StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Relativism and Morality - Research Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
Relativism and Morality BY YOU YOUR SCHOOL INFO HERE DATE HERE Relativism and Morality Goodman’s viewpoint that there are certain universal principles which are consistently wrong is somewhat flawed. Goodman (2010) highlights that rape, terrorism and murder (as three examples) should be considered wrongs within a global context…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.4% of users find it useful
Relativism and Morality
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Relativism and Morality"

Relativism and Morality BY YOU YOUR SCHOOL INFO HERE HERE Relativism and Morality Goodman’s viewpoint that there are certain universal principles which are consistently wrong is somewhat flawed. Goodman (2010) highlights that rape, terrorism and murder (as three examples) should be considered wrongs within a global context. Murder, as Goodman identifies, is a wrong due to the fact that it violates the inherent rights of the individual. In essence, it destroys the individual and therefore cannot be debated since the victim is unable to engage in future philosophical arguments about right versus wrong.

Rape, as yet another example, is a violation of the victim’s personal will and also exploits the victim (Goodman, 2010). However, Goodman is attempting to impose a set of universalist values which are not always going to be embraced by different cultures. In Africa, as one example, rape is a common practice engaged with members of the military and within the family dynamic. When the individual that has been the victim of rape becomes accustomed to this lifestyle, without proper guidance about the morality and ethics of the act, they are simply not educated that rape within the family unit is not acceptable in most cultures.

Therefore, without having a moral center within the African culture or government (or in education), whether the act of rape is wrong is completely relative. Mosser (2010) would likely defend the aforementioned argument, as he clearly indicates that the acceptability of moral versus amoral acts are directly linked to one’s culture, religion, worldview and even one’s personal set of values. Using, again, the aforesaid example of rape within the African family dynamic, if the local culture considers these acts to be moral and ethical, it would simply be one (or a handful) of individuals that would attempt to challenge the moral and ethical principles of rape.

It would seem, however, that Goodman is attempting to illustrate that it would be the majority within society that would be the proverbial gatekeepers of morality and ethics, thus being the dominant force in determining the moral and ethical acceptability of such issues such as rape, murder and even terrorism. However, society should consider that history often determines whether a group or individual should be considered a terrorist. For instance, there could be many British individuals that considered the war that occurred during American independence were all terrorists, as they defied the majority rule of the British empire during the time period.

However, American history has painted the individuals that founded the United States as heroes that were simply defending the needs, wants and values of the American citizens during the Revolutionary War. Now, using the argument of the Revolutionary War as the primary example, Mosser is given support for the relativist view of morality and ethics. As he argues that relativism is related to one’s personal values, culture, and even religion, he would likely ponder the American Revolution, using the worldview as an example, to recognize that not everyone in global culture views the founders of the American society as heroes and saviors.

Instead, Mosser would likely engage in debates that recognize that morality and ethics are largely individual and cannot be justified by any one set of moral and ethical contracts. All situations that are questionable as it relates to morality and ethics illustrate that there are not simply some scenarios and human actions that are wrong and cannot be debated since they are massive violations of the individual will and generic human rights. When a tyrannical government is overthrown, thus liberating society from oppression or domination, it takes a group of individuals (whether private citizens or militaristic) to provide the tools or support necessary to achieve the goal of said liberation.

Today’s global culture, such as those supported by such organizations as the United Nations, tend to attempt to impose a universalist approach to guiding and critiquing ethical and moral behaviors. These organizations, and several others in global culture, have much support from society and global governments which seems to add more clout to the basic and generic human rights issues. It would be the majority, in such a case, that would dictate the acceptability and moral responsibility of certain human actions that should be considered to be immoral or unethical.

However, if certain cultures began to reject this doctrine that rape, terrorism and murder are always wrong, it is likely that a more relativist viewpoint would be embraced, thus changing the dynamics of majority rule when it comes to determining whether certain situations are unethical or immoral. Having offered all of the aforesaid arguments, Goodman is not correct in stating that there are always going to be certain human actions that should absolutely be considered wrong. There cannot be a singular set of universal principles and social contracts that should guide global society.

