StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Drug testing for public assistance - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Drug testing for public assistance is one of the social issues being debated recently by the public due to the differences in opinion regarding the said action. There are two sides to the issue. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.9% of users find it useful
Drug testing for public assistance
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Drug testing for public assistance"

Drug Testing for Public Assistance Introduction Drug testing for public assistance is one of the social issues being debated recently by the public due to the differences in opinion regarding the said action. There are two sides to the issue. The aim of the paper is to present a personal view regarding the matter and the reasons for having the said opinion. On one side, people who advocate the notion argue that it is just fair and rational since people asking for assistance are also citizen of the nation, thus, they must have duties toward the taxpayer. If the people who hold jobs are undertaking random drug tests then they should not be any different (Sachteleben 1). On the other hand, the people who oppose the said notion are addressing the fact that the random drug testing is ‘scientifically and medically’ illogical. Aside from the fact that it was expressed to be ‘fiscally irresponsible’ (American Civil Liberties Union 1). Opinions on the Opposing Sides of the Issue On a personal note, both side present reasonable conjecture regarding the issue although as a citizen, I am in favor of the implementation of drug testing. There are different points that can be presented regarding the said point of view. Thus, the discussion is aimed to present the reasons for agreeing with the advocates of the issue and the reasons for disagreeing with the critics. One point is related to the fact that every citizen of the nation has his or her own responsibilities toward the community. Due to that fact that these people are in need of public assistance, on the basis of different reasons such as the lack of income sources, following the rules set up by the authorities can be considered as their duty. This view is even strengthened by the fact that the funds for public assistance are coming from the taxes of the citizen with stable source of income (Sachteleben 1). Another point that can be presented in favor of the drug testing is the fact that even the employees and workers who are screened for their jobs are being required to have drug test. This means that the said procedure is not meant to separate the group of people who needs public assistance from other groups in the community. For that matter, critics of the notion cannot use the reason that there is maltreatment or unjust regard towards the said group (Sachteleben 1). One of the most important reasons behind the proposition is the fact that drug addiction requires treatment. In a society wherein one of the most influential causes of disintegration is drug addition, the said action is ultimately aimed to lessen its effect in the community. Targeting the sector that needs public assistance in the community is important since they are the ones who lack the resources for even the most basic needs in life such as food, shelter and clothing. Upon presentation of the main reasons for advocating the drug testing for public assistance, it is important to also consider the reasons why critics are against the notion. This is to be able to explain a personal point of view each reasons. Based on the discussion of ACLU, who is one of the most substantial critics of the implantation of drug testing for public assistance, there are different reasons for their view. One of the said reasons is that, both in the scientific and medical points of view, the implementation of the action is illogical. One reason is that being a welfare recipient does not increase the possibility of using drugs (American Civil Liberties Union 1). On a personal note, this is where the reasoning that it every citizen of the nation should be treated fairly, thus, when workers and employees are being tested for drug use, then it is also just to have the welfare recipients to have the tests. Another reason given is that the stigma of the imposed drug testing would affect the welfare recipient far greater than the benefits it can bring about (American Civil Liberties Union 1). This point of view can be opposed by the fact that the main objective of drug testing is to help the people overcome addition and that again every citizen are needed to be treated fairly, regardless of the kind of life they are having. Other reasons presented by the critics are related to the price of the drug testing and the effects on children (American Civil Liberties Union 1). The price of drug testing can be expensive and considered futile in the fight for drug abuse in the society. This is true but the problem cannot be limited to the members of the society who requires public support and assistance. With regards to the effect on the children, on a personal note, can be one of the reasons that can sway the opinion of the advocates. This can be attributed to the fact that even innocent children can be caught in cases wherein their parents can be found out to be using drugs. This is due to the fact that they are apprehended and also the children are denied of health care. In this case, this aspect of the issue is needed to be given attention to prevent adverse effects in the life of the children. Conclusion Based on the study undertaken regarding the issue, it is on a personal note that drug testing for public assistance is generally favorable on the basis of positive points. Attention is needed to be given though to prevent negative effects to the children that can be affected in the issue. Works Cited: American Civil Liberties Union. “Drug Testing of Public Assistance Recipients as a Condition of Eligibility.” Sachteleben, Marilisa Kinney. “Random Mandatory Drug Testing for Welfare and Public Assistance Recipients.” Associated Content Website. 4 February 2010. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Drug testing for public assistance Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Drug testing for public assistance Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1562673-drug-testing-for-public-assistance
(Drug Testing for Public Assistance Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
Drug Testing for Public Assistance Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1562673-drug-testing-for-public-assistance.
“Drug Testing for Public Assistance Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1562673-drug-testing-for-public-assistance.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Drug testing for public assistance

