StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Agreement between Orlando and Helen - Assignment Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Agreement between Orlando and Helen " is an outstanding example of a law assignment. The issue is the case is whether there existed an agreement between Orlando and Helen and whether Helen does have to sell the special offer set to Orlando? This arose out of the fact that Helen sold the antique broach and hair clip to Angelica despite having created an open offer with Orlando…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.3% of users find it useful

Extract of sample "Agreement between Orlando and Helen"

BUSINESS LAW STUDENT NAME POFESSOR’S NAME COURSE TITLE DATE PART A Question 1 The issue is the case is whether there existed an agreement between Orlando and Helen and whether Helen does have to sell the special offer set to Orlando? This arose out of the fact that Helen sold the antique broach and hair clip to Anglelica despite having created an open offer with Orlando who had communicated acceptance at 10pm. An offer in law is the willingness of parties to be bound by the stated terms of a contract1. In Harvey v Facey2, Harvey sent a telegram to Facey stating whether he would sell him a bumper hall pen and Facey replied by stating the lowest price of $900, and Harvey replied to Facey saying he sends the deed for early possession. The Privy Council stated there was no offer hence no contract. A general rule in communicating an offer requires that there must be an effective communication of acceptance of the offer. In the case of Entores v Miles Far East, the court held that acceptance needs to be communicated for it to be effective. The method of acceptance is important especially when the offeror specifically communicates the mode of acceptance and that that the acceptance reaches the offeror by the specific mode of communication3. In case where there is breach of contract, a claimant is allowed to sue for breach of contract as was held in Adams v Lindsell4 where the claimant sued for breach of contract when the defendant sold wool to another customer despite having sent a letter of acceptance that was delayed in the course of posting. The court held that the acceptance was effective as soon as the letter was posted and not when the defendant receives it. In the law of contract, an offeror needs to communicate the revocation of an offer to the offeree and if the offeror fails to revoke an offer, then the offer is still effective as held in Bryne v Tienhoven5 . The revocation of an offer needs to be personal to the offeree or through a reliable third party6. The law in instantaneous communication regarding communication of acceptance has been set in the case of Brinkinbon v Stahad Stahl Gmbh7 that once one communicates acceptance through an instantaneous communication the contract is valid when the communication of acceptance is received. A term of a contract whether express or implied include any statement that appears on a written agreement and makes the contract more binding as held in Routledge v McKay8 with the statement going into the root of the contract. A term is determined when it can be inferred from the parties conduct that there was an intention for inclusion of that particular statement in a contractual document. Pre-contractual terms form part of a contract if the parties intend that the term will be part of the contract9. In the case of Helen v Orlando, the parties made a pre-contractual statement that she will keep the offer open for acceptance until 10 am the next day. This constituted an open offer since Orlando was allowed to communicate acceptance by 10am Thursday. There was a valid offer as was the case in Harvey v Facey10and acceptance as was the case in Brinkinbon v Stahad Stahl Gmbh11 since the acceptance is deemed to have been received when it was made at 10pm. There was no valid revocation of the contract since Helen contacted Orlando at 10am when she had already sold the broach and hair clip at 9.30am before the expiration of the terms to leave the offer open and the law clearly states that the revocation of the offer needs to be communicated. The fact that Helen contacted Orlando after selling the subject matter of the contract implies that she was in breach of the contract. In conclusion, there is a valid contract between Orlando and Helen and that Orlando can sue for specific performance to compel Helen to sell to him the antique broach and the hair clip. Question 2 The legal issue for determination is what are the terms agreed in relation to the restringing of Sybil’s racquets, whether Jeffery restringing can rely on the exclusion clause in the contract and whether there was a warranty or a condition in the contract. A term of a contract sets out the duties of each party under the agreement. In the case of Bannerman v White12 that if a statement is so important that a party would not have entered into the contract, then the statement made is a term of the contract. In law if one of the parties to the contract makes a statement with special knowledge and expertise on matters, the court deems the statement as forming part of the contract as opposed to when it is made by a person with no expertise as held in the case of Bentley Productions Ltd v Harold Smith (Motors) Ltd13. In contract law, a serious breach of the conditions of terms of the contract entitles the innocent party to repudiate the contract and sue for damages14. An exclusion clause or exemption/limitation clause in law is effective to limit the liability of the party that seeks to rely on it if it forms part of the contract and that it covers the breach15. In the case of Oceanic Sun