StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Is It Worth Becoming a Martyr for the Sake of Ethics - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
The study "Is It Worth Becoming a Martyr for the Sake of Ethics?" examines the case of Valerie, who, in fact, evaded a constructive solution to her ethical dilemma in the company, avoiding possible complications due to a conflict with the boss, and gives advice how to deal with such cases.
 
 …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.2% of users find it useful
Is It Worth Becoming a Martyr for the Sake of Ethics
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Is It Worth Becoming a Martyr for the Sake of Ethics"

How personal differences and preference can impact organizational ethics? Regardless of its size, any organization, in the nutshell, still is a group of individuals with personal differences and preferences. The individual is the starting point of organizational effectiveness, and understanding each person is the key in developing ethics in the workplace. In the case of Valerie the answer to the question posed can be given from two different angles. Valerie, an individual, had her own specific situation. It was a complicated one and we should not judge her on her solution. Anyway, her personal differences, in the end, influenced strongly the ethics in her organization. She faced a dilemma, outweighed her options, made a choice, and based it, solely, on her personal situation. She ended up not enriching her organization’s ethics. On the other hand, her boss acted on his personal preference. He, too, faced a dilemma, made clearly unethical choice and kept acting on it. Therefore, he not only did not help develop ethics in his organization, he compromised its integrity. In this particular case individual differences and preferences proved to be more important than ethics. Here, the ethical principles were not enforced from the leadership level, or followed by the individuals within the organization. I see organizational ethics as a two way road. On the road, a car, driven by a manager, is heading to meet the other car, driven by an employee. The manager is supposed to give the employee a set of instructions how to deal with ethical questions. Unfortunately, in this case, they never meet. How organizational policies and procedures can impact ethics? In recent years, with the discovery of unethical business practices in several big and “prominent” companies, the public started looking more closely into how business is conducted. The focus of this new interest became the ethics in business organizations and how ethical guidelines are followed. We perceive ethics as simply distinguishing right from wrong. On the organizational level this means treating employees and business partners fairly, and leaving no doubt or room for questions about implementation of organizational policies on ethics. Many organizations do have policies and procedures in place to guide individuals in confronting and resolving ethical dilemmas. But, often times that is not enough. What is needed is overall organizational culture in which top management leadership, by clear example, leads everyone else within the organization in navigating the rough waters of ethics. After all, managers and other leaders are the ones facing dilemmas more frequently than others. Organizational policies on ethics should include the elimination of fear from retaliation for reporting somebody else’s questionable actions, elimination of pressure on individuals to do something unethical, strict consequences for not following procedures, and, most importantly, conducting business not for the sake of quick and easy profit, but having in mind others involved in the process. The latter becomes more and more questionable with development of global economy. Frequently, companies from the world’s developed countries are doing quite the opposite by leaving their partners in developing countries with next to nothing. We hear all the time about sweat shops where children and women work long hours for miserable pay. We hear about farmers in Africa getting very little out of their work. These issues also should be covered by organizations. Ethical dilemmas Valerie is facing Dilemmas Valerie is facing, at the core, are not different from dilemmas every one of us has to deal with. Dilemma, in general, involves choosing from two or more options, none of which are favorable. Valerie’s situation, however, is more complicated than most dilemmas are. Her personal case includes a key legal component; her status as a foreign worker in the United States limits her options, adds another variable to the equation and, simultaneously, increases what is at stake. She is forced, and forced hard, to carefully weigh two sides of the issue. Her knowledge about unethical practices her boss is indulging in brings up all those questions- Who else know about this? Should I tell someone? Is this normal? Are others involved? By posing these, Valerie clearly shows her concern for ethics. On the other hand, her personal situation and what she could lose if she acted up on her dilemmas, pushes her toward doing nothing. At least for now. In her mind, Valerie makes a compromise between the two. Her decision shows that her organization did not develop the culture in which she could do what is right without being afraid about the future consequences. Recommend what Valerie should do. The way Valerie dealt with her situation, ultimately did not resolve her dilemma. She, in essence, did not make a choice between her options. She, simply, did nothing. Thus, her dilemma remained with her and was put on hold for a while. Valerie did not want to become a martyr for the sake of ethics. Blaming her for that would be unfair; martyrs do not come along often. But, sometimes martyrs are needed, to selflessly sacrifice themselves for the good of others. Let’s not forget that in Valerie’s complex equation there are other components. Obviously, her boss is not somebody she should take into account. He, surely, deserves to be exposed. What Valerie neglected is her whole company. Once her findings come out, the company will be scrutinized and under suspicion. She, also, neglected other perfumers that are clearly affected by the way Waters in doing business. They don’t get equal opportunity to develop. Finally, Valerie neglected her company’s customers whom are not getting the best choices for the right price. Given the complexity of this case, I still believe Valerie made a mistake. Acting according to the good old “ignorance is bliss” schema, she came up with the solution that benefits nobody in this case, not even her. Valerie is taking a serious risk here. In the case somebody else discovers what she already knows, she could find herself in serious trouble. If that is to happen, she would face questions why she did nothing about it and, with her circumstances, could end up at the point she was trying to avoid in the first place. I think she should have reported Waters. I might be idealizing the world around us, but I believe the majority of people can make a distinction between right and wrong, and I believe that same majority is prepared to act on it. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Is It Worth Becoming a Martyr for the Sake of Ethics Case Study - 1, n.d.)
Is It Worth Becoming a Martyr for the Sake of Ethics Case Study - 1. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/ethics/1568759-how-personal-can-ethics-get
(Is It Worth Becoming a Martyr for the Sake of Ethics Case Study - 1)
Is It Worth Becoming a Martyr for the Sake of Ethics Case Study - 1. https://studentshare.org/ethics/1568759-how-personal-can-ethics-get.
“Is It Worth Becoming a Martyr for the Sake of Ethics Case Study - 1”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/ethics/1568759-how-personal-can-ethics-get.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Is It Worth Becoming a Martyr for the Sake of Ethics

