StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Compare and Contrast the Emergent and Intended Approach to Strategic - Literature review Example

Cite this document
Summary
Strategies in organization is conceived in terms of what the management of an organization plan to do then and in future while strategy formation is treated as an analytical process for instituting long range goals and action plans for organization…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.8% of users find it useful
Compare and Contrast the Emergent and Intended Approach to Strategic
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Compare and Contrast the Emergent and Intended Approach to Strategic"

?Mintzberg, H., and Waters, J. A., (1985) Of Strategies Deliberate and Emergent, Strategic Management Journal, Vol. 6, PP 257-272 The main purpose ofthe authors work is to find how strategies form in organization. Strategies in organization is conceived in terms of what the management of an organization plan to do then and in future while strategy formation is treated as an analytical process for instituting long range goals and action plans for organization. The authors have been carrying out research for over ten years on the topic and the intended audiences are the entrepreneurs and organization leadership. The topic has meet my expectations because it compares and contrast the intended strategy together with realized strategy in a diagram form, hence distinguishing deliberate strategies realized as intended from emergent strategies patterns realized in spite of intentions. The special features of the work that were helpful was the identification of different types of strategies and everyone embodying different degrees of what is called deliberateness. The authors are of high integrity; Henry Mintzber is heading the faculty of management at McGill University while James Waters is a lecture at York University in the faculty of administration studies. The authors concluded that strategies are tending towards being more deliberate in tightly coupled, centrally controlled institutions and more emergent in decentralized loosely coupled ones. According to my conclusion, strategy formation walks in two forms, deliberate and emergent. Mintzberg, H., (1990). The design school: reconsidering the basic premises of strategic Management, Strategic Management Journal, Vol. 11, PP.171-195 This paper focuses on one school of thought on strategic management called design school. The design put forward a simple model that views the process as a design to obtain an essential fit between external threat and opportunity and internal distinctive competence. The first article tries to distinguish between deliberate strategies from intended strategies while this article explains a design school. The intended audiences by the author are students who want to learn the model and chief executives who are planning to control it. The information meet my expectations since it contain the information on the school design context and contribution, four strategic management conditions that encourage an institution to move towards design school are explained. The helpful work was in the explanation of premises underlying the school of design since each premise explains the process of strategy formation. Mintzber who is the author is a man of high integrity and he is heading the faculty of management at McGill University. The authors concluded that the school has provided significant information on the discussion of grand strategy and it has given the notion that underlies all prescription in the field of management. I concluded that there is concurrence between external opportunity and internal capability in the field of strategic management. Ansoff, H., (1991). Critique of Henry Mintzberg's 'the design school: reconsidering the basic Premises of strategic management,' Strategic Management Journal, Vol.12 (6), PP.449-461 The main focus of this article is to critique the work done by Mintzberg's (1990) on design school of emerging strategic management. The design is evaluated using two criteria’s, methodological soundness and factual veracity, after the evaluation, it was found that the critique has deficiency by both methods. The problem of Mintzberg's work is associated with lack of logics in his presentation, his definition on strategy differs from the current practice in management and he failed to differentiate prescriptive and descriptive statement. In this critique, the author emphasis on methodological deficiencies and factual contradictions between Mintzberg's and real world of strategic management. Full description of Mintzberg's model was presented by the author and he found some valid contexts in Mintzberg's work. These include for an organization to succeed, it should use emergent strategy trial and experience process of strategy formation. The intended audiences are organization chief executive officers since they are the ones implementing the organization strategies. The works by ansoff are important to my research since it reconsider the basic premises of strategic management which was put forward by Mintzberg's and it is discussed in the first article. Igor Ansoff who is the author of this article is a respected lecturer at United States International University, California. The author concludes that the trust on Mintzberg's proofs and concepts resulted from weak methodology and contradiction in factual evidence. According to my conclusion, Mintzberg's model is a good prescription for institutions that are moving towards optimizing their performance in the filed where strategic changes are increasing and the rate of change is slower than the organization respond. Kipping, M., and Cailluet, L., (2010) Mintzberg's Emergent and Deliberate Strategies: Tracking Alcan's Activities in Europe 1928-2007, Business History Review, Vol. 84 (1), PP.99-104 The purpose of this work is to explain how Mintzberg theories of strategic management were applied in Aluminum Company of Canada (Alcan); the strategies ranges from those coming as a result of deliberate internal decisions and those emerging largely as a response to outside forces. The analysis on the development of Alcan since its independence in 1928 has shown three things. This work is important to my research because the company strategies have evolved along the deliberate emergent range put forward by Mintzberg, this company has moved from emergent toward deliberate strategies mainly in response to external challenges and partly in response to the change in company leadership. Alcan slowly adopted more of deliberate strategies, imposed strategies was also present throughout. A special feature that was useful to my research is in the comparison between strategy and organization structure. The authors’ conclusion is that mergers and acquisition are part of an emergent strategy that developed in response to external problems that brought down investment. My observation in this article is that the role of highly emergent imposed strategies seems to play a significant role every time in business. Pretorius, M., and Maritz, R., (2011) Strategy making: the approach matters, Journal of Business Strategy, Vol.32 (4), PP.25-31 The purpose of this work is to explain how strategy should reflect the demand of the company environment and the way it should be shaped by business realities. The organization management in the current fast changing and challenging environment should move towards making their business dynamic and should not look like academic theories that are statically. This work is relevant to my research since it explains that emergent strategies are not necessarily deliberately planned but come into existence somewhere on the way. The deliberate and emergent view is viewed as a range with several elements. The Special features that are helpful are in the explanation that deliberate end refers to an additional rational and comprehensive approach whereas the emergent view refers to a more incremental type of approach. In contrast, the intended strategies are planned but not essentially realized while in emergent strategies, the pattern that was apprehended was not expressly intended. The authors are credible people; Marius Pretorius is an Associate Professor while Rachel Maritz is a Senior Lecturer at the University of Pretoria, Pretoria. The research targets the managers. The authors concluded that emergent approach towards strategy was pursued at the point where emergencies of strategies are encouraged. According to my conclusion, reflection on one aspect only when conducting strategy research deform the truth and reality of strategy making and cripples the use of strategy generally. References Ansoff, H., (1991). Critique of Henry Mintzberg's 'the design school: reconsidering the basic Premises of strategic management,' Strategic Management Journal, Vol.12 (6), PP.449-461 Kipping, M., and Cailluet, L., (2010) Mintzberg's Emergent and Deliberate Strategies: Tracking Alcan's Activities in Europe 1928-2007, Business History Review, Vol. 84 (1), PP.99-104 Mintzberg, H., and Waters, J. A., (1985) Of Strategies Deliberate and Emergent, Strategic Management Journal, Vol. 6, PP 257-272 Mintzberg, H., (1990). The design school: reconsidering the basic premises of strategic Management, Strategic Management Journal, Vol. 11, PP.171-195 Pretorius, M., and Maritz, R., (2011) Strategy making: the approach matters, Journal of Business Strategy, Vol.32 (4), PP.25-31 Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Compare and Contrast the Emergent and Intended Approach to Strategic Literature review”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/management/1464422-annotated-bibliography-based-on-five-articles-on
(Compare and Contrast the Emergent and Intended Approach to Strategic Literature Review)
https://studentshare.org/management/1464422-annotated-bibliography-based-on-five-articles-on.
“Compare and Contrast the Emergent and Intended Approach to Strategic Literature Review”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/management/1464422-annotated-bibliography-based-on-five-articles-on.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Compare and Contrast the Emergent and Intended Approach to Strategic

