Blatz, 2010). The traditional Perspective of Bereavement Even though the breaking ties orientation seems from the modernist angle to have universal implication scope, its spatiotemporal shortcomings become evident when looked at in the traditional contrast. A study on the traditional cultures indicates the beliefs regarding the worth of continuing ties with the departed vary greatly (Ainsworth, 2009). In contrast to the contemporary views, the maintenance of bond with the departed is sustained and accepted by some Yamamoto, Japanese religious rituals. The deceased stays accessible and the bereaved can converse with the deceased or give goodies such as cigars or food… the bereaved remains with the deceased forever (Dorsett, 2011). On quick contrast to the contemporary and Japanese grief patterns are those of some American tribes, for example among the Arizona Hopis. The deceased are quickly forgotten and life is intended to move on as normal as possible (Blehar, 2004). The bereaved may experience the loss pain, however the offer themselves over to no evident expression of grief. The practice is congenial with their customs concerning the afterworld. These people believe that any contact with demise causes pollution and they fear death and the deceased, whose has a depersonalized spirit. Conclusion A general perspective of the contemporary and traditional patters of grief in respect to “A grief Observed” by Lewis C. S, show that various groups of people carry out different patterns of habits and share diverse meaning systems through which their acts are recognized. Hence, actions deemed pathological, maladjusted or aberrant on a certain cultural setting could be completely acceptable in the other. There can be no fixed prescriptions for dealing with bereavement and grief. Each and every person must grow through it, live through it and live with it. There can be no fixed grief durations, in spite of the theories of time-based bereavement models. Responding with care and sensitivity, and empathizing with the bereaved as they undergo grief are what is important. Our beliefs, attitudes and values about bereavement and death are not cast on stone, however are modified by and responsive to social, economic and historical forces. People’s attitudes toward loss are social founded therefore we should expect mourners to react differently across different cultural settings. Death also entails assuming a new, perhaps unwelcome role – orphan or widower as well as ways of life that were unknown previously. References Ainsworth, M. (2009). Attachments beyond infancy. American Psychologist, 44, 709-716. Ainsworth, M & Bell, S. M. (2009). Some contemporary patterns in the feeding situation. In A. Ambrose (Ed,), Stimulation in early infancy (pp. 133-170). London: Academic Press. Bowlby, J. (1962b). Loss, detachment and defense. Unpublished manuscript, Tavistock Child Development Research Unit, London. Blatz, W. (2010), Hostages to peace: Parents and the children of democracy. New York: Morrow. Blehar, M. C. (2004). Anxious attachment and defensive reactions associated with day care. Child Development, 45, 683-692. Dorsett, W.(2011). And God Came In. New York: MacMillan Publishing Co. Kubler-Ross, Elizabeth, (1969). On Death and Dying. New York: Macmillan Publishing Co. Lindskoog, K.(2008). Light in the Shadowlands. Sisters: Multnomah Books. Grosskurth, P. (1987). Melanie Klein: Her world and her work, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. MacDonald, G. (2001). The Consuming Fire,? reprinted in Rolland Hein (ed.), Creation in Christ(Grand Rapids: Eerdmans. Musacchio, George(1998). Fiction in A Grief Observed,? VII: An Anglo-American Literary Review, Mains, L., Arend, B.. A., & Sroufe, L. A. (1978). Continuity and adaptation in the second year: The relationship between quality of attachment and later competence. Child Development, 49, 547-556. Miller, G. A., Galanter, F., & Pribram, K. H. (1960). Plans and the structure of behavior. New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston. Robertson, J. & Bowlby, J. (2002). Responses of young children to separation from their mothers. Courrier of the International Children’s Centre, Paris, II, 131-140. Sroufe, L. A., & Waters, B. (1977). Attachment as an organizational construct. Child Development, 49, 1184-1199. Vanauken, S. (2011). A Severe Mercy: San Francisco: Harper and Rowe. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Analysis of A Grief Observed in reference to Historical and Term Paper, n.d.)
Analysis of A Grief Observed in reference to Historical and Term Paper. https://studentshare.org/psychology/2061602-read-a-grief-observed-by-c-s-lewis-1966-with-reference-to-historical-and-contemporary
(Analysis of A Grief Observed in Reference to Historical and Term Paper)
Analysis of A Grief Observed in Reference to Historical and Term Paper. https://studentshare.org/psychology/2061602-read-a-grief-observed-by-c-s-lewis-1966-with-reference-to-historical-and-contemporary.
“Analysis of A Grief Observed in Reference to Historical and Term Paper”. https://studentshare.org/psychology/2061602-read-a-grief-observed-by-c-s-lewis-1966-with-reference-to-historical-and-contemporary.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF A Grief Observed by Lewis in Reference to Historical and Contemporary Views of Bereavement and Grief