Line Special Shipping Co v Fay16 where a brochure stated that an exclusion clause would be invalid if there are vitiating factors such as fraud, misrepresentation or undue influence, the exemption clause will not be relied upon17. It is important that an exclusion clause forms part of the contract and in the case of Toll (FGCT) Pty Ltd v Alphaharm Pty Ltd18 . In law, an exclusion clause contained in an unsigned document such as a notice then the notice must be brought to the other party’s attention before or at the time the contract is made as held in Olley v Marlbrough Court19. However the courts refuse to acknowledge the exemption clause where there is a total failure of one of the parties to perform their obligations under the contract. In the case of Metrotex Pty Ltd v Freight Investments Pty Ltd20 a contract to carry parcels to Melbourne from Sydney had an exclusion clause saying “the carriage accepts no responsibilities”, the High Court held that the carrier could not rely on the exemption clause since there was failure to perform. The court will also refuse to exclude liability where the defendants engage in a misleading and deceptive conduct21 and where there is fundamental breach that is the performance of the contract does not conform to the terms of the contract as held in Suisse Atlantique Societe d’Armement Maritime S.A v N.V. Rotterdamsche Kolen Centrale22 In this case Sybil relied on the statements made on the internet advertisement that “Jeffery’s Restringing was the best in New South Wales and no one can re-string racquets like them”. The inclusion of the statement in the advertisement informed the decision of Sybil to take her racquets for stringing at Jeffrey’s hence formed part of the contract as the case was in Bentley Productions Ltd v Harlod Smith (Motors) Ltd23 . An exclusion clause will not limit liability for defective goods in cases where there is negligence and poor workmanship contradicting the terms and implied skills of the party. Further Jeffery Restringing failed to inform Sybil about the exclusion clause when she brought the racquets. Jeffrey Restringing exclusion clause will not apply since there is a material breach of the contract terms and the exclusion clause were not displayed in a way in which Sybil could easily read it. Jeffrey Restringing also failed to perform the terms of the contract and liability will not be limited since it failed to perform the contract by the terms and the advertisement was misleading. Part B Where one is faced with conflicting decision of a single Supreme Court of New South Wales and a unanimous Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Victoria then one needs to base their decision on the case of Farah Constructions24 . In the strictest sense, a court can only be bound by a decision of another court in the same hierarchy sitting on appeal directly or through intervention of the intermediate appellate court from the first instance decision maker25. A judge is required to make his own decision based on the merits of the case and the interpretation of the law, and a precedent serves as persuasive authority and can bind the court depending on hierarchy. The court held that an intermediate appellate courts and trial judges should not depart from decision in intermediate appellate courts in another jurisdiction on the interpretation of Commonwealth legislation or uniform national legislation unless the interpretation is plainly wrong26. Every court case presented in a court of law is different with its own characteristics, and judicial decisions that a similar or identical in other jurisdiction are guides to but cannot control the meaning of legislation in the court’s jurisdiction. As was held in the case of Marshall v Director-General, Department of Transport27 that judicial decisions do not serve as substitute for the text in a legislation but by reason of precedent and hierarchical nature of the courts systems some courts may be bound to apply decisions of a particular court in the meaning of legislation. However if the judicial power of the Commonwealth was applied in the decision of the tow courts, then the court will be bound by that decision since the dispute was derived from Chapter III of the Constitution. Yes, I would follow a strong decision of the Supreme Court of Singapore on the point of law, but it will be limited to the persuasive nature of the decision. It is already and accepted principle as set out in the case of Cook v Cook28 that the precedents from other legal systems other than Australia are not binding, but are “useful only to the degree of persuasiveness of their reasoning”29. Bibliography Gibson, A. and Fraser, D. Business Law. 7th ed. Sydney: Pearson Education Australia, 2013. Sweeney, B. and O’Reilly, J. Law in Commerce, Sydney: LexisNexis Butterworths, 2004. Trietel G H, Treitel onthe Law of Contract. 9th edn. London: Sweet & Maxwell, 1995. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Agreement between Orlando and Helen Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words, n.d.)
Agreement between Orlando and Helen Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words. https://studentshare.org/law/2082198-business-law-assignment
(Agreement Between Orlando and Helen Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words)
Agreement Between Orlando and Helen Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words. https://studentshare.org/law/2082198-business-law-assignment.
“Agreement Between Orlando and Helen Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words”. https://studentshare.org/law/2082198-business-law-assignment.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Agreement between Orlando and Helen