Evolutionary Ethics

The notion of development was already a familiar one to philosophers and biologists from the time of Aristotle; indeed, nothing could be more obvious than that in the life of an individual animal or plant there is a development from the embryo or seed to the fully grown animal or plant. … The Darwinism theory has, however, given a special direction to the evolutionary theory of ethics in connecting good conduct with survival.... It may be a plausible theory that prolongation of life in the individual or in the race is a good thing, so that all actions leading to it are good, but this is not an evolutionary theory of ethics....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Ethical Integrity Issues

Having said this, this paper aims to prove the fact hat there is no excuse or/and reason for going against or betraying morals, ethics, convictions or ethical integrity.... ore often than not, integrity and ethics are tied.... When one talks about integrity, ethics is implied and vice versa.... ethics, according to the American Heritage Dictionary (2000), is construed to refer to the set of principles that govern behavior or simply the regulations or principles that govern the demeanor of a person or the membership of a profession such as law or medicine....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

The Arkansas State Lottery

hellip; It was estimated that the lottery could generate over $100 million worth of funds annually for college scholarships in public and privately-accredited higher institutions2.... In September 2007, Arkansas Lieutenant Governor Bill Halter submitted a proposal that would institute a state lottery by 2008....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Global Business in Emerging Regions

In PPP terms China's China's economy is worth $17.... billion which is slightly higher than America's economy that is worth $17.... Chinese social economy is the largest in the world in terms of PPP and second largest in terms of nominal GDP.... Although this account is disputed, there is however no denial to the fact that… Back in 1995 china's share to the global GDP was just 2% however as of 2013 china's share of global GDP is 12%....
14 Pages (3500 words) Coursework

Is the Sacrifice Worth It

According to the Merriam-Webster dictionary, the word sacrifice has been defined as 'something is given up or lost' or 'destruction or surrender of something for the sake of something else'.... This paper "Is the Sacrifice Worth It" discusses what is worth sacrificing for; is it happiness, morals, and ethics, or just about anything else, materialistically speaking, that would make someone else happier than the person giving it up was when he owned it.... However, was the same worth sacrificing for?...
5 Pages (1250 words) Assignment

A Picture Says a Thousand Words

This report "A Picture Says a Thousand Words" presents a collection of some of the most iconic images in history, analyzing how they influenced people in their particular social, cultural, and political context.... The images represent the strength of human beings even in the worst of circumstances....
6 Pages (1500 words) Report

The Passionate Contributions of Justin Martyr for Todays Christian

This literature review "The Passionate Contributions of Justin martyr for Today's Christian" presents the life of Justin Martyr that is a typical illustration of what it takes to attain great things in life; Justin had a lengthy career of a lifetime ranging from philosophy, and finally a martyr.... aint Justin martyr was born in c....
11 Pages (2750 words) Literature review

Social Work Direct Practice Skills

Social workers are guided by values and ethics, which help them to exhibit appropriate behaviors when dealing with clients.... ethics deals with what is right, good, and correct.... … The paper "Social Work Direct Practice Skills" is a good example of a term paper on sociology....
9 Pages (2250 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us