StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Crimes Against Humanity and Genocide in India - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay "Crimes Against Humanity and Genocide in India" deals with the events called the Sikh Massacre happened in India. As the author puts it, the anti-Sikhs ‘riots’ of 1984 refer to a sequential occurrence of events that directly targeted the Sikh community in India…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.6% of users find it useful
Crimes Against Humanity and Genocide in India
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Crimes Against Humanity and Genocide in India"

Crimes against humanity and genocide in 1984 Punjab, India The anti-Sikhs ‘riots’ of 1984 in the state of Punjab, India, also referred to as the Sikh Massacre, refer to a sequential occurrence of events that directly targeted the Sikh community in India. Anti-Sikh mobs, randomly attacked the existing Sikh community, as a direct response to Indira Gandhi assassination, carried out by her Sikh bodyguards. The paper aims at discussing the direct influence of Indira Gandhi’s assassination, on the Sikh community in India resulting in the infringement of many of their human rights and freedoms in terms of crimes against humanity, as well as genocide. The violence that broke out was patterned on the themes of political/religious intolerance and ethnic cleansing. Pertinent issues of concern include: the lack of proper police response, as well as organized perpetration of crime that went unabated by concerned security agencies (in Delhi). The involvement of government officials will be discussed, as well the Indian Army’s role-play. The massacre of the Sikhs in Punjab, India was an organized crime that was supported by the government following the assassination of Indira Gandhi who was Prime Minister at the time of her death, having had a massive influence on India’s political landscape because of her relation to Mahatma Gandhi, India’s most revered personality. The massacre led to the death of many people and destruction of a lot of property following the effective organization of the massacre. It is during her administration that the Indian Emergency (1970s) was imposed with this subsequently resulting in the detention of thousands of Sikhs who were politically agitating for some form of autonomy (Deol 78). During this era, sporadic violence was present, resulting from increased armed activity of an armed Sikh separatist group. The Indian government’s apt designation of this separatist group as a terrorist entity further worsened the already tense political atmosphere (Deol 75). This culminated in the commencement of Operation Blue Star, where Prime Minister Indira ordered an attack on the Golden Temple by the Indian Army. This was in response to the violent occupation of the Temple by Sikh separatists, whom being viewed as insurgents, were reported to have been stockpiling weapons (Singh). Her tough stance towards the group, resulted in this direct order that was to focus on eliminating any insurgents founds, with later armed operations initiated in the larger Punjab state’s countryside. Indian paramilitary forces were commanded to clear any separatists that were hosted in the countryside with no option of negotiation (Rana). In Delhi, violence erupted as a direct result of Indira’s assassination on 31 October 1984. The assassination was carried out by two of her Sikh bodyguards, projected as being a direct response to her authorization of the aforementioned military operation. In the ensuing chaos, an estimated 2,700 deaths were reported in the city, with more than 20,000 reported to have fled the city. Here, the most affected areas were mainly the Sikh neighborhoods where numerous human rights abuses were witnessed. The unfortunate mass violence and killing that occurred, as well as population displacement is not debatable. The Indian government did not label the massacres of Sinks as genocide following the assassination of Indira Gandhi. Instead, it labeled it as a riot to mischaracterize the massacre and make it appear as if it was not a serious issue. It is widely acknowledged that the Indian government participated heavily in the massacre of the Sinks as senior political party officials of the ruling party and the police carefully planned it. The congress party officials met with their local supported who helped identify the sinks and their properties, distributed weapons, chemicals and other things that could help to make the massacre of the Sinks successful. The same night, the police and the officials posted a rumor that the Sinks had celebrated the killing of Indira Gandhi creating a fertile ground for the violence that took place (SIKHSIYASAT). What happened in Delhi, and subsequently in the greater national arena, cannot be viewed as sporadic violence based on communal unrest. It is viewed by many as unfortunate that not only did the Indian government and police hurriedly bring to closure this case, but that the international community, as well as global oversight bodies also seemed to be in agreement in confining such violence as spontaneous rioting that went out of control (Deol 73). The most notable issue is that Amnesty International India used the term ‘riots’ in reference to the systematic and organized two-phased and two-pronged genocidal onslaught carried out in both Delhi and the Punjab state. As projected by the SIKHSIYASAT (2014), the direct target of this violence was the overall Sikh population, viewed by many as enemies within, and hence need for decisive action against them. The anti-Sikhs riots of 1984 represent horrific and violent crime against humanity, as a result of the Indian government directly launching a vicious war on the State of Punjab in June. This was through invasion and subsequent occupation of the region, carried out in a brutal and inhumane manner. In the same breadth, the army and Special Forces utilized, further bombarded the Golden Temple that was specifically the Sikh national shrine located in Amritsar (SIKHSIYASAT). Because the Golden Temple was