StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Debates between Marxism and Capitalism - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The essay "Debates between Marxism and Capitalism" focuses on the critical analysis of how the question of Marxism and the answer to capitalism – and the results from the debate – have slowly transformed society up until this point, affecting and changing social class and consciousness…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.9% of users find it useful
Debates between Marxism and Capitalism
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Debates between Marxism and Capitalism"

The Modern Condition and the Artist's Response: Social and consciousness Introduction Many new technologies and ideas inspired the change thatoccurred in the second half of the 19th century. These ideas, which eventually developed into realities, allowed information to be available to the masses and for mysteries to be explored. The growing cities provided jobs and opportunities which the rural workers left their farms for. All of these changes and new information, although amazing, also brought alienation and anxiety. These reactions to the "conditions for modern art" were examined by the artists of the time and expressed in ways the world had never seen before and have provided a way for us to understand these reactions. In Modern Art 1851-1929 the author, Richard Brettell, says that an obvious but unmediated way that the artist represented the change of their time is by the subject of their work. By painting modern inventions, such as the Eiffel Tower or a lunch at a new cafe in downtown Paris, the artists was recording modernity. Because one abject can be represented in many ways it helps us analyze how the artists felt about the subject. For example, images of the "most important single achievements of the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries", or the modern city, were very popular subjects. For the purpose of this essay, we will look at how the question of Marxism and the answer of capitalism - and the results from the debate - have slowly transformed society up until this point, affecting and changing social class and consciousness over time and how these changes have been reflected in art forms. Marxism versus Capitalism Marxism as a whole spurred the onslaught of a different sociological vehicle for governing the masses, a vehicle which contradicted the arguably excessive range of capitalism and what it stood for. By definition then this conflict reflected in art and how the psyche of the collective human race responded to either one or the other. Blamires stated that Marxists saw the chief evil to be eradicated as being the oppression by the capitalists and their allies of the working class (Blamires, pp. 404). Marxism advocated the administration and equalizing of society - all are equal - but failed to take into account the general urge of individuality as experienced by every human being. Due to the competitive and adaptive nature of capitalism, with its emphasis on individuality and the rights of every human, Marxist philosophy and strictures were revealed to be too oppressive, in a grand gesture of irony; human beings desired freedom and unique expression, and a system that regulated and repressed anything that promoted defiance was seen as limiting and unnecessary. Expressing the notion of change, even gradual, was an easy task for the painters and artists of the transitional times between Marxism/communism and capitalism. Painting life and people in current situations was a means of expressing identification, for self and others. Examples of such works would include Manet's 'Un bar aux Folies-Bergre' (The Bar at the Folies-Bergre) or 'Masked Ball at the Opera'. These images depict a changing time and most notably, a gathering of people and a celebration of life in its individualized freedom. By definition then, these paintings can be seen as symbolic of free will and its execution, in rebellion against oppression and repression as defined by the anti-liberal motion of the Marxist embodiment of social norms. Capitalism in itself is not an absolute expression of individuality. There are still classes and regulatory boundaries, but these are more manageable. As Abrams stated, "the older usage of the term 'capitalism' no longer describes the system as it presently functions". This is implied in other forms of art, such as sculpture and architecture. Because of the individualist drive of competitiveness and self-expression as engendered by capitalism, inter-people conflicts based on viewpoints and opinion become a definite occurrence, and are expressed in art forms accordingly. Modernism and postmodernism As evinced by various distinctive views on postmodernism and modernism, art, architecture and literature play a large part in the vehicle of expression. It was generally held by Fredric Jameson that there are four distinct views (Homer, 102). For the purposes here, only two of these will be looked at: the anti-postmodern/pro-modernist and the pro-postmodernist/pro-modernist stances. These two views imply that there was no distinct break, sociologically, between the modernist art movements and the postmodernist ones, but rather a continuation, a flow from one into the other. People who held to these tenets included American critic Hilton Kramer and French philosopher and literary theorist Jean-Francois Lyotard. Jameson also said that each historical period of capitalist production produces its own distinct form of spatiality and each form of spatiality in turn engenders its own aesthetic or specific regime of representation (Homer, 140). We find evidence of this in the notion of art as commodity: Warhol's repetitions with 'Marilyn Monroe', Jeff Koons's forays into the Kitsch movement with sculptures like 'Rabbit', the Bauhaus advent of architecture and the input of artists like Le Corbusier, with regards to commodities like furniture and household items. Such commodities are a signal aspect of capitalism in that they have taken art - paintings, sculpture - a mode of expression heretofore seen as relatively aesthetic in function only, and made it into household items which practically anyone and everyone can afford to have. This kind of proliferation of creativity and ingenuity reflected not only from the artists' works as representational of capitalist association but also on the mindset that capitalism in itself provokes. With regards to architecture and its effects on the modern-day world, we see a clearer picture of the aggressive trend towards class segregation, even in capitalist society. Mike Davis stated that postmodern architecture is a brutal and coercive matter, a representation of the continuous class war/ambition; in effect a polarization into antagonistic spaces (Homer, 167). Within our cities, we find clearly delineated spaces where the architecture is reflective of the standard, class and income of various people. Poorer sections are defined by less attractive, run-down structures, whereas the more economically stable and even wealthy areas are populated by better-looking buildings, cleanliness and an overall suburban glamour that is missing from less affluent regions. In this we see the perpetuation of capitalism as a means of societal impetus, a drive to compete and excel that is demonstrated in the way that structures differ from each other in style and function. The diversity mirrors society and is therefore a mark of changing time, carried through by the constant redefinition of norms and movements, expressed in changing skylines, changing houses and even the construction techniques and pioneering methods which characterize the critically different forms of architecture. A constant level of change has been implemented, immortalizing modern art and all its forms as a face for society. Conclusion The ultimate rejection of ideologies such as Marxism led to the exponential rise of the modern-day cities, populated by people unrestricted by the administrative regulations that Marxism implied. Because of this rejection, art movements freely magnified the situation of the growing masses, expanding from philosophy and notion to practical outputs. This reflection of our societies came to the fore in how artists depicted the world around them, whether it was to paint a social gathering or a well-known place, or to make art into a commodity for the enjoyment of all. These reflections of the individual, seen as emblematic of consciousness, did not do much to erase the notion of alienation and class distinctiveness, but also did not suppress the idea that every single living being had a right to self-expression, and that said expression could be incorporated into the modern-day society that resulted from the transition between modernism and postmodernism. Works Cited 1. Abrams, C. The Language of Cities. New York: Avon Books, 1971. 2. Blamires, C.P., Jackson, P. (ed). World Fascism: A Historical Encyclopedia. Santa Barbara: ABC-CLIO Inc., 2006. 3. Jameson, F., Homer, S. (ed). Marxism, Hermeneutics, Postmodernism. Cambridge: Polity Press, 1998. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Modern Art Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words, n.d.)
Modern Art Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/performing-arts/1510367-the-modern-condition-and-the-artists-response
(Modern Art Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words)
Modern Art Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words. https://studentshare.org/performing-arts/1510367-the-modern-condition-and-the-artists-response.
“Modern Art Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/performing-arts/1510367-the-modern-condition-and-the-artists-response.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Debates between Marxism and Capitalism

