StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Michael Sandel - Citizenship, Sacrifice, and Service - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The essay "Michael Sandel - Citizenship, Sacrifice, and Service" portrays an ideal model of society - one in which we take civic obligation and don’t allow ourselves to be distracted by material preoccupations. His ideas are just and would be practical and logical if they would attain fulfillment…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95% of users find it useful
Michael Sandel - Citizenship, Sacrifice, and Service
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Michael Sandel - Citizenship, Sacrifice, and Service"

Michale J Sandel Citizenship, Sacrifice and Service Citizenship status carries with it both rights and responsibilities. "Active citizenship" is the philosophy that citizens should work towards the betterment of their community through economic participation, public, volunteer work, and other such efforts to improve life for all citizens. In this vein, schools in some countries provide citizenship education. One Sandel’s basic assumption was that citizens would have quite different ideas of what "the good life" might entail. Sandel doesnt think questions about the good life can, or should, be set aside in that way; at every stage, they must be part of the debate over how societies should work. And he aims higher than grass-gazing. In Sandel’s opinion people should sacrifice for the common good instead of selfishly seeking their happiness: "Unlike customers, citizens sometimes sacrifice their wants for the sake of the common good. This is the difference between politics and commerce, between patriotism and brand loyalty". His idea is noble and very humane but awfully unlikely to attain fulfillment. I am not saying that no one is willing to sacrifice their enjoyment, their time or effort for the common good. What I am saying is that not many people would be up to it. People are, by nature, extremely selfish and the first thing on their minds is their own happiness and well-being. So, this unselfish act of sacrifice is hard for many people to do. On the other hand, many cases in which Sandel thinks sacrifice is needed, do not need any sacrifice. Michael J. Sandels displays a misunderstanding of environmental policy and of global warming. He argues that trading emissions credits undermines the ethic we should be trying to foster on the environment. What ethic does Mr. Sandel have in mind, other than his misplaced wish for a spirit of shared sacrifice? Why should environmental progress be accompanied by sacrifice? He asserts that a fee (that is, the cost of buying emissions credits) rather than a fine (for noncompliance) makes pollution just another cost of doing business. Exactly! There is no better way to incorporate environmental ethos into a company than to link the costs of pollution to the bottom line. According to the republican conception of citizenship, people should have more rights than just voting in elections and registering preferences or interests. To be free means to be able to participate in shaping the forces that govern the collective destiny. In order to do that, according to Sandel, and do it well, it is necessary that citizens possess or come to acquire certain qualities of character, or civic virtues. About the case of military service and voting, Sandel argues that there is reason to limit the role of markets in governing these practices more severely than we are accustomed to do. “In each case, an excessive role for markets corrupts an ideal the practices properly express and advance—namely, the ideal of citizenship as the republican tradition conceives it”. (Michael Sandel) In practice, despite the presence of civil service rules and labor unions, governments have made massive programmatic shifts, ranging from the closures of hundreds of mental institutions in the last two decades to the military base closures under way today. Tens of thousands of employees have been retrained to take on revised responsibilities.  The unhappy public service consumer, rather than voting, lobbying, or organizing politically to improve service performance, could jump ship and sign up elsewhere. By essentially abandoning hope of revitalizing the democratic process, we tend to forget how this society is complex and how decisions can be made here in ways that restore public confidence in government and that foster greater citizen participation. As much as people might be aware of the necessity to limit the role of markets in governing, there will always be a part of us that will still believe that what markets do is right and that is exactly the reason why it can never be permanently limited. However, the limitation of their role would be appopriate, practical and relieving to the regular citizens who would then have an increased freedom of choice and a much easier life. According to libertarians, the greatest threat to individual rights comes from the government. It shouldnt tell you how to live your life. Most important, the government should never tax for redistributive purposes. Redistributive taxation is theft. Taking your earnings and giving it to other people is like forcing you to work for those people. Libertarians say its almost like slavery. Sandel argues that military service should not be allocated by the labor market, as if it were just another job. According to this argument, all citizens have an obligation to serve their country. “Whether this obligation is best discharged through military or other national service, it is not the sort of thing that people should be free to buy or sell. To turn such service into a commodity—a job for pay—is to corrupt or degrade the sense of civic virtue that properly attends it.” Sandel quotes Rousseau who states that: “As soon as public service ceases to be the chief business of the citizens and they would rather serve with their money than with their persons, the state is not far from its fall. When it is necessary to march out to war, they pay troops and stay at home.... In a country that is truly free, the citizens do everything with their own arms and nothing by means of money; so far from paying to be exempted from their duties, they would even pay for the privilege of fulfilling them themselves.... I hold enforced labor to be less opposed to liberty than taxes” What Sandel is implying is that no one should be able to buy themselves into or out of the army, because army should be served by every man, for it is every man’s duty. Then again, it is not only a matter of duty, but how the paid army can be trusted in the case of war. Would they be ready to risk their lives for their country? Also, Sandel states that in the American army, that consists of men who are paid to be there, does not let in neither people of color nor foreigners. Why would it matter of which nationality they are if they are paid to serve the army? The right thing to do would be to make a rule according to which everyone would have to contribute and serve their country, but there will always be ways for wealthy people, who don’t want to go to the army, to pay the government to be excused or to pay someone to replace them. Money always finds the way to people’s greed and need. Sandel’s idea and argument about not letting people buy themselves in or out of the army is, in my opinion just, and practical, because it would make all people who live in America equal, regardless of their religion, color of their skin or nationality and it would oblige them to, at one point, serve the military, no matter how wealthy or poor they are. Some key questions raised by Sandels work are: Can one stress the importance of group solidarity without reigniting the ethnic and religious tensions that liberalism was designed to ameliorate? Can the notion that some ways of living are better than others, and that politicians and judges should make such judgments, be resuscitated without breeding intolerance or coercion? The answer is yes. There are two reasons to consider either conscription or some form of universal national service that would include military service as an option. One is the reason you suggest: if the decision to go to war does not involve any risk or sacrifice on the part of those making the decision, wars will be undertaken too lightly. The Iraq war is an example. Few members of Congress or the administration had family members who served in the war. A second reason is one of fairness: The volunteer army draws disproportionately from the lower middle class. The sons and daughters of the affluent are largely exempt. But if the nation decides to go to war, there is something to be said for sharing the sacrifice, rather than hiring those who cannot otherwise afford college to fight and die on our behalf. Sandel saw a connection between a just society—one in which all citizens are treated fairly—and a good society—one in which we take civic obligation seriously and don’t allow ourselves to be distracted by material preoccupations. In my opinion, his thoughts and ideas are just and would be very practical and logical if they would attain fulfillment, but unfortunately, our society has too many corrupted people on high positions and that makes any good change that would affect them harder to happen. But everything is possible if people try hard, and if they work together to accomplish the same goal. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Michael Sandel - Citizenship, Sacrifice, and Service Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words, n.d.)
Michael Sandel - Citizenship, Sacrifice, and Service Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1746872-citzenship-sacrifice-and-survice
(Michael Sandel - Citizenship, Sacrifice, and Service Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words)
Michael Sandel - Citizenship, Sacrifice, and Service Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1746872-citzenship-sacrifice-and-survice.
“Michael Sandel - Citizenship, Sacrifice, and Service Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words”. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1746872-citzenship-sacrifice-and-survice.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Michael Sandel - Citizenship, Sacrifice, and Service

