StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Ramayana and Shakuntala: A Comparison - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Both Ramayana and Shakuntala are great works of artistic and philosophical merit. Originally written in Sanskrit close to two millennia ago, their authorship and date of origin are both speculative and mythologized…
Download free paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.6% of users find it useful
Ramayana and Shakuntala: A Comparison
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Ramayana and Shakuntala: A Comparison"

Ramayana and Shakuntala: A Comparison Both Ramayana and Shakuntala are great works of artistic and philosophical merit. Originally written in Sanskrit close to two millennia ago, their authorship and date of origin are both speculative and mythologized. Yet, these ambiguities do not detract from their unique contributions to Eastern philosophy and literature. Both are great dramatic narratives and are integral to Indian folklore and tradition. The two works offer a glimpse into the social, political and philosophical currents affecting India two millennia ago.

In this sense, they can be treated as fictionalized yet historically informative documents. Though, both Ramayana and Shakuntala are different in scope and historical setting, they share a common focus on philosophical questions pertaining to morality, choice (freewill) and chance (opportunity). This essay will argue that, though the two works are narrative stories set in ancient India, their scales, characters, themes and tones are dissimilar. The rest of this essay will flesh out this position.

In Shakuntala, a salient philosophical debate is whether the titular character is a victim of misfortune (as in encountering an ill-tempered Sage Durvasa) or had let herself down (by living in her fantasies when Sage Durvasa visits her hermitage). Author Kalidasa doesn’t concern himself with answering this question, making it less philosophically investigative than the Ramayana. In other words, a concrete answer to the causes of Shakuntala’s misfortune is less important than its recognition as a real and plausible fact of life.

What led to Durvasa’s cursing of Shakuntala is a moot question, than acknowledgment of such occurrences as painful yet common part of human lives. In this sense, this great play offers a cathartic experience of the highest order to the audience. In contrast, in the Ramayana, the central and most dramatic moment in the narrative is when Ram and his faithful brothers are mandated to spend 14 years in the wilderness. The hardships and challenges they face during this period as well as the valuable friends they acquire on course showcase morals, values and virtues that are integral to Hindu Dharma.

In this sense, this great Indian epic serves as a theatrical illustration of ideal Hindu life, with a comprehensive list of moral codes to abide by. In the Ramayana, a recurrent theme is one of maintenance of honor and virtue. This is amply evident through the lives of Ram, Lakshman, Sita, Hanuman, etc. All these characters go to great lengths in keeping their promises and upholding their loyalties. Ram, for example, stands firm in his commitment to Sita, even when he is tempted by attractive women like Surpanak after Sita’s abduction by Ravan.

Sita, likewise is a model of restraint and fidelity, as she spurns Ravana’s repeated attempts to seduce her. Hanuman’s whole life is devoted to the service of his master and lord Ram. His loyalty exceeds even that of Ram’s younger brothers. Hence, the various characters in this great epic show how they overcome challenges in maintaining their honor and loyalty. In Shakuntala, in contrast, this showcase of virtue is not so pronounced, except tenuously. For example, one could see parallels between Shakuntala’s years of lament and longing for Dushyanta as similar to that experienced by Sita.

But Shakuntala’s virtue and fidelity were not as severely tested as that confronted by Sita. After Ram defeats Ravan and Sita rejoins with her beloved, as a proof of her chastity, she even steps into fire as part of a symbolic cleansing ritual. In terms of their scale and grandeur too there are differences between the two works. Shakuntala is a shorter narrative when compared to the lengthier and broad-scoped epic that is the Ramayana. The latter, believed to be written by Sage Valmiki, is a genuine epic, comparable to the Odyssey, Iliad or Beowulf of the Western literary canon.

Moreover, Ramayana is a more complete story compared to Shakuntala. Indeed, every common human crisis can be found at some stage in its narrative. The thoughts, actions and decisions of characters at various such moments of crisis serve as guidance and moral lesson to the reader of the text. In this way, the Ramayana is comparable to sacred texts of other major religions, in terms of the breadth of its scope and the profundity of wisdom contained within. In this regard the Shakuntala is quite limited.