Debate on Deliberate and Emergent Strategy

Taking up the challenge was Ansoff, one of the 'fathers' of strategic planning (1965), who felt alluded to.... To better understand why, it would be necessary to develop a clear understanding (Johnson, Scholes, and Whittington, 2005) of strategy, strategy formulation, and strategic management and implementation (or execution).... strategic planning involves knowing what to do in the future and is also called "long-range planning", but before an organization can decide “where it wants to go”, it has to know where it currently “is” and whether its future plans are realistic given its capabilities....
10 Pages (2500 words) Case Study

William Connor Case Study for Cruise Industry

In the similar background, Marlo (2000) indicate a intended approach encompass of a announcement of detailed and spoken meaning, holders with official gearshift (Boisot, M.... In vision of the onward looking natural earth of a intended approach, Mazzolini (1988) experiential that goals or purpose fulfillments are the dangerous ending of the approach.... strategic organization has usually been portrayed as rotating approximately the separate stages of formulation, accomplishment, and manages, approved out in approximately cascade ladder for ships....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Emergent Strategy

This case study explains the emergent strategy making example of Robin Hood's history.... obin Hood's group had advanced from the emergent strategy and in the second year, his band grew.... It discusses the influence of individual and collective experience on strategic thinking and choices.... strategic drift started occurring because Robin's lieutenant's resisted the idea of a transit tax on the travelers.... Here the individual and collective experiences are central and culture and history strongly influence strategic thinking and choices....
1 Pages (250 words) Case Study

Annotated Bibliography Strategic Management

This paper "Annotated Bibliography – strategic Management" focuses on the main objective of the study which was to help in discovering the ways to follow in order to come up with a sustainable business.... The purpose of the analysis carried out by the author was to show the importance of strategic management in commercial form, author-defined strategy as fundamentally the choice for businesses focus.... Mintzberg own proposal for the basic values of strategic management is criticized by using the identical criterion....
4 Pages (1000 words) Literature review

The Intended and Emergent Approach to Strategic Management

The article is important in relation to strategic management, as it depicts the controversial theories associated with strategic management.... It also gives the different approaches to strategic management.... The approach to strategy making, can normally take a deliberate end, which tends to be more rational.... The article uses an example to illustrate how a company moved from the emergent to a more deliberate strategy, despite the external forces that tend to influence its decisions....
3 Pages (750 words) Coursework

The Emergent and Intended Approach to Strategic Management

In doing so, it question the beliefs in the strategic management.... The critique is not intended to dismiss the design school model; lather, it opposes the assumption of its universality.... It follows the… Through out all this period the company moves from emergent to more strategies that are deliberate (Bryson & Famum, 2004).... After the analysis, the author arrived at the following conclusion, the company strategy evolved along deliberate emergent continuum as proposed by Mintzberg....
4 Pages (1000 words) Coursework

Prescriptive & Emergent Strategies

This has become a key determinant in regard to strategic planning of most organizations and companies.... All forms of organizations require strategic plan to ensure that they achieve the set objectives whether they are small or large.... strategic management is a core aspect of an organization and comprises of various approaches adopted in various companies.... Therefore to evaluate a strategic plan of a given company, it is important to acknowledge and explore other available alternatives....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Approaches and Schools of Business Strategies

The writer will specifically assess the prescriptive and an emergent approach to forming the strategy along with an evaluation of Classical and Processual schools of strategy.... In following prescriptive approach to strategy in an organization, an organizational analysis is essential along with the environmental analysis.... When the environment is fast paced with lots of competition, a systematic approach to the strategic formulation is needed....
14 Pages (3500 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us