Education

High stakes testing is one of the most prevalent trends in education since the inception of the No Child Left Behind legislation in 2001.... The author Fullerton presents findings on how this trend has affected social studies instruction in the classroom.... .... ... ... The research reveals that social studies are losing class time in elementary school due to the NCLB mandate for proficiency in Math and Reading only....
10 Pages (2500 words) Annotated Bibliography

Orlando's madness in Orlando Furioso

After losing his wit, orlando, who was the greatest knight of Charlemagne was punished.... John, who had confided in Astolfo narrated the reason of orlando's punishment saying that he had compromised upon what was right in order to pursue his evil dreams.... Instead of supporting his Emperor in his fight against the infidel, orlando had chased the graceful pagan princess.... John's deep desire to have Astolfo learn that, “Your orlando has misappropriated the standard committed to him, and God is punishing him---for He is harshest against those He most loves, when they offend Him” (Canto 34, 62)....
1 Pages (250 words) Research Paper

Events Project Management

The author describes different categories of the events; they can be leisure-based, personal, cultural or organizational.... Leisure events are sports in nature; personal events cover birthdays and weddings; cultural events are art and culture whereas commercial events come under organizational events....
9 Pages (2250 words) Term Paper

Finance Industry: The Nature of Debt Factoring and Debt Subordination

The author states that the factor and the investor cannot be too choosy and meticulous while doing adequate research on the prevalent elements of the investment being considered.... The factor should endeavor to get as many guarantees for the debts he is purchasing as can be secured.... .... ... ...
10 Pages (2500 words) Term Paper

An Analysis of Orlando A Biography

orlando: A Biography written by Virginia Woolf, which was probably not her most famous work, was however a thorough study of the characteristics and commonalities of gender during the long four hundred years that the novel traces through.... Interestingly orlando, the leading figure of he novel, by choosing not to grow old during the three centuries time span of the storyline and most importantly changing gender from male to female, is depicted in such a manner as to provoke the reader's thought by sincerely analyzing all aspects of the two sexes' behavioral attributes....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

The Theory and Practice of the Person Centred Approach

Attempts are made to facilitate related changes and seek to promote in clients the following: the closer agreement between the client's idealized and actual selves; better self-understanding; lower levels of defensiveness, guilt, and insecurity; more positive and comfortable relationships with others; and an increased capacity to experience and express feelings at the moment they occur (Rogers, 1980).... The study of the single individual studied quantitatively using the technique, is in one way person-centered, but is not normally so according to the definition given above (since the focus is usually then on relationships between variables within the individual)....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Orlando by Virginia Woolf

As the paper states, orlando by Virginia Woolf begins with the protagonist as a young boy, pretentiously slicing off the head of Moors just as his father and grandfather did.... The numerous heads hanging from their attic rafter spurs a motivation within orlando which inspires him to go to expeditions with his family.... 'So too would orlando, he vowed,' writes Wolf, but since he is too young, orlando cannot be taken along in the journey (40)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Book Report/Review

Sally Potters Film Orlando

In Orlando, for illustration, the clash of gender and historical situations such as the passing of Queen Elizabeth I displays the comfort in leadership that inspired Lady orlando and her husband before his gender... In the movie orlando, for example, confusions and changing.... Contrastingly, as this paper will explain, cultural structures that include patriarchy, mixed identity, language, and lived experience forms a critical framework of It also explores the complex nature of cultural interpretations that emerge when roles change with emphasis on orlando's sudden transformation in the movie....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us