StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Theory That People Are Intuitive Scientists - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Theory That People Are Intuitive Scientists" criticizes the theory that “People are intuitive scientists, constructing logical and rational theories to make sense of their environment.” Although some social psychologists have theorized that this is so, scientific data says otherwise…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.9% of users find it useful
Theory That People Are Intuitive Scientists
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Theory That People Are Intuitive Scientists"

It is true that people look for causes, both internal and external and that it is true that the more we believe that the causes are internal, the more we think that they are not external. Nevertheless, considering the fact that people have a tendency to show cognitive or motivational bias, then there is therefore the general tendency for people to make mistakes when determining not only whether the cause is internal or external but also when determining the actual cause (Buchanan et al. 2013). Just like Heider’s theory, Kelley also assumes the rationality of man but it falls short because of the biases inherent in him.

Kelley also has a point when he proposes that generally people systematically assess a situation and its cause using three variables: “consistency, distinctiveness and consensus” (Buchanan et al. 2013). . 2013). For example, based on Kelley’s theory, where a person asks himself whether other people would do the same in the following situation, an optimistic person would normally think that almost all people would help a wounded person in the street, yet this might actually be far from reality.

In the same way, a person with a pronounced judgemental bias and tendency towards availability heuristic would rather think that there are more examples of people in the past or in his past experience who did not help those who were wounded for fear of getting themselves involved in whatever it is that is happening. Thus, one’s biased perceptions would naturally interfere with one’s rationalization, and there seems to be no way to be completely rationally objective about any situation. 2.

2 Arguments Against the Theory One argument against the idea that people are indeed intuitive scientists and that they use logic and reason to make sense of their social environment is the fact that people are naturally biased in their assessment of situations. The experiments presented in Chapter 7 of the book somehow all prove that the claim under investigation is indeed far from true. The vignettes used in experiments of social psychology, for example, have a very clear disadvantage: “Reading a vignette in the laboratory is clearly quite different from observing an event or behavior in the course of everyday life” (Buchanan et al. 2013). This means that social psychologists like Heider and Kelley cannot possibly conclude that a person is rational and logical in his search for the cause of an event because what he is like in the laboratory is entirely different from what he is like outside in the real world.

He may be rational and logical in the laboratory but entirely the opposite outside.
Moreover, based on the study by Storms in 1973, “Actors tended to favor situational explanations of their behavior, whereas observers tended to favor dispositional explanations of the same behavior,” which then naturally translates as strong scientific evidence for FAE (Buchanan et al. 2013). Moreover, in the study by Lau and Russell in 1980, they found out that “there was a greater tendency to attribute wins to internal factors than to external factors” (Buchanan et al. 2013). This means that instead of rationally and logically determining the cause of a win or loss, an ordinary person tends to be biased. This also means that basically and even in controlled laboratory conditions, human subjects tend to commit the FAE in determining the cause of an event. This is indeed far from being rational and logical.

Lastly, the optimistic bias would naturally interfere with the way one perceives something. In the study by Taylor et al. in 1992, where beliefs of men regarding AIDS were examined, those who were HIV positive were more optimistic about not developing the disease than those who were HIV negative. Thus, people’s perception of HIV, which is normally supposed to be pessimistic or negative, tends to vary depending on one’s situation in the context of the disease. This is indeed far from being irrational.

3.0 CONCLUSION
People are not intuitive scientists, and they do not construct logical and rational theories to make sense of their environment. Although the theories of Heider and Kelley are somehow plausible and may be demonstrated by a number of people, the overwhelming amount of scientific data says otherwise. This means that people generally tend to have biases in their judgments of events and in their search for the cause of these events. Social psychologists may be able to account for rationality and logic inside the laboratory but reality may be entirely different from this. Moreover, committing the FAE and the optimistic bias are backed by scientific evidence.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“People are intuative scientists, constructing logial and rational Essay”, n.d.)
People are intuative scientists, constructing logial and rational Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/psychology/1468249-people-are-intuative-scientists-constructing
(People Are Intuative Scientists, Constructing Logial and Rational Essay)
People Are Intuative Scientists, Constructing Logial and Rational Essay. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1468249-people-are-intuative-scientists-constructing.
“People Are Intuative Scientists, Constructing Logial and Rational Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1468249-people-are-intuative-scientists-constructing.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Theory That People Are Intuitive Scientists

Compare how Interpretivist and Behavioralist Political Scientists Approach the Analysis of Politics

Thus understanding different philosophies and methodologies is of prime importance in order to compare how political scientists approach the analysis of politics.... In this connection interpretivist or behavioralist political scientists are two important analyst groups.... Depending upon various philosophies and methodology these scientists may analyze same situation differently.... Political scientists are no exception to this subjectivity and interpretivist or behavioralist scientists may deduce mutually conflicting conclusions while contemplating a specific situation or scenario....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Demystifying Intuition: What it is, What it does, and How it does it

Whether this is generally true or not, highly intelligent people are not exempt from the distorting influence of their experiential/intuitive system on their reasoning, as demonstrated in the following quotation from the German physicist and Nobel laureate Philip Lenard in his book German Physics: Jewish physics can best and most justly be characterized by recalling the activity of one who is probably its most prominent representative, the pure-blooded Jew, Albert Einstein.... Thus most people are willing to respond slightly nonoptimally in favor of frequency information, but most are not willing to make frequency-advantaged responses that are more nonoptimal....
65 Pages (16250 words) Research Paper

Philosophy of Science, Problem of Induction

scientists need to identify some of the risks involved in using induction and specifically the risks involved in using induction reasoning to come up with scientific principles as well as specific scientific judgments.... Thus, the problem of induction is a problem confronted by scientists and philosophers concerned with science, but more specifically it is a problem for scientific method....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Intuitive Scientists in the Social Environment

From the discussion in this essay, it may be concluded that people act as intuitive scientists in the social environment.... Studying this issue, social scientists have suggested that people act as 'intuitive scientists' when in a social environment (Heider & Simmel, 1944).... Self-serving bias is the tendency for people to claim their successes and ignore or downplay their failures, often with the effect that they become less able to adapt to different situations and social dynamics....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Philosophy of Science: Problem of Induction

Since centuries, suppositions have remained an imperative part of human lives, and it is an observation that humans, especially scientists have been successful in achieving the impossible based on their inductive inferences that indicate the significant contribution of.... In specific, Such arguments have now resulted in the creation of a philosophical problem, the problem of induction that stands disputed, especially in case of the scientists that are in continuation of using this technique of considering limited number of instances to derive a universal formula....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

When Should We Discard Explanations That Are Intuitively Appealing

They will consciously examine him/her ruling out the intuitive factor.... For instance, if people were shown short clips of teachers in a class, it is likely that their evaluations would be somewhat similar, based on their intuition, to those of the teacher's actual students....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Philosophy of Nursing

They were termed as “wise women” by the people.... The philosophy of nursing is concerned with our beliefs and perspective regarding the nature of the profession, and it is based on this philosophy that we perform our nursing duties.... The subject of nursing is both an art and a science....
8 Pages (2000 words) Coursework

Conceptual Processes Of The Phenomena Intuitive Intelligence

Before our research is concluded, our main findings are that people do have an understanding of intuitive effects, and to recognize the actuality of effect.... Few scientists have formally intellectualized intuitive intelligence.... This study takes intuitively-based intelligence, in its broadest essence and transforms its understanding of assessment into intuitive effects, a process used to improve performance and risk value.... This research examines the broader concept of intuitive intelligence and the cognitive psychological constructs of intuitive effect by means of literature review and a qualitative study....
8 Pages (2000 words) Article
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us