StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Maimonides and an Eternal Universe - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The writer of this essay thinks that there are many theories that have been competing about the ultimate fate of the universe. For example, the scientist shows that the universe has been governed by the same physical laws and constraints throughout the history…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.9% of users find it useful
Maimonides and an Eternal Universe
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Maimonides and an Eternal Universe"

Maimonides and an Eternal Universe The Universe is the totality of existence which includes the contents of intergalactic space, stars, planets, all matter and energy. The observation by the scientist shows that the universe has been governed by the same physical laws and constraints throughout the history. It is evident that there are many theories that have been competing about the ultimate fate of the universe. Having said that, I want to persuade Moses Maimonides in this essay that he need not to object to the claim that the universe is internal and have a different point of view. It is apparent that over the years Maimonides thoughts about the origin of the world have led to much discussion. Maimonides believes in creation ex nihilo, this is the biblical view that leaves the creator with complete power to create anything at the time of his choice. He also goes ahead to prove that a well understood religion and science are not odds with each other. The problem in this view of the scripture respectability in the eyes of the religious is that there is a scripture presumption. For the clarity it is evident that Maimonides revises the literal meaning of the scripture when it is incoherent. God is one and incorporeal, thus particular scriptural texts need to be reinterpreted to align with this view (Hyman, 19). By following the Biblical, Aristotelian and Neo-Platonism Maimonides expresses God as absolutely necessary and completely uncaused unity. Due to this Maimonides follows the Neo-Platonist tradition of envisioning God as the purest of all beings. This means that it is a being that transcends any other divisions. It is evident that this sense of unity has accounted for the Maimonides strong negative theology. Also as God is a subject about whom we cannot predict of it then portrays that he transcends the normal parameters of language and conceptualization. (Hyman, 20-23). When Maimonides says that the world is created ex nihilo, some theological-political readings answers negative because of the presumptions about the philosophical of the scripture. It is apparent that according to the theological-political reading Maimonides may be suppressing his real view because he is not reinterpreting the biblical scripture. He believes that there is no proof for the Aristotelian that is available thus creation is a live option. This tends to be an inference best explanation for holding the view of prima facie. This makes Maimonides to favor ex nihilo and therefore opposing the eternity of the world (Hyman, 28). Maimonides to one group is heretic while to another his views are a model of conventional orthodoxy. His literature was often polarized by bitter attack on the truthful of his doctrines and the equally intense defense of him as the most authentic of the Jewish teachers. It is evident that Maimonides reasoning and point of view was due to the strong faith he had in the truth and eternity of the Torah of Moses and the traditions derived from it (Fox, 8). It is apparent that at the practical level of Maimonides he attempted to purge Judaism of any incident that had accrued over the ages. It seems also that he would banish the poets from the referred optimal city, which at his view the society was constituted by Torah. This enabled him to do a lot as some of his poetry was grounded in the traditions. Though Maimonides did not think that all philosophers were prophets, he was of the opinion that all prophets are philosophers. This is because philosophy meant metaphysics and natural science. The impact of this was that the impasse between the truth from Torah and the truth from philosophy could not last (Fox, 10). With time it is apparent that Torah and philosophy contradicted with one another. One of the major contradictions he faced is when Torah taught that the universe is a result of pure creation meaning that the universe was not internal. He was of the opinion of that but he can change and be of the opinion of Aristotle that the universe is eternal meaning it has no beginning and an end. At that time he argued that if Aristotle had clearly demonstrated his theory of the universe eternity, then one could have interpreted the Torah appropriately. He accepted the traditional authority only in matters of law but in matters of science however there were no authorities. But as per now I would urge Maimonides to accept the theory of the eternity of the universe as a convincing demonstration was done in the fourteenth century by Jewish natural scientist Gersonides (Fox, 13). The eternity thesis was plausible as the traditional Jewish doctrine of creation ex nihilo. This led to the advantage of sticking with the traditional view, since when it comes to change the burden of clarity is more on those who would change than on those who will remain the same. This led to him arguing that Aristotle was not teleology enough as he could not come up with a teleology for the universe. This meant that he could not find out the reason for the universe as a whole as his God was part of the universe still (Rudavsky, 67). The approach of Maimonides Christian and Islamic faith is similar to the approach to philosophy. As in the case of philosophy Islam and Christianity are true when the variations of themes are presented in Judaism but they in error when they don’t align with Judaism. He has also gone ahead and judged communities based on their relation to the theory and practice. This has made him to be viewed as the Platonist and not the consistent individual as some scholars thought him to be. It is evident the consistent treatment of Islam by Maimonides. He sees relation of Islam to Judaism as theoretical and a strict monotheism of Islam. He considers Islamic ethics and politics to be minor as to their Jews counterparts (Rudavsky, 69). His view of Christianity which he had diminished underwent a change over time. Maimonides realized that Christian theology was similar to Islamic arguments. He says that despite the errors of Muhammad and Jesus, the religions that emerged from their teachings were leading all human kind to worship one true God. This resulted to Christianity not regarded as worship of idolatry. Also it shows one can change his view of seeing things as people can see the universe as internal. In conclusion, I would urge Maimonides to accept the internal universe as at now proper clarification has been done. This was evident through the works of Jewish theologian and natural scientist Gersonides in the fourteenth century. Also, there is no any reason to resist the view of internal universe as is a way of being diverse in day today activities. Work cited Fox, M. Interpreting Maimonides: Studies in Methodology, Metaphysics, and Moral Philosophy Chicago studies in the history of Judaism.USA: University of Chicago Press, 1995. Print. Hyman, A & Ivry, L. Alfred. Maimonidean Studies, Volume 5.USA: KTAV Publishing House, Inc, 2008. Print. Rudavsky, M. T. Maimonides Volume 12 of Blackwell Great Minds. USA: John Wiley& Sons, 2009. Print Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Maimonides and an Eternal Universe Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1643873-maimonides-and-an-eternal-universe
(Maimonides and an Eternal Universe Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1643873-maimonides-and-an-eternal-universe.
“Maimonides and an Eternal Universe Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1643873-maimonides-and-an-eternal-universe.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Maimonides and an Eternal Universe

