StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Nobody downloaded yet

Discuss how Joseph Schumpeter's view of capitalism differs from the views both of Marx and of economists who favor vigorous competition - Essay Example

Summary
Joseph Schumpeter argued that capitalism would succeed, and through its own success, undermine the institutions that created and supported its existence (61). Schumpeter claimed to be in line with ideas of Karl Marx on that issue, despite the fact that Schumpeter was an…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.8% of users find it useful
Discuss how Joseph Schumpeters view of capitalism differs from the views both of Marx and of economists who favor vigorous competition
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Discuss how Joseph Schumpeter's view of capitalism differs from the views both of Marx and of economists who favor vigorous competition"

Download file to see previous pages

In comparison to Schumpeter, Smith argued that only external factors such as corruption and idleness can destroy capitalism. Hayek added socialism to the list. In short, Schumpeter advocated the middle road between the two extremes. For Marx, capitalism is based on accumulation of money. A capitalist sees his purpose in never ending accumulation of capital, which is surplus value acquired from sale of commodities, industrial goods or interest on a loan (Marx 9 - 11). Due to the accumulated money, the capitalist is able to hire labor (Marx 18).

However, capitalism creates classes, antagonistic to each other. Until capitalism was created through accumulation of wealth and a necessary mode of production that enabled large scale production, labor could not be hired in exchange for money (Marx 18). As a result, capitalism is a product of historical developments and changes in production techniques (Marx 19). However, capitalism creates tensions. Labor is paid only the subsistence wage so that it can keep on producing, while providing the capitalist with maximum profits (Marx 19).

The total money earned to the capitalist is much higher than the salary obtained (Marx 41). As long as this inequality exists, capitalist will be able to perpetuate the capitalist mode of production. However, class struggle arises, as the workers are overworked (Marx 47). Marx called this “antagonism of capitalist production” (75). Thus, though in this system money is used more efficiently, there are still only two classes, just as in feudalism. Capitalism evolves at the expense of labor, and progress of technology (Marx 68).

As capitalists grow and overtake each other, they decrease in numbers, until means of production are centralized, and labor organizes and annihilates capitalism (Marx 80). Capitalism for Schumpeter was significantly different from feudalism. Schumpeter argued that business success, instead

...Download file to see next pages Read More

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Discuss how Joseph Schumpeter's view of capitalism differs from the views both of Marx and of economists who favor vigorous competition

Economics of Modern Capitalism

Despite being put under criticism by most economists who were pro-capitalism, to the employed people it was popular especially during the 1930's depression.... marx and Malthus's arguments of the population differ.... marx and Malthus arguments of population differ.... marx and Keynes on Unemployment.... the views by Keynes were two-fold.... As per his argument the reserve army constitutes groups of workers who relate differently to the economy of capitalism....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Malthus vs Marxs Views on Capitalism

The Value of marx: Political Economy for Contemporary Capitalism.... Elements of capitalism include production of goods or services for profit, means of production is owned privately, wage labor, and competitive markets.... The main forms of capitalism include state capitalism, free- market capitalism, mercantilism, corporate capitalism, and social market capitalism.... Of particular interest to this essay is the production aspect of capitalism, especially as it has been the focus of Malthus and Marx's arguments....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Analysis Karl Marx View of Capitalism

This paper seeks to analyze Karl Marx view of capitalism and the major criticism of the system by Karl Marx and other individuals.... Analysis Karl Marx view of capitalism ... This paper seeks to analyze Karl Marx view of capitalism and the major criticism of the system by Karl Marx and other individuals. ... Another vital criticism of the capitalism as depicted by marx and Engels is that its social and economic problems are caused by private ownership....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy by Schumpeter

he most interesting chapters of the first part are chapters 2 and 3 where the author explains sociological and economic views of marx.... Also Schumpeter discusses a number of other aspects of marx's theory and composes a list of advantages and disadvantages.... However, while he criticizes Marx's position that capitalism will eventually self-destroy, the reader may notice that his own views in this regard do not differ much from those of marx's: Schumpeter believes that capitalism bears the seed of its own destruction. ...
8 Pages (2000 words) Book Report/Review

What is an Entrepreneur

from the time when economists started to theorize on human actions, they have been looking for constancy in theory.... In the Mark I, Schumpeter stated that the innovation and technological change of a nation comes from the entrepreneurs, or wild spirits.... chumpeter's theory is that the victory of capitalism will direct to a shape of corporatism and a development of values aggressive to capitalism, mainly among intellectuals.... One of the enormous advantages of capitalism, he argues, is that as contrasted with pre-capitalist periods, when education was a freedom of the few, more and more people acquire education....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study

The Economic Theory of Joseph Schumpeter

Lastly, there are few economists today that can make a thorough analysis of economy and at the same time consider Most of all, Schumpeter encouraged innovation through is theory of ' Creative Destruction'.... Schumpeter Biography - (1883–1950), The Theory of Economic Development, Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy, Ten Great economists .... However, it is because of schumpeter's critical thinking that great minds such as Robert Solow ( a former student) has contributed....
4 Pages (1000 words) PowerPoint Presentation

Schumpeter''s Theory of Creative Destruction

Creative destruction is a phrase that originated from the Marxist economic theory and refers to the connected processes of accumulation and annihilation of wealth as far as capitalism in concerned (Reisman 58)1.... from the 1950s going forward, the phrase creative destruction has been more freely associated with Joseph Schumpeter who The phrase as used by Schumpeter has very little similarity with the one that was used by Marx.... ccording to the theory development by Schumpeter, creative destruction will result in consequent failure of capitalism as an economic system, but in the present business use, the phrase refers denotes unpleasant options that are perceived necessary for sustainability....
13 Pages (3250 words) Term Paper

Neoclassical View of Competition

As marx and a certain stream in the post-Marxian literature assume, regardless of concentrated and centralized capital, capitalism is regulated by the self-expansion and accumulation of independent units of capital.... Lately, Neoclassical economics have been subject to a variety of criticisms, especially from the schools of Keynesian economics and the Austrian school.... Lately, Neoclassical economics have been subject to a variety of criticisms, especially from the schools of Keynesian economics and the Austrian school....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us