Grief Holistic Approach

In the paper “grief – Holistic Approach” the author analyzes the reason of grief or the effect of the same, which may be varied according to the significance, timing and implications of the incident for each individual but the general holistic approach associated with grief remains the same.... hellip; According to the author, the grief can be prolonged and complicated but in maximum cases it was a normal and needful adjustment response of an individual for a particular incident....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Kubler-Rosss Five-Stage Model of Grief

Even before contemporary scholars began to look at the nature of the grieving process or, basically, ‘grief', different religions already illustrated several of the attributes of grief that would be distinguished by modern psychologists.... The story of Job in the Holy Bible… In numerous literatures on grief it has been believed that a systematic sequence takes place through separate stages which can be characterized by specific Running head: Nursing The Grieving Process Essay Outline Even before contemporary scholars began tolook at the nature of the grieving process or, basically, ‘grief', different religions already illustrated several of the attributes of grief that would be distinguished by modern psychologists....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Kubler-Ross Grief Model

In the essay “Healthy grief” the author looks at the first stages of Kubler-Ross' grief model.... After the individual has processed his initial grief emotions, he is able to accept that the loss has happened and undoing it is impossible.... Job's stages of grief can be illustrated by the following chart.... igure 1: The extended grief cycle.... He views himself as doomed to die a hated, despised, lonely, and broken person....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Bereavement Care

These people are therefore at a more comfortable position to not only handle death but also bereavement and grief issues in general than those living in cities.... With the 9/11 bombing however, most people came to terms with being bereaved and grief after a massive number of people lost their lives.... These people are able to grief more comfortably and handle bereavement in an… For those who have not had such previous history or death happened when they were really young and could not understand grief for them becomes “heavy” and unbearable as they go through the denial period for long....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Grief as a Persons Way to Recovery after Experiencing Loss of Something

Moreover, these interactions spark an internal change that becomes part of our grief grief It is part of human life to lose a person or an object of close proximity.... grief can be defined as a way in which a person may react to loss.... grief is a person's way to recovery after experiencing loss of something they had a relationship with1.... However, the explanation of grief does cannot be exhausted by the understanding of the person relationship with what they lost....
2 Pages (500 words) Research Proposal

The More We Love, the More the Price We Pay in Terms of Pain

Experience has made me belief that the more we love, the more the price we pay in terms of pain and grief.... Experience has made me belief that the more we love, the more the price we pay in terms of pain and grief.... The saying by Lewis revived my pain and grief.... there is a big difference between in the pain and grief I experience when a distant person dies or encounters worst situations.... Lewis's saying reflected on my experiences by reminding me the intense pain and grief I experienced after the disappearance and burial of K....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment

Healthy Grief and Components of Grievance

hellip; However the most common responses of a person to grief are anger, shock, numbness, fatigue, shock and yearning.... Though grief is considered to be normal and the expected reaction of a son when faced with pain, still lengthened or severe grief may impose negative effects on a person's health and may also result in some serious issues.... This paper takes into account the comparison between the grief process defined by the writer Elizabeth Kubler-Ross and also the relationship that exists between grief process and joy....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Bereavement Across the Lifespan

Reportedly, people show different reactions towards grief.... hellip; According to Kail and Cavanaugh (2013), grief reactions changes based on the growth stages.... The eight stages are re-grouped to fit four stages based on the similarity or grief reaction.... Individuals in infancy and early adulthood have inferior knowledge and understanding about death and likely to experience no grief.... However, individuals at the two stages of development may experience extended effects of grief experienced by elder siblings....
8 Pages (2000 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us