StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

On IT Doesn't Matter - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
The case argues that information technology, while important, will become commoditized and essentially cease to be a point of differentiation for firms, and no longer strategic. On the other hand, it can be argued that IT can be an enabler of other strategies for competitive…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91% of users find it useful
Case Study on IT Doesnt Matter
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "On IT Doesn't Matter"

Case Study Table of Contents Case Analysis 3 Works Cited 4 Case Analysis The case argues that information technology, while important, will become commoditized and essentially cease to be a point of differentiation for firms, and no longer strategic. On the other hand, it can be argued that IT can be an enabler of other strategies for competitive advantage that build on the power that IT brings to firms. This progression can follow the way of other technologies that preceded IT, such as the combustion engine, as well as electricity.

One key lesson is how to use this insight to help strategists put any plans in perspective. If IT can no longer be a source of differentiation and competitive moving forward, how is one to properly strategize? One take is that while no longer strategic, IT investment and excellence remains something that is essential, as a kind of ticket to the game. Another take is that companies who are able to glean insights into how technology is to be used to further their own strategies have a leg up on others.

The case makes the point for saturation of infrastructure, where like in railroads there was a rapid and massive building phase, followed by a capacity glut. Again the take here is with capacity overbuilt strategies must look beyond using IT as a source of advantage, but rather something that is a given, to excel at, but not to necessarily get ahead of the others, who are basically doing the same thing and enjoying the same benefits from IT. Moreover, the insight from the paper is that there is the risk that companies may continue to spend a considerable part of their funds on IT, not heeding the warning from other companies, who are not realizing returns commensurate with the level of IT investments.

These constitute investment and operational, as well as broader risks. The lessons learned are in this area. The prescription from the article is that of greater focus on astuteness when it comes to investing in IT, focusing on such things as efficiency, and return on investments. What this means for strategy is that more care must be placed on those things that can add real value to the firm and differentiate it from others in the same field, and the warning is that IT is not the way to achieve this.

It is necessary, but it will not get you very far in terms of building a sustainable source of competitive advantage. One insight from the article is that that we should look elsewhere. There are problems in terms of actually having to excel in IT as a prerequisite for succeeding, to get to the starting block, but having likewise to go beyond that and to consider other strategies in other areas of the business, for example in innovation in key focus areas. The recommendation is to do this exactly, while making sure to optimize investments in IT as a given.

Investments in IT should not get in the way of devising sound strategies that go beyond IT, is the take, and the recommendation. The literature is increasingly replete with references to IT investments not as strategic investments but as necessary investments whose risks need to be managed, and this pieces of literature, for one, show the wisdom of the insights provided by Carr. Risk management in IT investments is a recognition that IT investments need to be viewed in the same way as other essential but not growth-inducing or differentiation-creating investments.

The same can be said of literature investigating the impact of IT investments on firm valuation or market value, which is to say, that the general lack of impact on firm valuation due to its investments in IT further corroborate what Carr is saying about IT investments being necessary but not necessarily equivalent to improving the future prospects of the firm relative to competitors and the general market (Carr; Dos Santos et al.; Benaroch and Kauffman). Works CitedCarr, Nicholas. “IT Doesnt Matter”.

Harvard Business School at Large. May 2003. Benaroch, Michel and Robert Kauffman. “A Case for Using Real Options Pricing Analysis to Evaluate Information Technology Project Investments”. Information Systems Research 1 (10). March 1999. Web. 29 January 2013. Dos Santos, B. et al. “The Impact of Information Technology Investment Announcements on the Market Value of the Firm”. Information Systems Research 1 (4). March 1993. Web. 29 January 2013.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Case Study on IT Doesn't Matter Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 250 words”, n.d.)
Case Study on IT Doesn't Matter Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 250 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/information-technology/1613880-case-study-on-it-doesnt-matter
(Case Study on IT Doesn'T Matter Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 250 Words)
Case Study on IT Doesn'T Matter Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 250 Words. https://studentshare.org/information-technology/1613880-case-study-on-it-doesnt-matter.
“Case Study on IT Doesn'T Matter Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 250 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/information-technology/1613880-case-study-on-it-doesnt-matter.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Case Study on IT Doesn't Matter

Shipmaster's Liability for Loss or Damage of Goods Resulting from Their Transporting

The study "Shipmaster's Liability for Loss or Damage of Goods Resulting from Their Transporting" discusses standard salvage contracts in the international maritime community which set the criteria on which the salvage award would be based, and where and how any disputes would be settled.... nbsp;  … The Bulk-Carrier has a lot of violations that were committed if we are to deal with the Haque-Visby rules, with reference regarding the responsibility of the cargo vessel to transport goods from the starting point down to the receiver....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

Addiction problems

he first scenario is that the nurse could be sued for negligence in the matter of the patient having fractured the neck of her femur.... Mrs.... Smith was aged 85 and on 28 November 2009 was admitted to hospital with pneumonia.... On 1st December 2009, she was being assisted by a nurse to get out of bed when she slipped on a wet floor and sustained a fractured neck of her right femur....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

Media and Entertainment Law in Ireland

It's all about the law of media and entertainment when it comes to work through posts sitting both the worker and the dealer far away from each other.... The informally or unofficially made agreements might cause any of the two parties to get dishonest.... Though, here in the case study, when in Ireland, Ms....
10 Pages (2500 words) Case Study

Analysis of Case Concerning Immigration Asylum

"A requirement of promptness and reasonable expedition is implicit in all cases but where the possibility of removing the individual from the harmful situation is available, the investigation must be undertaken as a matter of urgency.... Margarita's situation is delicate, and this will be discussed in the realm of: a) the five Convention reasons and articles of the ECHR on which to base her claim; b) the issue of persecution/well-founded fear and future persecution; c) sufficiency of protection from the Ecuadorian authorities; and d) the issue of internal relocation. … One of the issues with the articles of the ECHR is that there is a statute that forbids any kind of illegal activity, such as human trafficking to go on....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

The Concept of Depressive Psychological Condition

She had dated her boyfriend for 2 years when he proposed to her.... Her parents are rich people and have always provided her with whatever she demanded; also, they are happily married and their… Elena says she has never seen them arguing and their marriage is an example for her.... When she was talking about her fiancée she seemed sad and told that her parents had always been against their relationships; h she always knew their relationships wouldn't work because there were a lot of things she couldn't be able to accept in her fiancée, still she always tried to save the relationships....
5 Pages (1250 words) Case Study

Conflict Resolution at General Hospital

The case study “Conflict Resolution at General Hospital” is related to the General Hospital that has been at a declining stage because of the increasing costs.... The aim of the study has been to identify the conflict management style as practiced by Mike Hammer.... hellip; The case study is all about the General Hospital that has been facing problems and the performance of the organization has been declining....
5 Pages (1250 words) Case Study

Evolution of Master Motors Organization

This work "Evolution of Master Motors Organization" focuses on the Italian car manufacturer Master Motors.... The author outlines the company's objective to provide a seamless, smooth, and comfortable driving experience to its customers.... It is clear about its opportunities, strength, weakness, the possibilities of online booking, and Residential test drive....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study

Improving Inclusion Classroom

In this matter, some of the questions were designed in such a way to investigate whether the person knows their roles and the roles of the inclusion classroom in the district.... The paper "Improving Inclusion Classroom" clears up that there is no staff trained to deal with special education....
5 Pages (1250 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us