StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Was Japanese Colonialism Different from Western Colonialism - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper “Was Japanese Colonialism Different from Western Colonialism?” states Japan’s attitude towards its colonial subjects fundamentally differed from its counterpart in the west can be inferred by the fact that it came from a 200-year isolationist policy of the Tokugawa Shogunate…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.5% of users find it useful
Was Japanese Colonialism Different from Western Colonialism
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Was Japanese Colonialism Different from Western Colonialism"

? “Japanese colonialism was fundamentally different from western colonialism.” Do you agree? I. Introduction The act or exercise of dominating individuals or groups over a territory may constitute colonialism, but not all forms of colonialism are the same. While colonialism shares the same component of a specific nation exercising power or control over another sovereign country (Horvath, 1972), different colonizing countries, depending upon their circumstances, may have different motivation, purpose, and timeline from other colonizing countries. Such, it cannot be generalized that all colonial nations follow the same form of colonialism that bears the same geopolitical meaning and practice across regions and continents. This fundamental difference in colonialism can be best illustrated in the case of Japan when contrasted with its colonialist counterpart in the western part of the world where its colonialist differences were identified in this paper. The most plausible cause that can be identified for this difference was that Japan jumped in the colonialist foray later than its western counterpart that it had an implication why colonialism in the East, particularly Japan, fundamentally differed from its counterpart in the West. It can be surmised that while the west has already a deep experience of colonizing, the idea of colonialism was only impinged into the consciousness of Japan in the 1870’s with the Meiji Restoration (Myers and Peattie, 1984) which has an implication on how it exercised its power and prerogative over its colonized countries. Japan’s exposure in colonialist effort was short while its western counterparts had already a long history of colonizing exploits that stretched as far back as 900 A.D. with the crusades. This wide gap in terms of colonizing experience has an implication on Japan’s motivation, purpose and method of colonizing that fundamentally differed from the West which will be elaborated in this paper. This difference in timeline of arriving in the colonial scene shall be used as a framework to discuss why Japan’s colonialist tendency was fundamentally different compared to that of the west. This approach will reveal the difference of their motivation for expansion and treatment of their “subjects” that will underpin fundamental differences of their colonialist practices. II. The Fundamental Difference of Japanese Colonialism from Western Colonialism A. Timeline and motivation for being a colonial power The western colonizers have a very long and deep experience in colonizing. While Japan as a country was still struggling among itself in 900 A.D., Europe has already embarked on a crusade to reclaim the Holy Land from the Turks and Saracens in the Middle East. Needless to say, the West already has already a deep experience with colonizing while Japan only learned the idea of colonialism in the 1870’s. It is also important to note that before the Meiji Restoration in the 1870’s, it came from a 200 year isolationist policy of the Tokugawa Shogunate and as such, was economically and military inferior compared to the west. In addition, Japan began with the same disadvantages just like its neighboring Asian countries. Also, just like any other non-European states, it was forced to sign unequal treaties that chafed the ire of its nationalists as an infringement of its national sovereignty. Moreso, when Commodore Matthew Perry of the United States came to Japan in 1853 with its fleet that forced Japan to open itself to trade and end its self-imposed isolation (Myers and Peattie, 1984:78). This made Japan realize how backward they were and prompted them to embark on a nationalist endeavor to strengthen itself and become a respected country. This sentiment was recorded by a memorandum of saga samurai, Eto Shimpei in 1856 that “what was required . . ., was a long-range plan to utilize the talents, not merely of all Japanese, but of talent wherever it might be found in tools, in arms, in medicine, in land development, in astronomy, and so on, should be utilized for the development of national wealth and strength”. This sentiment later served as a platform of Japanese expansionist policy towards Formosa, Korea and later Taiwan. The impetus which propelled Japan to become a colonial state is starkly different from its European counterpart. Aside from religious fervor, the west colonial power’s primary reason for colonialism was more driven by “scientific intellectual curiosity, by the frustrations and daring of merchant adventurers, and by the naked greed of established elite classes” whereas Japan only rose as a colonial power out of its determination to abrogate unequal and arbitrary treatise and to become a respected country. B. Japan did not assume the “white man’s” burden During the early colonial years, western colonizers were predominantly Caucasian and carried with them an air of racial and cultural superiority over their subjugated subjects. This air of racial and cultural superiority gave the colonizers the impression that it is their obligation to lord over the whole world to provide economic and cultural development over underdeveloped countries. It also made the western colonizers to believe that it is a noble enterprise to colonize “savages” in the underdeveloped countries because they are doing them a favor of improving their socio-cultural well-being. This is viewed in the light of the western colonizers condescension and scorn for their colonized countries as backward and inferior. Japan did not share the racial bigotry of their western counterparts when it colonialised other countries. When Japan formally acquired its first colony after the Sino-Japanese War (1894-95) by the Treaty of Shimonoseki, Formosa