StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

A Closer Look on the Religious Liberty in the United States - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The first amendment of the Constitution of the United States of America states that the “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.5% of users find it useful
A Closer Look on the Religious Liberty in the United States
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "A Closer Look on the Religious Liberty in the United States"

? (day month year A Closer Look on the Religious Liberty in the United s The first amendment of the Constitution of the United States of America states that the “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or the press; or the right of the people” (Congressional Research Service 25). The primary focus of this discussion is the free exercise clause and the establishment clause of the amendment. Several scholars had provided different positions regarding the amendment of the constitution and its practical and legal ramifications. Some scholars have highlighted the pitfalls of the implementation of the free exercise clause since it has been used by some individuals as shield against the law by using the notion of religious liberty as cover to their practices that is deemed by others as a criminal activity. Other scholars also suggest that religious liberty is an impossible ideal, targeting the lack of a concrete definition of what a religion is. In order to gain a broader knowledge on the concept of religious liberty as well as to develop a more in-depth understanding on the first amendment, the above said positions will be examined through the course of this paper. According to the Religious Liberty in American Law, the relation of religion and law in the United States may be summarized as follows; the government cannot establish a religion or church under the law, the people have the freedom of conscience in matters of religious belief and worship, citizens cannot be discriminated or be subjected to any form of legal preference based on different forms of religion (Bates 538). The citizens cannot be compelled to join any religious worship as well as contribute money in support to the religious institution, Public funds of any state may not be used or appropriated for the support of any religious organization, Religious tests cannon be established as a requirement to hold a public position, to have the right to vote, to be a juror or a witness in court proceedings and for any state policies and functions. The civil rights of a person cannot be reduced or altered based on his religious views and beliefs. All forms of religious beliefs are also given equal protection under the law. The law also states that everyone is guaranteed of religious liberty as long as it does not interfere with peace, good order, and the morals of society. Separation of the church and state, in terms of civil and ecclesiastical functions, is also stated in the first amendment (539). With the understanding of the provisions of the law, the first position may be addressed through the use of past court orders made for cases that involved the concept of religious freedom. The limitations of religious liberty can also be addressed through the examples. According to Chester Antinaeu (221), the freedom of religion provides individual a preferred position in the hierarchy of socio-legal values though it is not absolute. Based on the proposition of Justice Black, a well-organized society cannot allow any individual to make a final decision on everything that he will do or not do that is free from his liabilities to the state. Thus individuals that practice their religious freedom are still subjected to conduct themselves to abide obediently to the laws of the state that are designed to protect the welfare of the society from any form of threats to danger. Thus for societies that are politically organized such as the United States, the judiciary department carries the burden of delimiting the fundamental freedoms that are given to its citizens (221). Historical jurisprudence had been a key guide in determining the limits of the religious freedom. On the early years of the law, an accused claimed that by the virtue of his religious freedom, he was exempted from the statute of the state that forbids polygamy. This may be a norm the members of the Jesus of Latter Day Saints in practicing their religion but polygamy is considered by the statute of the state as a criminal offense and the freedom of religion does not free the members of this religion from the punishment that is associated with committing the crime (222). The delimitation of the First Amendment cannot be considered as a breach of the constitution since there sufficient expressions by other Justices of the Supreme Court that attest that court have been weighing societal utilities before coming up with a decision that limits the religious freedom (225). Courts have frequently considered religious freedom as a protection to an individual’s beliefs but not its activities. The freedom of religion does not function as an excuse for criminal acts and would not be accepted by courts as justification for committing an act that is considered as a criminal offense under the law of the state (227). In addition, courts have denied constitutional protection for commercial and profitable activities of religious organizations, stating the business undertakings such as fortune-telling and faith healing can be subjected to claims for religious liberty (228). The general criterion of courts in denying constitutional guaranty of religious freedom is when these activities “deprive the state of its police power to enact laws for the protection of the public safety and morals and the protection of the general welfare” (230). Usually these cases clash with social interest in health, safety, order, and morality. The limitation of religious liberty in relation to the social interest in public health can be clearly depicted with the case of Prince v. Massachusetts wherein a child was not given proper medical attention and its guardian was claiming that it is their freedom of religion to distribute religious flyers in the street. However, the Supreme Court ruled that the health and welfare of the child is considered with higher priority than the guardian’s freedom of religion (230). It is not an excuse to violate the compulsory vaccination statutes of the state and the state has the authority to exclude unvaccinated children from public schools due to the increased health risks