StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Article Critique: The Cost of Instructional Improvement - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Odden, A., Goertz, M., Goetz, M., Archibald, S., Gross, B., Weiss, M., & Mangan, M. T. (2008). The cost of instructional improvement: Resource allocation in schools using comprehensive strategies to change classroom practice. Journal of Education Finance, 33 (4), 381-405…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.6% of users find it useful
Article Critique: The Cost of Instructional Improvement
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Article Critique: The Cost of Instructional Improvement"

Odden, A., Goertz, M., Goetz, M., Archibald, S., Gross, B., Weiss, M., & Mangan, M. T. (2008). The cost of instructional improvement: Resource allocation in schools using comprehensive strategies to change classroom practice. Journal of Education Finance, 33 (4), 381-405. Odden et al. (2008) used data from the Consortium for Policy Research in Education (CPRE) to analyze the costs of improving school instruction and its effect on classroom practice and academic achievement. The main problem that the study identified is determining the costs and benefits of enhancing instruction plans.

The CPRE's first set of studies evaluated the effectiveness of educational dollars in shaping student performance. It designed a new expenditure-reporting structure that determines spending by educational program within the instructional functions. The general intention for the expenditure structure was to analyze the instructional category and account for the spending of dollars, based on educational strategy, such as core instruction, specialist teaching, professional growth, and different kinds of additional help for students with special needs.

For this research, Odden et al. (2008) provided the outcomes of a project that employed the mentioned expenditure framework to recognize the costs of a number of instructional improvement strategies that CPRE researchers at the University of Michigan examined in their Study of Instructional Improvement. They also compared an experimental group applying comprehensive school reform programs with those that have not yet used such programs. They analyzed three instructional interventions that are embedded in the comprehensive school reform (CSR) programs: Success for All (SFA), America's Choice (AC), and Accelerated Schools Project (ASP).

Eleven schools were chosen for this study. Data collection included reviewing budget documents and school report documents and interviewing key informants from 2004 to 2005. Findings showed that using CSR programs enhanced levels of educational attainment for the respondents, with broad differences in levels of resources for the sampling, allocation of resources, divergence in resource use from what the instructional improvement designs recommended, and across and within sampling groups. The purpose of the article is clear in the introduction of the paper.

The researchers provided the context of CPRE and the work it has done and further aims to do. They specified their focus, which is studying the efficiency of instructional improvements. The authors also reviewed pertinent literature, but concentrated on the CPRE’s mission, goals, and developments. Most of the research also came from the researchers’ past studies. This makes the literature biased toward what CPRE needs to do, so that it can attain its mission and goals. The introduction lacks further review of past and existing studies on the accounting of educational dollars.

More studies about existing cost structures, including auditing and accounting practices and policies, will help identify the relevance and position of this research in the extant literature. The data collection is valid, because the researchers ensured that data can be compared across the states. They were able to compare the data by adjusting districts and states’ national average school salaries and fixed benefits rates through the Geographical Cost of Education Index (GCEI). The researchers also used diverse data methods to attain a comprehensive view of the components and effects of comprehensive school reform (CSR) programs.

They triangulated data collection methods that improved the validity of their research findings. The findings of this research are convincing, because the data shows the effects of CSR on resource allocation and priorities of the schools. For instance, because of the high population of low-income students, the schools used around 20% to 40% of their budget on financial assistance programs. This means that instructional costs included responding to the socio-economic limitations of their students.

The researchers also noted the high expenses on professional development, even stressing that they seem to be a bit high. They considered, nevertheless, the focus on extensive professional-development strategies as part of the intervention. They also discovered that schools in their fifth to sixth years of using the program are still spending majority of their budget on professional development. The authors are right to argue that this reflects a “new instructional regime” (Odden et al., 2008, p.401). This regime is based on enhancing instructional components and their contribution on student academic achievement.

Thus, in reality, there are gaps in program designs and how they are implemented, although it is evident that additional professional help and professional development enhanced the impact of educational dollars on student academic achievement. My personal reflection on this article is that comprehensive school reform (CSR) programs are beneficial to schools, teachers, and students. They help advance professionalism in how schools handle their budgets, in ways that they can correlate their spending on actual student performance.