was treated without racial condescension as Japan “followed generally the same procedures which had been and were being used in promoting the modernization of the homeland” (Kublin, 1959:77). Japan did not have the pretension of the white man to “civilize” its colony other than serving the interest of the mother country (Kublin, 1959). In this aspect, Japan was essentially different compared to its western colonizing counterpart as it did not rationalize its expansionist tendency as a moral obligation other than to serve the interest of its mother country. C. Forced assimilation Japan may be no different from its western counterparts in assuming that its way of life is superior to its colonial subjects. But unlike its western counterpart, who encouraged its subjects to adopt and assume its own culture and way of life, Japan did not encourage its colonial subjects to adapt to “the culture and ways of the metropolitan country; for Japan with its traditions of social and cultural conformity this policy was evidently inconceivable” (Kublin, 1959). Instead, Japan implemented the forced assimilation such as the enforcement of State Shinto nationalism and asserted brotherhood among Koreans to facilitate assimilation. Japan also deliberately replaced the educational institution of Korea to make it Japanese eradicate the native culture. While Japan pursued forced assimilation, there was a contradiction to its policy because it did not share its cultural and social tradition to Korea. Instead, it campaigned to obliterate and remove Korea’s 2,000 year old culture which became traumatic to its subject more than its draconian rule and merciless economic exploitation (Myers and Peattie, 1984). This policy of forced assimilation is fundamentally different with the western colonizers as the latter did not attempt to eliminate its colony’s sense of national identity but only sought to improve it by influencing them with its own culture and “better way of life”. The Japanese idea of improving the cultural and social context of its subject is by methodologically eliminating the existing culture of its subject and replacing it with its own such as the case of Korea. The Japanese was only acquainted with colonization, which is distinct from colonialism, whose sole experience at Hokkaido in 1873-1883 provided them with a “practical experience in creating a settlement colony which is different with the British colonisation of Australia and New Zealand wherein wherein a government settles its own lands with its own peoples” (Myers and Peattie, 1984:80). D. Japan’s colonialist expansionary policy was government driven Unlike the West or Europe who was under the influence of Roman Catholic Church during its early days whose motivation was to “Christianize” the pagans or reclaim the Holy Land from the infidels, Japan’s motivation towards colonialism was driven primarily by the government’s desire to rise in power as quickly as possible. This was primarily motivated by the desire to abrogate unfair treatise and apprehension over western aggression. Especially when the United States sent a fleet of ships in 1853 under the command of Commodore Matthew Perry to Japan in order to end the nation's self-imposed isolation and open itself to trade. That incident induced the Japanese government spearheaded by the Meiji Restoration to pursue a policy of national progression when they realized how backward they were coming from a 200 year isolationist policy of the Tokogawa regime (Kublin, 1959. This was essentially different from the west as their motivation to colonize was a singular and raw desire to rise in power unlike in the west whose motivation varies from “scientific intellectual curiosity, by the frustrations and daring of merchant adventurers, by the naked greed of established elite classes, by evangelical and missionary fervor, to the quest of emigrants for the political and economic opportunities closed to them at home” (Kublin, 1959). III. Conclusion Japan’s attitude towards its colonial subjects fundamentally differed from its counterpart in the west can be inferred by the fact that it came from a 200 year isolationist policy of the Tokugawa Shogunate. It can said that when it decided to embark on a rapid economic expansion which served as its platform of its colonialist exploits, it still carried that isolationist mindset that is why it is quite intolerant when it practiced its hegemony among its colonial subjects. This is best illustrated with its treatment with Korea where it methodologically attempted to replaced and eliminate the existing 2000 years Korean culture. It also showed brutality when it occupied the Philippines and Japan was mercilessly exploitative when it occupied Formosa. Still, considering where it came from before Commodore Matthew Perry of the United States came to Japan in 1853 where its fleet forced Japan to open itself to trade to end its self-imposed isolation, it was able to embark on a colonialist conquest in a very short period of time. It only fundamentally differed with the treatment of its colonial subjects compared to its counterpart in the west due to its isolationist mindset that manifested in the treatment of its colonial subjects. REFERENCES: Kublin, Hyman (1959). The Evolution of Japanese Colonialism. Comparative Studies in Society and History. Cambridge University Press. Vol. 2, No. 1, pp. 67-84. Myers, Ramon H. and Peattie, Mark R. (1984). The Japanese Colonial Empire, 1895-1945. Princeton University Press, United Kingdom. Horvath, Ronald J. (1972). A Definition of Colonialism. The University of Chicago Press on behalf of Wenner-Gren Foundation for Anthropological Research. Current Anthropology. Vol. 13, No. 1 (Feb., 1972), pp. 45-57 Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Japanese colonialism was fundamentally different from western Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1431193-ypjapanese-colonialism-was-fundamentally-different
(Japanese Colonialism Was Fundamentally Different from Western Essay)
https://studentshare.org/history/1431193-ypjapanese-colonialism-was-fundamentally-different.
“Japanese Colonialism Was Fundamentally Different from Western Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1431193-ypjapanese-colonialism-was-fundamentally-different.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Was Japanese Colonialism Different from Western Colonialism