to other pupils. Religious liberty also does not excuse any pupil to submit to a physical examination. In addition, practices of religious healing cannot be defended in courts as part of the religious liberty since the practice of medicine is a police regulation for the protection of public health and does not interfere with one’s freedom of religion (231). The safety of the state is also another societal interest that cannot be bypassed by the freedom religion, cases that included appeals of not joining the military training because of religious beliefs was dropped by the courts, ruling that the individual still has to attend military training despite it being against his religion (233). Peace and Order is also a consideration for court rulings. Individuals that practice their rights for religious liberty cannot extort others by physical attack just because they belong to another sect. Also religious activities that entail public inconvenience were also not allowed by the state (234). The state also protects the morality as a societal interest thus the practice of polygamy is never accepted by courts even if ministers of religious organizations plead their right of religious liberty (239). Another position that must be addressed is claim of other scholars that the concept of religious liberty cannot be protected by the government without defining the meaning of religion. However, in doing so, an individual will be limited with its free exercise since the definition may not cover his own definition of religious practices and beliefs. According the Jeremy Gunn (190), several attempts have been made to explain the rights protected under the concept of religion or belief. However, the term religion, even though it is present in human rights laws around the globe, still remains undefined. Making it hard to understand what is protected and what is not in the practice one’s religion. The complexity of religion makes it difficult to define and much of it is subjective to those who are part of a religious organization (191). Based on the information that had been gathered to address the commentaries of scholar with the first amendment, it can be said that the free exercise of religion has been protected well by the constitution. The beliefs of an individual are not subjected to scrutiny or criticisms by the society and the government and not external forces are present that can interfere or affect one’s religious beliefs and practices. The first amendment as well as the fourteenth amendment ensures that a person cannot be influenced by others and cannot be controlled by the federal government and its states to practice a certain religion opposed to what the person believes in. However, the freedom of religion given to an individual also has an inherent responsibility for the individual to conform to the rules and policies of the state. It does not mean that having religious freedom provides the person do whatever his religion teaches him to do since every individual in the society also has their own rights and freedom that the state and government also has to protect. Thus, on occasions that the practice of a religious belief clashed with the societal interests and goes against the statute, the state has all the authority to limit the religious liberty of an individual. The United States have contributed to the political theory and practice through its success in completely separating the church from the state (Doerr 1). Separation of the Church and State is clearly described in the first amendment of the US Constitution. The constitution ensures that the law cannot establish a religion or a church and it reject any attempt to require members of the government must be members of a particular religious organization (McKinstry 1). The main consideration of having a freedom of religion in the US is due to the multiple sects that are practicing their own beliefs and practices and if the government will support a certain religion, several disputes will be faced. Thus, the amendment to have religious freedom and tolerance took place (2). “The Supreme Court’s interpretation of the Free Exercise Clause has mainly focused on the reasons or motivations for government regulation of religious practice” and not on the effects of such regulations. Thus regulations of the court cannot have a religious rationale for the regulation since by doing so the regulation cannot be permitted based on the constitution (Beattie 389). The Establishment Clause jurisprudence prohibited three main types of government regulations. It prohibited the regulation base on sectarian reasons and motivations, regulations that require undue interference between secular and sectarian institutions, and regulations that had effects of advancement of a religion (397). Works Cited Antieau, Chester J. “The Limitation of Religious Liberty.” Fordham Law Review.18.2 (1949): 221-241. Web. 20 April 2012. Bates, M. Searle. Religious Liberty: An Inquiry. Kessinger. New York, International Missionary Council. 1945. Web. 20 April 2012. Beattie, James, Jr. R. Taking Liberalism and Religious Liberty Seriously: Shifting our Notion of Toleration from Locke to Mill. 2004. Web. 20 April 2012. Congressional Research Service. The Constitution of the United States of America: Analysis and Interpretation. Washington: US Government Printing Office. 1992. Web. 20 April 2012 Doerr, Edd. The Importance of Church-State Separation. 2004. Web. 20 April 2012 Gunn, T. Jeremy. “The Complexity of Religion and the Definition of “Religion” in International Law.” Harvard Human Rights Journal 16 (2003): 189-215. Web. 20 April 2012. McKinstry, Sam W. Separation of Church and State: The American Dillema. Web. 21 April 2012. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“A Closer Look on the Religious Liberty in the United States Essay”, n.d.)
A Closer Look on the Religious Liberty in the United States Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/religion-and-theology/1448931-though-the-concept-of-religious-liberty-has-deep
(A Closer Look on the Religious Liberty in the United States Essay)
A Closer Look on the Religious Liberty in the United States Essay. https://studentshare.org/religion-and-theology/1448931-though-the-concept-of-religious-liberty-has-deep.
“A Closer Look on the Religious Liberty in the United States Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/religion-and-theology/1448931-though-the-concept-of-religious-liberty-has-deep.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF A Closer Look on the Religious Liberty in the United States