Sikh nation’s holiest place, it brought about great bitterness portrayed by the populace as it was used for the crimes that were committed against its rightful owners. The Indian government through the Indian Army utilized helicopter gunships and tanks to deal decisively with the insurgents housed in the Temple. On the other hand, by closing off the entirety of the State of Punjab to the rest of global society, the Indian government turned it into a massive concentration camp. Here, Indian soldiers were accused of rampaging through all villages engaging in mass arrests, torture, rape and killings. In the city of Delhi, the Sikh neighborhoods were turned into killing zones, as Sikh men were dragged out of their houses, hacked to death, shot or doused with petrol and burned alive by the frenzied mobs. Sikh women were further raped with the children not being spared either. Subsequently, their bodies were stripped of both belongings and clothing, to be cremated en-mass (Singh). Such systematic killing of a community falls under the crime of Genocide, as well as crimes against humanity (Charny 516). Such wide-scale violence as witnessed in Delhi’s Sikh neighborhoods was directly enhanced through collaboration of both officials from the nation’s ruling Congress party and local authorities through logistical support, financing and preparation of the killing squads. In addition, use of voting lists enabled targeted killings, as Sikhs were promptly identifiable and hence easily located. The state media’s incitement best presented through superstar Amitabh Bachchan’s utterances of the slogan ‘khun ka badla khun sae laengae' (Blood for blood) further fueled the tension. Such a leading Indian figure, in uttering such sensitive words on public television was taken up by a majority of the concerned perpetrators as being a rallying point for the subsequent engagement in vicious atrocities against the Sikhs (Rana). Further worsening the situation is what appeared to be state-orchestrated cover-up. This was in the form of how the government subsequently handled the case, terming the deaths as directly resulting from communal riots, as opposed to systematic massacre of a religious minority. In addition, fundamentally worsening the fragile reconciliation process is the fact that perpetrators as well as organizers and inciters to the violence were never fully prosecuted (Singh). Instead, almost all cases were brought to quick closure, without proper justice being dispensed, citing lack of evidence. Only a few police officers, were charged with negligence to their duties and provision of protection to attackers. Notable in this context is use of the term ‘Riots’, which negate the full impacts of the violence to communal unrest. Additionally, the influential nature of official British aid through its SAS military department is also an issue here. This was through intelligence reporting as well as logistical support (SIKHSIYASAT). Since the Indian government has hid the evidence and shielded those responsible for the massacre for a long time and even went ahead to characterize it as a communal riot, it is evident that India cannot achieve accountability. To achieve peace and justice, the international community in conjunction with the International Criminal Court should conduct fresh investigations to bring the culprits to justice even if it means putting sanctions on the Indian government to cooperate. After this, reconciliation process can begin after the truth of the matter is known and the culprits face the law for their actions. In conclusion, as stated above, the anti-Sikhs ‘riots’ of 1984 in the state of Punjab, India, also referred to as the Sikh Massacre refer to a sequential occurrence of events that directly targeted the Sikh community in India. The main cause of the massacre was the impunity that had lasted in the country for a very long time. The Indian government participated heavily in the massacre of the Sinks as senior political party officials of the ruling party and the police carefully planned it. The congress party officials met with their local supported who helped identify the sinks and their properties, distributed weapons, chemicals and other things that could help to make the massacre of the Sinks successful. In fact, the government played down the massacre by labeling it a riot. The lack of proper consideration of the violence as being equal to genocide by the international community and concerned global oversight bodies is what fuels continued strive for justice and final justified closure to the case by the global Sikh community. Works Cited Charny, Israel W. Encyclopedia of genocide. ABC-CLIO. 1999, (pp. 516–517). Print. Deol, Harnik. Religion and Nationalism in India: The Case of the Punjab. London: Routledge, 2000. Print. Rana, Yudhvir. 1984 riots: ‘Why nobody noticed Amitabh Bachchan spewing venom in India. The Times of India, 20 Oct. 2011. Web. 12 Nov 2014. SIKHSIYASAT (Punjab Update Bureau). Sikh Genocide 1984: Amnesty International India petition demands Justice for victims BUT terms it as ‘riots’. Punjab Update Bureau, 25 Oct. 2014. Web. 12 Nov 2014. Singh, Parmjit. UK had helped India to prepare June 1984 attack on Sikhs, reveals Secret British documents released after 30 years. SIKH SIYASAT NEWS – Special News. 13 Jan. 2014. Web. 12 Nov 2014. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Crimes Against Humanity and Genocide in India Essay”, n.d.)
Crimes Against Humanity and Genocide in India Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/social-science/1665362-crimes-against-humanity-and-genocide-in-1984-punjab-india
(Crimes Against Humanity and Genocide in India Essay)
Crimes Against Humanity and Genocide in India Essay. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1665362-crimes-against-humanity-and-genocide-in-1984-punjab-india.
“Crimes Against Humanity and Genocide in India Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1665362-crimes-against-humanity-and-genocide-in-1984-punjab-india.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Crimes Against Humanity and Genocide in India