Service and Sacrifice by America's Veterans Benefit Today's Youth

The simplest way to complete the sentence would be to say that the service and sacrifice by America's veterans benefit today's youth by giving them the freedoms they enjoy.... Of course, few of the wars that the Veterans have fought have been on American soil since America has… The wars with Canada and Mexico have been largely forgotten in the story of history as both Canada and Mexico are a part of NAFTA which has brought the three countries towards greater economic service and Sacrifice by Americas Veterans Benefit Todays Youth by....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Corporate Citizenship

The author examines Corporate citizenship which is a trend that has gained huge momentum in the corporate circles for the last two decades or so.... Companies invest huge resources towards Corporate citizenship and it can, therefore, make one wonder what they stand to gain while considering on one hand that a business' business is business and no a diversion of resources to non-business ventures.... nbsp; Corporate citizenship is a trend that has gained huge momentum in the corporate circles for the last two decades or so....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment

Government policies on citizenship

Other than being born as a citizen of a particular nation, there are other ways of acquiring citizenship though the rules and policies vary from one country to another.... In this essay, there will be… Arguments surrounding these citizenship policies will also be brought out and discussed in detail. According to the citizenship acts and policies of the two governments, there are majorly Government policies on citizenship Affiliation: The objective is to create an argument with at least three sources that is created by the comparison and contrast....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Ritual Sacrifice in a Nameless Society

Traditionally, offerings in terms of human sacrifice appeared to be the best way, denoting people who are ready to surrender to the will of their creator.... People have distinguished ways of worshipping their supernatural being.... A number of individuals believe that God is a holy spirit where else other people believe that God is a being who may die....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Randel and Puglisi

He gives a shallow detail on how John Smith interacted with the chief who controlled the existing native Indian Kingdom by that time (michael, 1991).... The two articles present John Smith as very tricky and a political schemer who survived the wrath of captivity but wittingly lured the native Indians to the bait of British colonialist at the reign of King James I References michael J....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Self-Sacrifice and the Leadership Effectiveness

The paper "Self-sacrifice and the Leadership Effectiveness" explains that self-sacrifice contributes significant roles in the development of the group morale within the society.... Freedom Self-sacrifice and the Leadership Effectiveness The chronological accounts for various great leaders indicate that self-sacrifice is one of the most critical qualities of a leader leading for freedom.... Leader self-sacrifice and leadership effectiveness: the moderating role of leader prototypicality....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The Basis for Global Citizenship

This essay "The Basis for Global citizenship" focuses on the strong reasons why we ought to consider ourselves as global citizens.... nbsp;The basis for global citizenship is ample.... hellip; The basis for global citizenship arises because "the idea of 'political community' can no longer be understood within the limits of a nation-state.... Thus, for him, the notion of global citizenship will be important to denationalize, de-territorialize, and democratize citizenship....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Sacrifice Is a Part of Life

Captain's deed shows how worthy and lofty the cause may be as saving the lives of his soldiers for the cost of his own life obviously is a genuine sacrifice and thus requires no justification as relatively opposed to Eddie's.... The paper "sacrifice Is a Part of Life" highlights that sacrifice is an essential part of our life since we have to be engaged in something to the detriment of something else, which appears to shape the vital dilemmas we encounter throughout our lives....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us