Religious Liberty and the US Constitution

Bush speaks of the united states having a calling or mission that has come from the Maker of Heaven.... Keeping in view all these facts and realities, along with the mental condition and sentiment of the people behind them, the founder-leaders of the USA decided to offer unrestricted religious liberty to the masses in order to avoid and escape any unpleasant state of affairs for the future years to come.... Adherence to the religious teachings is not confined to one single community or social class only; rather, it is equally popular among the rich and poor and the strong and weak....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Sociology of Religion

By studying that and other historical aspects of religious rise in the united states, the Putnam and Campbell also managed to use some questions such as ;” how Protestants came to stress their commonality with Catholics.... In order to help deal with the situation, Americans learned how to practice religious tolerance which effectively means that they know how to accept and respect the religious beliefs of other cultures and religions.... America began its quest for religious tolerance when immigrants from Europe and other countries began to flock to the country after World War I....
4 Pages (1000 words) Book Report/Review

Separation of Church and State

This priority of the religious is clearly evident in the legislative explanation for the revised 1798 Act Relative to Religious Freedom and the Maintenance of Ministers: Whereas Almighty, God hath created the mind free; that all attempts to influence it by temporal punishments or burthens, or by civil incapacitation, tend only to beget habits of hypocrisy and meanness, and is a departure from the plan of the Holy Author of our religion, who being Lord both of body and mind, yet chose not to propagate it by coercions on either, as was in his almighty power to do that to compel a man to furnish contributions of money for the propagation of opinions which he disbelieves, is sinful and tyrannical; that even the forcing him to support this or that teacher of his own religious persuasion, is depriving him of the comfortable liberty of giving his contributions to the particular pastor whose morals he would make his pattern, and whose powers he feels most persuasive to righteousness, and is withdrawing from the ministry those temporary rewards, which, proceeding from an appropriation of their personal conduct, are an additional incitement to earnest and unremitting labors for the instruction of mankind....
17 Pages (4250 words) Literature review

Religious Opposition to Modern States

Attacked by widespread international criticism and even condemnation for actions ranging from the Vietnam War to aid for Israel and support of globalization, the united states has gained the ire of religious extremists.... Now, even as the united states and its allies seek to destroy Osama bin Laden's terrorist network, critics are questioning America's sensitivity to the concerns of the Islamic world and beyond.... The author analyzes the article "Holy Orders: Opposition to the Modern states" by Juergensmeyer which states that religious warfare is difficult to address because, in almost every recent case of religious violence, concepts of cosmic war have been accompanied by claims of moral justification....
10 Pages (2500 words) Assignment

Separation of Church and State

The compulsions that knowledge creates we can never fulfill, which is why the religious life is a life of determined.... he encompassing description of liberty of conscience was the systematizing principle of society, and it produced a kind of severance of church and state.... This research explores church-state relations as it seems highly paradoxical that the US Constitution provides for a strict separation of Church and State yet religious considerations have a major impact on the country's public life....
17 Pages (4250 words) Essay

An Evaluation Of Four Arguments Against State-Maintained Faith Schools

Of the remaining 2 %, only 58 are non-Christians, namely, Jewish (38); Muslims (11); Sikh (4); Greek Orthodox, Hindu, Quaker, Seventh Day Adventist, united Reform Church with one (1) each (DCSF 2010).... In the light of contentions from secularists, people who have been against UK state-funded faith schools, there have been some alarming reasons why they say that government should not fund these religious oriented educational institutions....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Religious Tolerance

This paper "Religious Tolerance" discusses the declining influence of the religious establishments on not only the political aspects of society but society as a whole.... hellip; As society is becoming more secular, religious trends and attitudes are losing power over the masses.... With the trend of increasing political correctness, Western culture has become over tolerant of religious differences.... One must question the willingness of Western cultures to have the attitude of religious tolerance....
11 Pages (2750 words) Case Study

Sociology of Religion

in the united states, there are institutes and public figures who publicly promote the idea of creationism.... Although the teacher, Scopes, was eventually found guilty—and made to pay a fine—the Supreme Court of the united states eventually overturned the ban on teaching evolution in 1968, saying that such a ban would violate the constitution since it would be to the benefit of religion.... On various school boards across the united states proponents of ID would not ask to ban teaching evolution; instead, they would argue that there was more than one viewpoint on the matter and that schools should also teach ID or “teach the controversy....
19 Pages (4750 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us