Political Trials And What Can They Tell Us About The Relationship Between Law And Politics

This is because it prevents future, negative public opinion which might work against... Simply defined, a political trial is any legal proceedings held in a court of law, which addresses political issues.... The use of political officials in these trials is a crucial characteristic which differentiates them from normal court proceedings....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

The United Nations Function

It is the purpose of the UN to encourage peace among all the nations [1] The UN's first experience of peacemaking activity came in 1949 in the Middle East and in 1950 in Kashmir conflict between india and Pakistan, The second function of UN was the promotion of welfare of mankind and of course the international cooperation.... United Nations is involved in fighting for the elimination of the different stigmas such as poverty and diseases and the fight against the threat to the environment....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

How Can Societal or Regime Security Explain Intra-State Conflict

Utilizing a security studies perspective and looking at intrastate conflict over the past… The Copenhagen School of security studies, led by Barry Buzan, emphatically argues that regime insecurity can lead to extreme violence and have dramatic ramifications at the Seeking to explore regime insecurity and extreme violence and genocide, this essay will explore Nazism and the Final Solution, the recent Sri Lankan Civil War, Saddam Hussein's gassing of the Kurds of Halabja and the horrendous Rwandan Genocide....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

The Concept of Intervention and State Sovereignty

Only when the situation arises when there is a huge humanitarian crisis like genocide being committed on a population, that an external force or country should intervene to bring about peace and stability.... ut when a clear comparison is made about all the above perspectives it is very clear that in the name of humanitarian intervention mass crimes and atrocities are being committed on humanity, by the rich and powerful nations of the world.... It is very clearly seen that in the name of humanitarian intervention, the US is taking double standards in its fight against terror....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Documentary Analysis and Opinion: No End in Sight

The fact that they were not held accountable even though there exists a theoretical framework that they may probably have been used on a less powerful institution to make the war an ideal example of “crimes of the powerful”.... The paper "Documentary Analysis and Opinion: No End in Sight" states that the seriousness of the matter raised in “No end in sight” is underpinned by the impunity of the US, its allies directly resulted in civilian casualties, and owing to the fact that these nations have influence at the UN....
8 Pages (2000 words) Movie Review

The Rights of Civilians at Times of War

During World War II and earlier wars, there were no particular requirements in the law of armed conflict about the management of the civilian population in areas controlled by an aggressor, other than isolated provisions of the Hague Regulations although violence against the civilian population of the adverse party would amount to war crimes....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Why the United Nations Security Council Supported an Intervention in Libya but Not Syria

With regard to this doctrine, a sovereign state is mandated to prevent mass atrocity crimes within its territory failure of which the international community would assume the mandate in order to avert genocide and crimes against humanity.... The UN Secretary-General through his advisers on the Prevention of Genocide and the Responsibility to Protect reminded Libyan political leadership of its international mandate and obligation of prevention of crimes against humanity failure of which the state would be held accountable (Zifcak, 2012, p....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Theories of International Relations

… The paper "Theories of International Relations" is a great example of a Socie Science Assignment.... Fukuyama's response is a depiction of conservative thinking.... For instance, his proclamation of the end to history simply disqualifies politics as a conservative force in the world.... This is because the end of history would mean an end to world politics....
13 Pages (3250 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us