Maimonides

That event had affected the health of maimonides and he remained sick for a long time span.... “Moses Ben Maimon” is largely known to English audience as “maimonides” and Hebrew audience as “Rambam”, which is Hebrew acronym for “Rabbi Moshe Ben Maimon” and in Arabic Literature known as “Abu Imran Musa ben MaimunIbnAbd Allah” (Jacobs &Broyde).... … This essay will purely focus on the personality “maimonides”.... esides maimonides, Cordova was also the birthplace of Avveros (Davidson 7-9)....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Paper

Internal and External Threats

The impact has been more towards the positive side with improved efficiency and increased output.... One sector in the United States… The health sector is now attaining progress in the field of information technology and many health organizations have started EXTERNAL AND INTERNAL THREATS INSTITUTE EXTERNAL AND INTERNAL THREATS With the advancement in technology and the invention of computers, the working and functioning of organizations and industries has widely changed....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Internal and External Forces: Volcanoes and Earthquakes

The author describes the forces of nature that shape the landmarks on the earth's surface: external forces and internal forces.... The mechanism of their action is quite different from each other, and both have played a part in the formation of the features of the earth as are known today.... nbsp; … On the other hand, earthquakes are relatively harder to predict (Earthquakes and Volcanoes), since the seismic activity, in this case, is not fixed, and no pattern is followed (Earthquakes and Volcanoes)....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment

Human resources internal and external recruitment

Internal recruitment is employing persons from inside the organization to acquire the vacancies left in an organization.... Conversely, external… This unit describes the inner and outside recruitment and identifies their significance in an organization (Byrnes, 2009). The internal recruitment needs support from other management departments to Internal and External Recruitment Task Introduction Recruitment is a process of choosing the best applicant in a group from inside or outside a business organization for a job vacancy....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Key Religious Beliefs of Judaism

Explain the key religious beliefs of Judaism, and how the Diaspora cast Jews in socio-religious seclusion and persecution amidst their host Christian and Muslim countries throughout the centuries ending with the Holocaust. In Judaism, it is primarily believed that there exists… ne and only one God who created the entire universe with everything in it and established the essence of personal relationship or covenant with men – the highest order of God's creation (Jewish Beliefs)....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Internal and External Pay Equity

If the employer matches the pay with the other labor market, the pay equity is known external.... This paper will analyze the importance of managing both internal and… Comparing the wages among the industry enables the standardization of wages to ensure no employee is overpaid or under paid....
1 Pages (250 words) Research Paper

Internal vs. External Validity in Research

In the paper “Internal vs.... External Validity in Research” the author analyzes a tradeoff between internal and external validity.... He also examines a benefit in achieving a high level of one type of validity (internal versus external) over the other.... … The author states that internal validity refers to the certainty that a research presents true results of the relationship between the dependent and the independent variable in the study....
2 Pages (500 words) Coursework

Earth-Centered Universe and Sun-Centered Universe

… The paper "Earth-centered universe and Sun-centered universe" is an outstanding example of an essay on astronomy.... The geocentric of the earth-centered model of the universe was the initial theory about the universe proposed by Aristotle and Ptolemy.... According to this model, the earth was at the center of the universe while the sun, moon and the planets revolved around it in a concentric motion....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us