There is simply too much diversity in cultures, when taking a global viewpoint, to attempt to impose a singular, universalist set of values and ethical contracts. Eventually, these doctrines will be rejected by those who demand change, thus Goodman is really, after assessing the viability of his argument, simply using his own opinion which is absolutely not going to be shared by everyone in global society. References Goodman, Lenn E. (2010). Some Moral Minima, The Good Society, 19(1), pp.87-94.

Mosser, Kurt. (2010). Ethics and Social Responsibility. Pearson.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Relativism and Morality Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words - 2”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/sociology/1489552-relativism-and-morality
(Relativism and Morality Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words - 2)
https://studentshare.org/sociology/1489552-relativism-and-morality.
“Relativism and Morality Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words - 2”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1489552-relativism-and-morality.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Relativism and Morality

A discussion between two characters--about moral relativism

Cultural values define morality and moral claims and these claims will therefore be different from one society to another.... Jenifer: A relativist may however be particular to situation and therefore specific on morality in an act.... ifferent ethical theories exist to explain people's behaviours … A discussion between two characters- About moral relativism Ethics, a set of rules in a society that regulates people's behaviour by defining wrongs and rights in a society, is a fundamental aspect of people's behaviour....
2 Pages (500 words) Research Paper

Aesthetic relativism versus aesthetic objectivism

Objectivists blame relativist of being subjectivists that look for ethical negativism by claiming that morality is up to the individualism; relativist blame objectivists of being absolutists of whom believe that all queries have a single right answer, regardless of culture or context.... That being said we can say that morality is determined on an individual level and not at a social or even universal level.... While objectivism was against beauty, the judgment of beauty in the eighteenth century idea of taste was to be immediate, against self-absorption of virtue and held the desire of beauty to be disinterested (“relativism vs....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Moral relativism and Moral absolutism

From this perception, the ethical disagreements demonstrate that the issue of morality is just but a product of our personal opinions or our different cultures.... The theory suggests that moral relativism comes in two forms which are the cultural relativism along with the ethical subjectivism.... The… On the other hand, the issue of cultural relativism suggests that morals have relations to different cultures.... The two forms of moral relativism refute The concept of moral relativism stipulates that there is no sense in asking abstract questions concerning whether an act is either good or its bad....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Debate on Relativism and the Absolute Truth

This essay Debate on relativism and the Absolute Truthtalks that people tend to run after the fall of an idea by subjecting the idea to numerous criticisms.... … According to the report relativism is a perception, which posits that moral values or the conception of truth are not absolute but are subject to acceptance depending with the view of the individual.... The concept of relativism has puzzled many theologians and philosophers with respect to the Christian views....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

Ethics and Relativism

Famine, affluence, and morality.... In a couple… In an argument by Mosser (2010), emerging trends and social life is the cause of insensitivity when it comes to morality. However, relativists can support abortion if the issue is connected to other Ethics and relativism affiliation Ethics and relativism The moral issue in this paper is whether or not to have an abortion.... In a couple of years ago, abortion was a heavy sensitized issue on society's morality....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment

The Relativity of Cultural Normality

The paper 'The Relativity of Cultural Normality' focuses on cultural normality which is a relative concept that encompasses all the different features of different cultures around the world.... The relativity of cultural normality is central to its interpretation and application.... hellip; Tea drinking may be a definitive feature of Japanese culture but not China's....
5 Pages (1250 words) Term Paper

Morality and the Culture People

In the paper “morality and the Culture People” the author analyzes the existence of moral absolutes, and the statement that moral truths can be universal.... morality that is relative to culture has liberal implications for ethics, and as result it is a very significant topic, and the opinion on moral cultural relativism is virtually important.... Proponents of this argument normally point out that different cultures are built on different moral beliefs, and that morality is just a result of specific culture....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Cultural Relativism

In the video summary of James Rachel, he explains the elements of moral philosophy by first defining the meaning of morality.... Cultural relativism is generally the attitude of society's mores and ideas that is viewed within the framework of society's problem and opportunity.... To him, he views the cultural relativity as an attitude of objectivity towards another culture. The major believes of the cultural relativism is not a single doctrine but Cultural relativism Cultural relativism is generally the attitude of society's mores and ideas that is viewed within the framework of society's problem and opportunity....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us