It will be interesting, however, to learn more about the exact instructional components that affect particular student skills, attitudes, and knowledge. This way, accounting will also take note of its intangible effects on student development. Finally, I believe that this approach on school budgeting will enhance the efficiency of instructional programs and improve the role of instruction in boosting student academic achievement. This approach can also be modified to study the effects of budget decisions on professional development and student academic achievement.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Article Critique: The Cost of Instructional Improvement Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/education/1454895-article-critique
(Article Critique: The Cost of Instructional Improvement Essay)
https://studentshare.org/education/1454895-article-critique.
“Article Critique: The Cost of Instructional Improvement Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/education/1454895-article-critique.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Article Critique: The Cost of Instructional Improvement

Effect of Same-Sex Marriage Laws on Healthcare

Running head: ARTICLE critique Effect of Same-Sex Marriage Laws on Health Care Use and Expenditures in Sexual Minority Men: A Quasi-Natural Experiment Name Institution Professor Subject Research Problem The study aimed to investigate the impact of same-sex marriage policies on the physical and mental health conditions of gays, bisexuals, and lesbians in the U....
4 Pages (1000 words) Article

Pain in the Hispanic Cancer Patient

Hispanic Cancer Patient's Pain as Described in the Article – Discussion and critique As the authors' examined the part that socio-cultural background plays in the experience of pain in Hispanic cancer patients, I was given a clear representation of how the healthcare paradigm works in for the case of migrants....
7 Pages (1750 words) Article

Critical Evaluation of A Fly in the Buttermilk

In their article, ““A Fly in the Buttermilk”: Descriptions of University Life by Successful Black Undergraduate Students at a Predominately White Southeastern University” Davis et al explores deep into the self-realization -from the student's perspective- of a… The title of their study explicitly asserts the concerns of the Successful Black Undergraduate Students with their University Life among white majority....
6 Pages (1500 words) Article

Distance Learning versus Classroom Instruction

The objective of the paper is to provide a critique of an article that provides research and studies on the subject of determining which was better to use distance learning or classroom instruction.... The paper would describe what was read in the article and to present a critique....
3 Pages (750 words) Article

Positive Effects of Active Procrastination Behavior on Attitudes and Performance

The independent variables of the study are academic procrastination and active procrastination, where active procrastination can be identified as an opposite of passive procrastination because the procrastinator has the ability to execute his/her decisions in a manner which is… The dependent variables of the study are 1) time structure 2) purposive use of time 3) perceived time control 4) self-efficacy 5) extrinsic motivation 6) intrinsic motivation 7) task coping 8) emotion coping and 9) avoidance coping 10) stress 11) life From the point of view of the sample size, which comprised of 230 undergraduate students, the researchers could have taken into account the association between academic and active procrastination during various periods of the semester....
5 Pages (1250 words) Article

Solid Waste Management

The increasing cost of finding suitable landfills together with increasingly strict regulatory guidelines and higher environmental awareness has compelled many researchers to focus on the issue of recycling as a viable alternative due to increased production, consumption, and waste generation rates of PSW in the last few decades.... Thermoplastics are SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT (Article critique for Environmental Studies) ID number: of University (affiliation)Location of University:Date of Submission: February 14, 2014Estimated Word Count = 622 (text only)Solid Waste ManagementThe article chosen for this paper is entitled “Recycling and recovery routes of plastic solid waste (PSW): a review” written by S....
2 Pages (500 words) Article

Use of Diuretics in Patients with Hypertension

One of the articles that will be included in my own research as a reference is that of Ernst, Pharm, and Mosers' 2009 piece entitled “Use of Diuretics in Patients with Hypertension”.... The underlying reason for this particular piece of research being included has to do with… the fact that the article itself provides a very thorough review of the historical means by which thiazide drugs came to be used for the treatment of hypertension....
1 Pages (250 words) Article

The Potential of Mental-Health Social Workers

… 28 March 2009McCrae, N.... Murray, J.... Huxley, P.... & Evans, S.... (2005).... The Research Potential of Mental-Health Social Workers: A Qualitative Study of the Views of Senior Mental-Health Service Managers, British Journal of Social Work, 35 (1): 55-71 28 March 2009McCrae, N.... Murray, J....
8 Pages (2000 words) Article
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us