The South Debts, Western Economic and Political Control

Impact of colonialism in AfricaThe African continent is made of a group of countries that are largely considered developing.... Years of colonialism and exploitation from the Western countries depleted their natural resources and brought socio-political turmoil into their lives (Salifu, 2010).... Although colonialism has also affected various 'southern' territories, this portion shall focus on the impact of colonialism on Africa....
15 Pages (3750 words) Essay

Was Decolonization Beneficial for Former Colonies

“If colonialism distorted economies, freedom did not always deliver prosperity.... colonialism had lasted for centuries and the traditional models of government and social life had been transformed greatly.... Emancipation from foreign rule was yielded by nationalist zeal, and sacrifices of the masses and was considered as the major benefit of decolonization.... Nonetheless, few colonies were in a better position to evolve naturally out of decolonization into independent and sovereign states that had adequate infrastructure to shift from colonization to decolonization in a smooth and planned manner....
16 Pages (4000 words) Essay

From firepower to finance:the evolution of colonial and neo-colonial power

In the century that followed, the nations of Europe and the United States would find colonialism to be an unwieldy and ruinous practice born of hubris and a misguided belief in the efficacy and sustainability of force.... As the chaotic aftermath of World War 2 gave rise to the Cold War, old notions of colonialism morphed into new forms designed to serve the political agendas of the U.... This “neo-colonialism” has given way to “corporate colonialism,” a product of economic globalization and the technology-enabled interconnectedness of business and banking interests the world over....
15 Pages (3750 words) Research Paper

Japanese Colonialism Was no Different to Western Colonialism

Japanese colonialism was no different to western colonialism Colonialism refers to the extension of political and economic control of a government to other nations.... The Japanese aimed to have a controlled empire which would be controlled from Tokyo and the laws would be no different from those which govern the original Japanese nation.... World war two ultimately led to a decline of colonialism where political unrest resulted in the demand of independence by natives of colonized areas....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Influence of Colonialism on Political Structures of Africa Nations

Presently, like most parts of the world, Africa has different people, cultures, languages and history partly because of colonialism (Hrituleac 2).... However, most political science and history research analyzes the implication of colonialism in a holistic manner.... Moreover, the debate of the political and economic influence of colonialism in Africa is still open with some school of thoughts arguing that colonialism has assisted Africa more than exploited it....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Influence of Colonialism on Politics and Economics of Africa Nations

However, most political science and history research analyzes the implication of colonialism in a holistic manner.... Moreover, the debate of the political and economic influence of colonialism in Africa is still open with some school of thoughts arguing that colonialism has assisted ... This paper will attempt to weigh in on the debate by using secondary data to explore the influence of colonialism in Africa by observing three African countries with distinct colonial history....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Japanese Colonialism

While colonialism shares the same component of a specific nation exercising power or control over another sovereign country.... Such, it cannot be generalized that all colonial nations follow the same form of colonialism that bears the same This fundamental difference in colonialism can be best illustrated in the case of Japan when contrasted with its colonialist counterpart in the western part of the world where its colonialist differences were identified in this paper....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Sexuality and Gender in Asia as an Erotic of the Exotic

The colonial soldiers saw Asian women as quite different from their women at home.... "Sexuality and Gender in Asia as an Erotic of the Exotic" paper discusses how western colonization changed the aspects of gender and sexuality of Asians with reference to some examples from Asian countries.... Stereotyping of Asian women as exotic and sexual objects deeply roots itself in the colonization of the Asian countries by the western countries.... Briefly, western colonization did figure these women as materials of possession....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us