Written in the form of a play, its primary purpose is entertainment, although it contains some elements of didacticism (related to Hindu Dharma). Hence, in conclusion, though he Ramayana and the Shakuntala are two narrative stories set in ancient India, their scales, characters, themes and tones are largely dissimilar. Reference: Fred Stielow (Editor), Judith M Novak (Editor), Linda Silva(Preface), World Literature Anthology Through the Renaissance: Volumes 1, 2 & 3, Published by American Public University in 2011, ISBN-10: 1937381005

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Ramayana and Shakuntala: A Comparison Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/literature/1465628-ramayana-and-shakuntala-a-comparison
(Ramayana and Shakuntala: A Comparison Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/literature/1465628-ramayana-and-shakuntala-a-comparison.
“Ramayana and Shakuntala: A Comparison Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/literature/1465628-ramayana-and-shakuntala-a-comparison.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Ramayana and Shakuntala: A Comparison

Shakuntala

Having to leave after some time due to unrest in the capital city, Dushyanta gave shakuntala a royal ring as a sign of their love, promising her that he would return for her.... Time passed, and shakuntala, wondering why Dushyanta did not return for her, finally set out for the capital city with her father and some of her companions.... The play describes the quest for harmony between the court and the forest through the different scenes which portray Dushyanta's world of dharma, or duty, and shakuntala's realm of nature and spontaneous action....
2 Pages (500 words) Book Report/Review

The Ramayana Book Report/Review

In the original version of ramayana written by Valmiki, Rama has been shown as a mortal.... (Rao). The ramayana opines that Valmiki co-existed with Rama, and the complete saga of the ramayana unfolded before his eyes.... hellip; However, another school of thought believes that ramayana was existent even before this time.... Rajagopalachari observed that "The traditional orthodox view is that Valmiki wrote the ramayana during the life-time of Ramachandra....
4 Pages (1000 words) Book Report/Review

The Ramayana

the ramayana is an episodic epic story reflecting religious, political, and social beliefs and moral doctrines.... Primarily of Hindu origin, the ramayana also exists in other versions within some Buddhist and other Asian religious traditions.... hellip; There are texts of ramayana in several regional languages, including Sanskrit, Chinese, Thai, Telugu, Bengali, Kashmiri, and Tamil.... The ramayana story recounts the life of Rama-the seventh incarnation of the Hindu god Vishnu, his brother Lakshmana-his wife Sita, his opponent Ravana, a host of demons, and an army of monkeys loyal to Rama led by Hanuman....
7 Pages (1750 words) Book Report/Review

How are women represented in the Ramayana story

ramayana is one of the two great epics of the Hindu mythology, and dates back to as early as 1500… It is believed that ramayana was first composed by the great saint Valmiki in classic Indian language Sanskrit.... ramayana is basically the story of Lord Rama and Goddess Sita.... ramayana has been translated, rewritten and reinterpreted by many scholars in various Indian languages.... , in his narration of The ramayana (p....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Comparing themes in Gilgamesh and Ramayana

Love motivates them into a life of interdependence as Enkidu ensures checks and balance on the restless and powerful energies of The theme of love in Gilgamesh and ramayana The theme of love in Gilgamesh appear to be both in the form of erotic and platonic which serves as a major agent of change in the story.... n the other hand, in the epic of ramayana, affectionate love is made evident in the epic of Ramayan by how Sita who is the wife of Rama begs to accompany him to the forest upon being banished....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Comparing themes in gilgamesh and ramayana

However, he emphasizes Comparing Themes in Gilgamesh and ramayana The Epic of Ramayan, as well as that of Gilgamesh, expounds on many diverse themes in the society.... Just like in the ramayana's epic, the epic of Gilgamesh expounds on how love united Enkidu with Gilgamesh.... In tandem with this assertion, it is evident that Gilgamesh's epic differs slightly from ramayana's epic....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Comparing Sakuntala and the Ring of Recollection and Ramayana

"Comparing Sakuntala and the Ring of Recollection and ramayana" paper compares the immortal epic, ramayana by Valmiki, and the renowned Sanskrit drama Sakuntala and the Ring of Recollection by Kalidasa which are great examples of poetic craftsmanship in the context of the world of literature.... The ramayana narrates the tale of Prince Rama, his divine power, truthfulness and valor, his marriage with Sita, their fourteen years of banishment, the war between Rama and evil king Ravana, generated from Sita's kidnapping by the evil king, destruction of Ravana and his kingdom, Sita's ordeal to prove her chastity, her banishment and finally the reunion of Rama and Sita....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Differences between Both Sakuntalas

This essay investigates differences between both Sakuntala's.... One of them is a socio-spiritual drama by the Kalidasa, famous scholar of Sanskrit, that propounds the doctrine of Karma.... He states that each action has a reaction, and its intensity is proportional to the intensity of the action....
11 Pages (2750 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us