A Critical Evaluation of the Feasibility of a Marxist Political System

A Brief Overview of marxism and a Marxist State Being commissioned by the Communist League, Karl Marx and Frederick Engels jointly wrote the book, 'The Communist Manifesto', in 1848, which is often accepted as one of the most influential political documents around the world.... Because of the profoundness of the Marxist perspective about human society and its economic functions, it tends to trace and foretell the processes of changes of human society from its penultimate stage, namely capitalism, to the final stage, socialism, a form of power of working-class people....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Recent Changes In Organisational Form And Personnel Strategies

Braverman held that work had been degraded by capitalism thus turned into mere labor.... Differences between the connotations of the words "labor" and "work' suggest the reorienting effect that Braverman's formulation had on views regarding work, workers, and the workplace (Rowlinson, 2000, p....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Marxism in General Implies Analysis of Social and Political Processes

Finally, based on the debates between Alex Callinicos and Kees van der Pijl this paper will conclude if there is an inherent contradiction between the capitalist states or, as Neo-Granscianism claims, capitalist states, driven by the social forces represented by bourgeoisie elites, will come to a consensus on the common exploitation of the world-system.... The paper 'marxism in General Implies Analysis of Social and Political Processes' presents a Marxist and particularly neo-Marxist approach in IR since the 1970s look at how relations between the states and groups of states are conditioned by the existing global economic structures....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

Elite's Theory and Marxism Theory in Power and Politics

From this work, it is clear about the use of power, critics of capitalism, the artificial dichotomy between Marxists' position, and that of institutional elitists.... Marx's theory explains that capitalism is an intrinsically contradictory system, overwhelmed by class conflict.... Furthermore, as capitalism develops and the capitalists grow more powerful in influencing the state and politics the class conflict worsens.... The author of this coursework "Elite's Theory and marxism Theory in Power and Politics" describes key aspects of theories in politics....
9 Pages (2250 words) Coursework

Marxism as a Bankrupt Social Theory

Marxist theory has rightly criticized the view that the existing social arrangements serve society's general interest and has pointed out the power differentials that capitalism's class character inevitably involves.... (McIntosh, 1977, 15-23) Their insistence on such power differentials leads them to focus on the opposition of class interests under capitalism and on class struggle as the means to social change.... In doing so, however, they abstract from the complications of the struggle of the oppressed that capitalism's "dialectic of scarcity" poses....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

The Relevance of Marxism to International Relations

"The Relevance of marxism to International Relations" paper purposes to discuss the place of marxism in international relations (IR) and gives an explanation as to how Marxist theories of class divisions and labor help us to understand the globalized world.... Marx 1844It is evident that marxism has and is being considered to have a peculiar destiny within the field of social science and international relations.... It is also known that marxism has had a strong influence on various academic subjects such as sociology, history, international relations, and development studies....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Why Is Marx Considered to Be a Sociologist

Through his different theories, Marx has provided theoretical insights necessary to attract the mystification surrounding capitalism and therefore providing the vision required to mobilize people for struggle.... The paper will discuss the marxism theory in relation to the various sociological perspectives so as to create an argument that Marx is a sociologist....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Capitalism's Achievements and Triumphs

This paper ''capitalism's Achievements and Triumphs'' tells that capitalism's achievements and triumphs are deeply rooted not only in advancement but also in aggression, coercion, mistreatment, segregation, wastage as well as in warfare in both developed and developing states.... Within the class analysis of Australia and other parts of the world, capitalism has always been able to rise above its permanent inconsistency, although not without worsening the aggression with which they have been associated with and resolve to be practiced by subsequent generations (Rowse, 1978)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us