Drug Testing for Welfare Recipients is Illegal and Unnecessary

Instructor name Date drug testing for Welfare Recipients is Illegal and Unnecessary Random drug testing of employees and job applicants began during the “just say no” era of the 1980's when the Reagan administration amped up the failed “war on drugs” that began in the early 1970's by the President Nixon.... A more egregious example of an overzealous drug policy is the recent growing trend to require welfare recipients, residents of public housing and other forms of public assistance to be tested for drugs prior to receiving assistance....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Welfare recipients and drug testing

Almost two dozen states are considering enacting bills that require individuals applying for or receiving public benefits to undergo drug testing.... The author further argues that this has made the issue of substance abuse a periodic policy and a programmatic concern Welfare recipients and drug testing Luigi Chiappini COMM 200 Michelle Holling October 23, Welfare recipients and drug testing Almost two dozenstates are considering enacting bills that require individuals applying for or receiving public benefits to undergo drug testing....
2 Pages (500 words) Research Paper

Why people on goverment assistance should be drug tested to recieve assistance

Additionally, legislators in Michigan are hoping that the act of drug testing for benefits is best and will be beneficial since it has been done in 29 other states.... drug testing Welfare benefits to families have so far increased in number in the United States with poor families in different states receiving varying amounts of benefits.... … drug testing Welfare benefits to families have so far increased in number in the United States with poor families in different states receiving varying amounts of benefits....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Mandatory Drug Testing for People on Welfare

Mandatory drug testing for People on WelfareI.... “drug testing for Welfare Recipients?... “Drug Testing of public assistance Recipients as a Condition of Eligibility”, American Civil Liberties Union.... … The debate has been raised as to whether or not mandatory drug testing is appropriate before supplying taxpayer-furnished welfare benefits to ensure the money is being well-spent and will not be exhausted on drug purchases....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Random drug testing at school

Random drug testing at schools is being implemented in many cities and states of the United States.... Researchers for the American Journal of Public Health Christ Ringwalt and colleagues reported in 2008 that suspicionless or random drug testing is being allowed by… Nonetheless, the testing is being criticized by several individuals and groups with regard to its desirability and legality.... Formally, drug testing is defined as “drug testing conducted 827)....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Should people who receive welfare be required to be drug tested

In Oklahoma, for example, the Republican Governor signed into law a legislation that requires drug testing for those applying to the Temporary Assistance for Needy Families program where by if they test positive of illegal drugs in their system or refuse to be tested, they will be denied aid.... Legislators Continue To Propose drug testing for Welfare Recipients, 2012.... Therefore,… people who receive welfare should undergo drug testing so that public funds do not go to the wrong hands and be misused to support the drug user's habits. Welfare programs provide support to disadvantaged individuals and families in society....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Mandatory drug testing for welfare recipients

This paper will examine the issue of mandatory drug testing for welfare recipients and further explain why the testing policy is not effective.... One of the debates that dominated the political scene is the connection between drug abuse and the recipients of public welfare As a result, several Acts to support mandatory drug testing were introduced in order to reduce drug abuse by social welfare recipients.... For instance, introduction of mandatory drug testing to the social welfare beneficiaries is good from a social perspective because it is aimed to better the social status of the recipients....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

Drug and Substance Abuse Testing

Moreover, drug testing by itself does nothing to promote employment, economic stability or responsible parenting ("drug testing for welfare recipients to be considered by state Senate" 6).... This paper tells that drug testing is a waste of tax-payers money.... million would be used in drug testing.... Similar research observed that drug testing welfare would be a costly blunder as evident from the thirty-year war on drugs.... nbsp;The adoption of state drug testing requirements are unconstitutional and a violation of privacy....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us