StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Moral and Ethical Dilemma in the ase of Spaulding v Zimmerman - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
This paper tells that the case of Spaulding v Zimmerman involves a moral and ethical issue that demonstrates the typical conflict that a lawyer faces between protecting his client’s interests yet ensuring that fairness and justice are achieved…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.4% of users find it useful
Moral and Ethical Dilemma in the ase of Spaulding v Zimmerman
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Moral and Ethical Dilemma in the ase of Spaulding v Zimmerman"

Ethics Question The case of Spaulding v Zimmerman involves a moral and ethical issue that demonstrates the typical conflict that a lawyer faces between protecting his client’s interests yet ensuring that fairness and justice are achieved. This case presents an ethical dilemma wherein the question of disclosure arises as a mandate to satisfy the requirements of morality and truth, but in an instance where it is not advantageous to the client’s interests. The Law Council of Australia has established rules for model conduct of lawyers1, however these tend to revolve around a client centered approach which is inimical to the practice of law in an ethical manner, rather it tends to be centered around better earning and protecting the client at any cost.

2 Such a client centered approach makes lawyers amoral and indifferent to maintain ethical standards or morality in the practice of law, thereby engaging in role differentiated behavior that ignores moral considerations in the case of clients, which would be relevant and applicable in the lawyer’s own life.3 Warrerstrom argues that while such an approach may be useful in criminal cases in ensuring that all clients get a fair chance in court, irrespective of the lawyer’s personal convictions in that relevant area, it is not applicable on a wider basis to all cases.

Positivist philosophy also separates law and morals, so that a lawyer is not necessarily required to make a moral decision, rather he/she is expected to ensure that the client’s best interests are served as far as possible within the framework of the law. In the instant case of Spaulding v Zimmerman, the issue that arises is the need to disclose potentially damaging information mandated from an ethical standpoint. Lawyers are to work in the best interests of their clients, yet they are also considered officers of the Court who must serve the cause of fairness, equity and jsuitce.

4 A lawyer has a paramount duty to the Court5 to pursue the course of justice, which shapes the kind of society that we live in. Allowing individuals to escape with wrong doing is not in the interests of justice or fairness to all men. Therefore, in the instant case, the professional responsibility of the lawyer would have mandated the disclosure of knowledge that could be inimical to the Plaintiff fin the long run, especially since the Defendants were morally in the wrong, to have caused bodily harm to the Plaintiff.

However the argument of the defendants also holds merit, in that it is the responsibility of the plaintiff and plaintiff’s counsel to ensure that his best interests are served, therefore they were not obliged to disclose the contents of the medical report. In this moral and ethical dilemma, it must be remembered that the purpose of litigation is to secure justice. Unless full and fair compensation is made to the Plaintiff for injuries sustained as a result of acts of the defendant, true justice cannot be said to be done.

It is the lawyer’s professional responsibility to disclose all evidence relevant to the case and not merely that which favors his own client, which in a sense, amounts to the concealment or manipulation of evidence.6 Therefore in this case the actions of the lawyer in concealing evidence relevant to the case was not ethical or professional. In the same place, I believe that such evidence should have been disclosed because its nature is such that its relevance to the final decision cannot be ignored or set aside.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Moral and Ethical Dilemma in the ase of Spaulding v Zimmerman Case Study”, n.d.)
Moral and Ethical Dilemma in the ase of Spaulding v Zimmerman Case Study. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1538131-ethics-no-2-mini-essay
(Moral and Ethical Dilemma in the Ase of Spaulding V Zimmerman Case Study)
Moral and Ethical Dilemma in the Ase of Spaulding V Zimmerman Case Study. https://studentshare.org/law/1538131-ethics-no-2-mini-essay.
“Moral and Ethical Dilemma in the Ase of Spaulding V Zimmerman Case Study”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1538131-ethics-no-2-mini-essay.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Moral and Ethical Dilemma in the ase of Spaulding v Zimmerman

Dishonoring a Persons Moral Rights

Many have argued about the extent of moral rights but the issue still remains as a moral and ethical dilemma in the present society.... Many have argued about the extent of moral rights but the issue still remains as a moral and ethical dilemma in the present society.... In Gazzaniga's book, “The Ethical Brain: The Science of Our Ethical Dilemmas,” the author addresses the issue using neuroscience, hence giving light to the moral and ethical dilemma....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Confidentiality as an Ethical Dilemma

This is the nature of an ethical dilemma in which confidentiality is an issue.... The key facts that create an ethical dilemma when confidentiality must be breached are first, the nature of an ethical dilemma in which confidentiality is an issue.... hellip; The essay "Confidentiality as an ethical dilemma" shows the key facts that create an ethical dilemma when confidentiality must be breached.... According to Stephen Behnke, APA ethics director, (2005), “confidentiality is the core value of the profession,” but when faced with an ethical dilemma, the APA Ethics Code can offer guidance in a difficult situation....
4 Pages (1000 words) Article

Making Ethical Decisions and Choices

These things are rewards for the achievement and maintenance of high moral and ethical standards.... ethical decisions and choices are made by people in every day.... As people increasingly under public scrutiny, they find themselves exposed to complex ethical issues.... hellip; There are many ethical issues with which society struggles and points to ethical systems as tools that can be used to solve ethical dilemmas....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Moral Dilemmas in Nursing

hellip; An ethical or moral dilemma is a situation that presents two options, and a choice has to be made between them, neither of the choices serves to resolve the situation or dilemma in an ethically acceptable way.... Ethics Ethics Ethical or moral dilemma is a situation that presents two options, and a choice has to be made between them, neither of the choices serves to resolve the situation or dilemma in an ethically acceptable way.... Health leaders and ethical dimensions of managing "value adds”....
1 Pages (250 words) Coursework

Treatment of Ethical Dilemmas

So complicated is the issue of abortion that until today, there has not been a general ethical dilemma YourFirst YourLast Introduction Ethical dilemmas can be defined as difficult situations where individuals are faced with situations that are not obvious or straightforward and which on many occasions cause an individual to wonder whether to obey their moral duty or act according to how society or a situation demands of them.... Is paediatric research an ethical dilemma?...
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The Moral and Ethical Dilemma Faced by the Model TX

The author discusses the moral and ethical dilemma faced by the company.... Through this advertisement, the company has involved itself in such moral and ethical dilemmas that it would be very tough to come out of them.... The discussion includes an analysis of appropriate ethical theories.... hellip; Various pressure groups that can protect the consumers' interests against unethical marketing include regulatory agencies which are organized by the government itself and other groups which are self-regulatory such as the Better Business Bureau have established formal methods to deal with ethical concerns related to marketing....
8 Pages (2000 words) Assignment

The Ethical Dilemma: Making the Moral Decision

"The ethical dilemma: Making the Moral Decision" paper defines an ethical dilemma and explores the decision-making process used to arrive at a decision where all the options have significant consequences.... Confronting an ethical dilemma merely a matter of taking an action that we can morally justify to our own sense of personal integrity.... This paper will define an ethical dilemma and explore the decision-making process used to arrive at a decision where all the options have significant consequences....
6 Pages (1500 words) Coursework

Situations of Moral Dilemma

According to Gandhi, there is an amicable solution to every dilemma in life.... This essay "Moral dilemma" discusses decisions that are bestowed on a human being.... When faced with a moral dilemma a decision has to be made.... hellip; The best way to take the approach is to understand all elements that are manifested in a certain dilemma.... The decision made on moral dilemma must also reflect sacrifice and love for humanity....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us