StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Discovery and Preservation of the Miami Circle - Article Example

Cite this document
Summary
The article "Discovery and Preservation of the Miami Circle" focuses on the critical analysis of the major issues in the history, discovery, and preservation of the Miami Circle. The Miami Circle is an archaeological discovery that has raked up a lot of controversial issues…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.4% of users find it useful
Discovery and Preservation of the Miami Circle
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Discovery and Preservation of the Miami Circle"

It was called Bricknell Avenue, named after William Bricknell, the co-founder of Miami. Baumann had to let the site undergo a routine archaeological excavation of the site before he started on his ambitious project to construct a luxury condominium there. The excavation, conducted under Bob Carr revealed a patterned group of holes of various sizes cut into the oolitic limestone. This covered a circular shaped area of 38 feet in diameter. And the excavated earth contained various artifacts like shell tools and stone axe heads. Other crucial discoveries included human teeth and charcoal from fires. According to the diary report of Ryan J Wheeler, one of the archeologists who participated in the excavation, they also found "….some concrete, modern glass, and other construction fill, lower portions produced nineteenth-century materials, including the fragmentary neck of a blown green glass bottle and a wire-wound glass button, probably from a ladies' blouse or jacket" (Wheeler).

A controversy regarding the preservation of the site ensued, especially after the suggestion by Baumann to relocate the circle to another location for which he offered to pay the expenses so that he could pursue the construction of the condominium. But there was a general resentment among the general public which included archaeologists, Native Americans, new agers, and school children. And the State the State of Florida Preservation 2000 land acquisition program had to purchase the disputed site from Bachmann for $26.7 million.

The radiocarbon dating, conducted in 1999 revealed that the wood was 1800 to 2000 years old. John Ricisak a specialist in the County Historic Preservation department confirmed this finding against the skeptical view that the age of the holes cannot be decided from the radiocarbon dating of the wood. However, the argument that the holes belonged to the modern age was further disputed by Tom Scott and Harvey Means, Florida Geological Survey, who brought to light the fact that there was a buildup of calcite duracrust on the edge of the cut face, which cannot happen in the case of modern objects.

The artifacts that were found are supposed to belong to the Tequesta native group which existed before the European settlement of the area. But to come to such a conclusion, other possibilities were to be discounted. There is no proof that native North Americans built such permanent structures so long ago. And the hypothesis that the site could have belonged to the Olmec or Mayan civilizations was more or less ruled out as there was no evidence of any artifact belonging to Central American origin on the site. According to Bob Carr, “Mayan architecture is always rectilinear, except for the observatory in the Yucatan, so nothing about this fits a Mayan connection”. He thinks that the references to Mayan civilization in this context are “just an exotic way to explain it” (Nimnicht). There exists an argument that the holes were postholes of some structure, some sort of foundation for a building. Another hint is that it could have been a burial site, but the excavators could find only a five-foot-long shark skeleton, a dolphin skull, and a complete carapace of a sea turtle. Apart from the four human teeth found on the site, nothing confirmed to the idea that it could have a common burial ground.

The controversy regarding the decision of the State to spend a phenomenal amount on the project reached its height with the hunch by the University of Florida archaeologist Jerald T Milanich that the Circle can be nothing but the septic tank of the previous apartment building there. Bob Carr and John Ricisak had to bring in a lot of evidence and new lines of argument to counter this proposition. Such alternate theories and even speculations like the possibility of aliens and the mythical city of Atlantis remain unproved to date. Though Milanich created a series of controversies through his publication titled “American Scene: Much Ado About a Circle”, he sums it up introspectively, on how Miami Circle has influenced people in general: "Whatever the circle is, or is not, it is encouraging to see so many people step forward when it seems an important archaeological monument is threatened. Because of the Miami Circle, a lot of people have learned a great deal about Native American history and now recognize that we must work together to understand and preserve that legacy" (Milanich).

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Miami Circle Article Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Miami Circle Article Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1513959-miami-circle
(Miami Circle Article Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
Miami Circle Article Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words. https://studentshare.org/history/1513959-miami-circle.
“Miami Circle Article Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1513959-miami-circle.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Discovery and Preservation of the Miami Circle

Retail Competition: In-Store Strategies of Primark and Forever 21

This essay "Retail Competition: In-Store Strategies of Primark and Forever 21" presents Primark and Forever 21 that have successfully used in-store atmosphere/ambiance to distinguish its goods from their competitors and to communicate with their consumers.... ... ... ... The atmospheric shopping environments at both stores ensure that impulse buying is a very real possibility....
20 Pages (5000 words) Essay

Las Vegas as a Western City

This discovery was able to shorten the trail from Los Angeles and lent a positive aspect to hasten the rush west for California gold.... Just 14 short years after Rivera's discovery, John C.... This essay "Las Vegas as a Western City" discusses the entertainment capital of the world, which is one specific name given to the City of Las Vegas....
14 Pages (3500 words) Essay

Men as Contemporary Shopping Spectacles in London

The late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries saw a growing feminized consumerism.... Women have been classified as an active consumer and also a spectacle under the masculine gaze.... But what the period also saw is the consumerisation of masculinity; a paradoxical statement but nevertheless, the advertising industry motivated the men to consume male " beauty culture " products and other commodities claiming to modify the male body. ...
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Does Playing Violent Video Games Increase Aggressiveness

Principal Investigator (PI) InformationName Maricel WalshRelationship to NSU:Faculty Staff Student xHome Mailing Address (for students)15420 SW 74th circle ct City/State/Zip: Miami, Fl 33193Office Phone:786 873 0511Home Phone (for students):305 752 7884NSU Center/College/Dept:Farguhar College Behavioral Science Dept....
17 Pages (4250 words) Research Paper

Insight in Australian ancient Aboriginal Rock- Art

The essay examines what is rock art and analyzes evaluation of its relevance in a broader context of Aboriginal Art.... Rock Art is the most direct way of studying past human life.... It is like a photograph of pre-historic life.... It is found all over the world, in every continent.... ... ... ... This essay analyzes Australian ancient Aboriginal Rock- Art....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Circles in a Circle by Vasily Kandinsky

The work of art chosen for this essay is Circles in a circle by Vasily Kandinsky.... The paper analyzes Vasily Kandinsky's "Circles in a circle".... The essay "Circles in a circle by Vasily Kandinsky" explores the work of art Circles in a circle by Vasily Kandinsky.... One could read Circles within a circle as a tribute to the musical genius from the Baroque era....
5 Pages (1250 words) Term Paper

Pros and Cons of Implementing Literature Circles

The main purpose of the literature circle is to engage the student(s) in a discussion wherein they will be assigned to share their personal thoughts and ideas with regards to the topic or issues being examined or explored by the author(s).... (Daniels, 2002) The study of Daniels (2002) shows that elementary students who have undergone a literature circle-based activities in classrooms were able to attain a 10% higher score as compared to students in other schools who did not go through the same teaching method....
15 Pages (3750 words) Assignment

IR Theory: Globalization & Fragmentation

This research paper "IR Theory: Globalization & Fragmentation" discusses IR theory that entails the development of conceptual frameworks to facilitate the understanding and explanation of events and phenomena in world politics as well as the analysis an informing of associated policies and practices....
50 Pages (12500 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us